Spice Up a Boring Sandwich: 7 Ideas for Flavored Mayonnaise

We support our readers with carefully chosen product recommendations to improve life at home. You support us through our independently chosen links, many of which earn us a commission.
(Image credit: Apartment Therapy)

Admit it: Part of the charm of buying your lunch is eating a fancy sandwich. Sure, you know you could make it at home, but when it comes down to it, time is short and it just seems easier to fork over a small handful of cash at that adorable gourmet deli near work.

Homemade mayo is a whole other story (a very delicious story!), but even a store bought jar combined with the right ingredients can do wonders to spice up that sorry excuse for a turkey sandwich thrown together in the morning.

Work ahead and keep a tub of flavored mayo in the fridge for use all week. It’s best to keep the quantities small – think of how much you might need for a few days of sandwiches, for example, and adjust the mix-ins appropriately. What we’ve found though is that a zippy mayo in the fridge often finds its way onto all sorts of other things beyond sandwiches, like roasted potatoes. The options are endless!

Here are 7 ideas for flavored mayo mix-ins:

Herbs: An obvious favorite — dill, basil, and tarragon are all great. For an extra something-something, squeeze in a bit of lemon or lime.

Chili Sauce: Sriracha is a main staple, but we’ve had luck with sambal oelek, or my favorite: gochujang, a sweet and spicy fermented Korean chili paste.

Sesame Oil: A little goes a long way. Toss in a few sesame seeds for a sauce that takes roasted vegetables on a baguette to a whole new level.

Blue Cheese: Ever foolishly tried to get blue cheese to stay on a sandwich? Blend it into mayo.

Roasted Garlic: Another classic. Roast up a few cloves of garlic to mash into mayo.

Raid the Spice Drawer: Curry, herbs de provence, smoked paprika, or even coarsely ground pepper are all great.

Maple Syrup: Ok, hear this one out. Almost equal parts mayo and maple syrup, plus a slug of apple cider vinegar.

What are your favorite sauces to spice up a sandwich – mayo or non-mayo?

(Image: pepmiba/Shutterstock)