Recipe Review: Turkey Gravy from Scratch

(Image credit: Elizabeth Passarella)

Well, the gravy is finished. We decided to make ours over the weekend rather than wait to see what kind of pan drippings we got from the turkey or risk not having any at all. So we used a recipe from The New York Times that we wrote about last week. Click below to find out how it went…

We halved the recipe to get six cups instead of three quarts, but we didn’t end up with six cups. This is how much we got:

(Image credit: Apartment Therapy)

All in all, about three and a half cups. Which should be fine for our family, but it was quite a lot of work and a whole lot of mess for less than four cups of gravy.

The actual gravy making was the least time consuming part. We first roasted turkey legs and wings which we then boiled to make homemade turkey stock. It wasn’t complicated, but it did take time, and we think we simmered our stock too long, ending up with less liquid than the recipe called for.

Also, we were supposed to deglaze the roasting pan and add that liquid to the simmering stock. But once we put the turkey in our stock pot, we left to run some errands, so by the time we remembered about the deglazing, our stock was finished. No problem. We just deglazed and added the liquid to the finished stock. (This is getting complicated, but we were supposed to cool the deglazing liquid and skim off the fat before adding it to the stock, but since we were going to cool our stock and skim the fat off of it, too, why not add the deglazing liquid, fat and all, and just skim once? Maybe there’s a reason, but anyway. That’s what we did.)

We’ve never been great at skimming off fat. And we weren’t patient enough to wait for it to completely harden before getting it off, so our turkey fat that we then cooked with flour for the base of the gravy was pretty liquid. Our flour/fat mixture was thin and runny, too, even though we added more flour than the recipe called for. It did seize up as soon as we poured in the stock, but the lumps smoothed out and everything came together quickly.

It tastes pretty great, we have to say. We’re just disappointed in the yield. Bottom line: It doesn’t take much more time to make the full recipe, so if you have a big enough pot to make the stock, go for it. You could also make the stock well ahead of time and use butter for the base instead of turkey fat, which would save you a lot of messy skimming.

We support our readers with carefully chosen product recommendations to improve life at home. You support us through our independently chosen links, many of which earn us a commission.