apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Recipe: D.I.Y. Butter

2007_03_26-HomemadeButter.jpgHomemade butter is an easy treat worth trying at least once. It's lighter and fresher, free of the preservatives and artificial coloring present in much commercial butter. It's also easier to flavor with just enough salt. We like to add a bit of sour cream; this gives it a pleasant tang similar to cultured butters.

Making butter now involves quite a bit less work than it did in olden days; a few minutes in the food processor replace hours of churning. But if you would like a workout (or an afternoon of activity for small and enthusiastic children) put the cream in a tightly sealed Mason jar and shake away.

 
 

D.I.Y. Butter
about 1/2 cup
1 cup heavy whipping cream
1 tablespoon sour cream
1/8 teaspoon salt (optional)

Whir the cream and sour cream in a food processor for about five minutes. (Alternately: shake energetically in a Mason jar for about 15-30 minutes.) After the cream becomes thick and clotted like whipped cream it will suddenly start spattering against the top again as it clumps into yellow butter. Whip until the butter has formed a solid yet grainy mass.

Put a small mesh strainer over a bowl and pour everything into it. Refrigerate the liquid; this is buttermilk and it will last for several days. Use it for pancakes, or Pecan Cake, or Meatballs with Buttermilk Gravy.

Put the butter in a small bowl and rinse under very cold water until the water runs clear. You want every bit of the buttermilk removed; any left clinging to the butter will cause it to get sour and bad overnight.

When the water runs completely clear squeeze the butter inside a clean paper towel or cheesecloth until dry, then turn out into a crock or small bowl. Mash in the salt, if using. Refrigerate and use within a week.

Tags

D.I.Y. Recipe

Related Links

Share

Comments (15)

How fun! I remember making butter in kindergarten in a mason jar.

posted by rachel on March 26th 2007 at 6:07am
view rachel's profile

Oh this is going to be FUN!!!

posted by Keisha Kornbread on March 26th 2007 at 7:18am
view Keisha Kornbread's profile

Faith, this sounds both interesting and easy. I think, tho, that photos/video would make this one soo much better. (Place the butter in a bowl and run water under cold water? I envision disaster!). Any chance of you guys adding slide shows similar to the city pages on the site?

posted by Martybird on March 26th 2007 at 7:39am
view Martybird's profile

That step stopped me too, Marty. I'm guessing you remove the mesh strainer, with the collected butter, from the bowl o' buttermilk. Then, you put that strainer under the tap to rinse out the remaining buttermilk.

posted by verily on March 26th 2007 at 7:46am
view verily's profile

Hmm. OK, so web links are doing strange things too.

posted by faith on March 26th 2007 at 8:28am
view faith's profile

Made herbed cheese butter this weekend using an electric mixer.

1 cup whipping cream
grated cheese rinds (from whole foods, very cheap), grated using smallest size
gradually folded grated cheese into whipping cream as it was becoming firm.
Added dried basil, dill, salt, garlic, etc.

Turned out very good

posted by josie on March 26th 2007 at 10:56am
view josie's profile

this might be a stupid question -- but how would you make "whipped butter"? after you mash in the salt, put it back in the processor for some extra time and air?

posted by megfitz on March 26th 2007 at 11:23am
view megfitz's profile

Careful! You are confusing cultured buttermilk and natural or "churn" buttermilk. These are definitely NOT the same product and the buttermilk here cannot be used in the recipes you note because it is not acidic.

posted by Andy M. on March 26th 2007 at 5:22pm
view Andy M.'s profile

I made this last night and don't see why I should buy butter when this tastes so much better and costs a fraction of the store bought. Rinsing off the buttermilk was more like kneading dough under running water and wasn't a problem. Thanks for both the recipe and the link to Cooking for Engineers and I urge everyone to try this at home!

posted by Martybird on March 28th 2007 at 4:50am
view Martybird's profile

Andy M., the addition of sour cream makes me think that this is indeed a recipe for cultured butter/true buttermilk.

Here is a great recipe with detailed pictures for making cultured butter and real buttermilk. The author uses yogurt which is not too unlike sour cream.

http://blog.cooklikeyourgrandmother.com/2008/06/how-to-make-cultured-butter-and.html

posted by pedalpowered on January 12th 2009 at 12:55pm
view pedalpowered's profile

I made this butter, but instead of sour cream, I used yogurt. I think the yogurt made it lighter than sour cream, because when I poured cold water on the butter it sort of ruined it. It tasted so good before I poured the water on it though! I'm hoping the water and oil separate and I can pour it out so it tastes good again.

posted by andrennabird on February 16th 2009 at 6:16pm
view andrennabird's profile

what does the sour cream add? i made this recipe and it was delicious, just wondering what the difference is between plain cream vs. cream and sour cream.

posted by kelly c on February 18th 2009 at 9:20pm
view kelly c's profile

Andrennabird -- After you rinse it, you have to knead it until all the water is out. There are special butter paddles for this, but you can use your hands too. You'll know it's done when it starts to "sweat" and the texture becomes smooth.

posted by Minerva of the Airship on February 24th 2009 at 3:19am
view Minerva of the Airship's profile

My mother used to work at a "historic village museum" where she had to make butter in the old fashioned method of the 1850s- hard work.

posted by bkk on April 7th 2009 at 7:11am
view bkk's profile

bkk - in williamsburg, va?

posted by m! on October 8th 2009 at 10:10pm
view m!'s profile