Creamy, seasoned feta cheese tossed with Kalamata olives and green onions, wrapped in crispy layers of paper-thin phyllo? Oh, yes! These Mediterranean-inspired cigars are a really great appetizer to have in your back pocket as the holidays approach. You might even have all of the ingredients stashed away in your fridge and freezer. Get rolling!
Although working with phyllo might sound intimidating, I truly believe that with patience and the right tools, these can be made effortlessly. The key is patience, properly thawed phyllo dough, and a damp kitchen towel. If you have that down, these will be well worth it.
I did several tests with this recipe and found that a hot 400°F oven, three layers of phyllo per cigar, and a small amount of filling per cigar yields the best results. The cigars stay intact and the cheese doesn't burst through the center. I also found that buttering each phyllo layer individually was unnecessary. Brushing the top layer is sufficient; the butter drips and gets absorbed by layers underneath. Buttering all the layers individually made the cigars come out too greasy and not as crispy.
Feta & Olive Phyllo Cigars
Makes 32 cigars
thinly sliced green onions
chopped pitted kalamata olives
sprigs fresh thyme, leaves only
freshly ground black pepper
phyllo dough, thawed according to package instructions
large egg, for the egg wash
In a large bowl, combine the feta cheese and egg. Use the back of your fork to mash it into a creamy mixture. Toss in the sliced scallions, chopped kalamata olives, fresh thyme, and ground black pepper. Mix well.
Preheat the oven to 400°F. Arrange your work surface with a clean cutting board, a bowl with the melted butter, a pastry brush, the feta cheese mixture, and a baking sheet.
Roll out the thawed sheets of phyllo. Start by taking out three pieces of the phyllo dough. Cover the rest of the pile of dough with a damp kitchen towel (otherwise they will dry out and be impossible to work with). Lay them out on the cutting board and lightly brush the top layer with the melted butter. Using a sharp knife, cut the phyllo in half lengthwise and then horizontally into fourths, leaving you with eight equal-sized pieces.
Measure out 1/2 tablespoon of the feta cheese mixture and evenly spread onto the bottom half of one of the phyllo pieces. Carefully roll the phyllo into a tight, thin cigar. Place the cigar seam-side-down onto the baking sheet. Repeat with the cut phyllo pieces, and then again with the remaining feta cheese mixture and sheets of phyllo dough.
Brush the tops of the cigars with egg wash and bake for 20 to 25 minutes, or until golden brown and crispy. Serve warm.