apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Is This the Easiest Cake Ever?

2009_02_26-easiestcake.jpgLast week, we spotted something called a Nantucket Cranberry Pie over at the blog Cooking Books. It's a recipe from Laurie Colwin, and it involves so few ingredients and so little effort, we had to make it immediately. Yes, we know those don't look like cranberries. Bear with us...

 
 

There were no cranberries to be found at the grocery store (nope, not even frozen), so we went with a mixture of frozen cherries and blueberries.

It's funny that this is called a pie, because it is definitely not. It's more like a cobbler, really. The flavors are similar to those in Faith's Cranberry Cake, but with this recipe, you don't even have to use a mixer.

Here's what you do: Sprinkle walnuts and cranberries (or defrosted and well-drained cherries and blueberries) into a round cake pan. Toss on some sugar (we reduced the amount, since we were working with sweeter fruit than cranberries). Stir together a quick batter (with melted butter- no softening!) and pour it over the nuts and berries. Then throw the pan in the oven.

This is our new favorite discovery. It has a hint of almond flavor, which is lovely, and it is so absurdly easy we're almost embarrassed. We nominate it for "Most Likely to Serve as Last-Minute Dessert for Unexpected Guests" or "Easiest Dessert for a Busy Weeknight." Either one. You pick.

Get the recipe: Nantucket Cranberry Pie, from Laurie Colwin's More Home Cooking, via Andrea at Cooking Books.

Related: Recipe: Cranberry Tart

(Image: Elizabeth Passarella)

Comments (15)

Did you grease the pan or line with parchment -- or is that not necessary?

posted by Julie on February 27th 2009 at 5:00pm
view Julie's profile

Julie: I did not do anything the first time I made it, and it came out fine. Second time, I sprayed it quickly with Pam and it came out slightly easier, but no big difference.

posted by Elizabeth P on February 27th 2009 at 5:03pm
view Elizabeth P's profile

Yummy. We've made Nantucket Pie for for the last few years with wild cranberries picked at a Secret Location, on Boston's North shore. It's a special treat we look forward to every Fall.

posted by Dulcibella on February 27th 2009 at 6:54pm
view Dulcibella's profile

isn't this kind of cake a buckle? i love this - simple and delicious and easy to make.

posted by Joan in SB on February 27th 2009 at 7:25pm
view Joan in SB's profile

Sounds very easy indeed, it reminds me of clafoutis, a french cake very popular, often done with cherries :)

posted by Christelle on February 27th 2009 at 8:52pm
view Christelle's profile

Looks dangerous. I'd eat all myself.

posted by Icanmakeit on February 27th 2009 at 10:32pm
view Icanmakeit's profile

Is it really desserty or more breakfasty? It kind of looks breakfasty to me with the blueberries.

vw
http://www.margincomments.blogspot.com

posted by VirginiaWestfield on February 27th 2009 at 11:45pm
view VirginiaWestfield's profile

My family has been making this "pie" for years and years. It's always been a Thanksgiving favorite since that's when it's easiest to find fresh cranberries. I'm so glad you've shared it here and given me new ideas about ways to modify it for any season.

posted by ebenko on February 28th 2009 at 12:28am
view ebenko's profile

Does it all blend together in cooking? It seems like just pouring the fruit and sugar in first would give you a chunky layer of just sugar and fruit, with the batter baking on top.

awapplesauce.etsy.com

posted by Damfino on February 28th 2009 at 9:51am
view Damfino's profile

Damfino - I just made it today (with cranberries and almonds and a scant cup of sugar total) and there were two pretty distinguishable layers going on in my cake. I also made it in a springform pan, which I think was a mistake as it was a *very* leaky cake and a lot of the cranberry juices seeped through and burnt on the bottom of my oven. That was my fault of course.

I thought it would be more cake-like, but I don't really know if it should be considered such. Mine was pretty dense (there are no leaveners at all) and seemed more like a griddle cake than a more traditional cake. (But now perhaps I'm splitting hairs?)

In terms of flavor, it's DELICIOUS. I had a piece, then another, and then another sliver. Then I portioned it out, stuck some in the fridge and gave some to some friends so it wasn't readily available for munching. The almond flavor of the dough is just divine and it goes with the tart of the cranberries very nicely. I'm already looking forward to breakfast tomorrow morning!

posted by laetitiae on March 1st 2009 at 12:18am
view laetitiae's profile

I made this yesterday with 1 cup fresh blueberries and 1 cup frozen raspberries. Overall I liked it very much and will make it again. The cake batter settles around the fruit and the juice from the berries works it way up to the top so you have splotches of berry all over.

I like almond, but found 1 tsp to be too much for this combo. Next time I will reduce to 1/2 tsp.

The cake had a very fine crumb and was very moist. I would like something more biscuit/cobbler like and may experiment to see what I can do in this regard. But this was very easy and very good. Worthy trying.

posted by klem on March 1st 2009 at 3:43pm
view klem's profile

I made it this weekend with blackberries and raspberries, using a cast iron skillet and less sugar. This recipe is delicious. I can't wait to try variations.

posted by jakesprincess on March 2nd 2009 at 12:29pm
view jakesprincess's profile

I made this last night with the exact recipe but swapped out blueberries for the cranberries. It was tasty, but overly sweet and a little greasy from all the butter. My husband thought it was divine. Tonight I tried it again, but used fewer blueberries, half the sugar, and half the butter. I substituted buttermilk for the rest of the butter and also added the juice of a lemon to the berries. It was great! I love the blueberry lemon combination and the buttermilk really cut the sweetness. It still tasted like a dessert and a confusing combination of cobbler and cake.

posted by sar3j on March 2nd 2009 at 10:26pm
view sar3j's profile

sar3j or Elizabeth P: I also found this tasty but too sweet. Do you suggest half the sugar for *both" the batter and the fruit mix? I was a bit worried that cutting the sugar in the batter would mess with consistency ...

posted by rebelle on March 4th 2009 at 6:40pm
view rebelle's profile

I cut the sugar in half for the batter and the berries. I still think it was sweet and very good.

posted by sar3j on March 19th 2009 at 7:40pm
view sar3j's profile