Recipe Review

Orange-Scented Olive Oil Cake from Saveur

We independently select these products—if you buy from one of our links, we may earn a commission. All prices were accurate at the time of publishing.
Post Image
(Image credit: Apartment Therapy)

World, meet my new favorite cake. It’s damp and soaked with musky orange syrup, with a tender, springy crumb and a whiff of olive oil. It has shot to the top of my baking go-to list, too, with its easy yet very unusual preparation.

(Image credit: Apartment Therapy)

This recipe comes from Saveur‘s current issue, #129. It is an adapted recipe from The Perfect Finish by Bill Yosses and Melissa Clark. I was drawn to it because, first of all, it is citrus-flavored (my favorite) and also includes olive oil (like my husband’s all-time favorite cake/food). It also has something in common with an old favorite, Nigella Lawson’s clementine cake: The oranges are boiled, and then whizzed, peels and all, into the cake batter. I was intrigued by this cross between two favorites.

The recipe started off, though, with some grumbling on my part. It directs you to boil two quartered oranges not once, but three — no, four — times. You bring the oranges to the boil, drain them, then repeat twice. This presumably draws off the bitterness in the peels. It wasn’t so much of an inconvenience, though, I realized. After that the oranges simmer in a sugar syrup for about 45 minutes until they are tender.

After that the cake is a snap. You whiz the oranges with flour, sugar, and baking soda, and a few other things in the food processor (or, in my case, the blender). The only oil or fat (other than the eggs) comes from 6 tablespoons of olive oil. But this doesn’t mean that the cake is dry. Oh no — it turns out delightfully damp and springy, with all the dark flavor latent in oranges.

I did change a couple things. The recipe doesn’t call for salt in the batter; I added a pinch or two. I also skipped the extra glaze of fresh orange juice and powdered sugar that the recipe calls for. It seemed criminal to waste the delicious and more sophisticated orange syrup left over from simmering the oranges. So I poked holes in the cake after it came out of the oven and poured this over. I am sure it would be a bit brighter with the glaze, and I will try it next time, but this was just delicious, too.

Overall, this is one you have just got to try. It also holds beautifully; we’ve been sneaking slivers off for breakfast and snacks the last several days, and it’s just as moist and tender as it was the day it was made.

Get the recipe: Orange-Scented Olive Oil Cake at Saveur

(Images: Faith Durand)