I Traded My Single-Serve Coffee Maker for This “Perfect” Machine, and I’m Never Going Back (Bonus: It’s 33% Off!)
As much as I’d love to call myself a consistent coffee drinker, that’s never been the case. I typically wake up, have a glass of water, and then decide on my breakfast right then and there. My drink almost always comes down to how much effort I want to put into it. If I wanted tea, I’d heat up the stovetop kettle, and if I wanted coffee, all I had to do was drop a coffee pod into the Keurig — unless I wanted a flavor that I only had on hand in a bag. And when the pods ran out between store runs, tea was the clear winner.
Because coffee and tea are so interchangeable in my household, I’m always open to checking out any products that make preparation easy, quick, and convenient. But I never thought to look into a countertop brewer that could do both. Then, I was introduced to the Mr. Coffee Perfect Brew.
A Quick Look at the Mr. Coffee Perfect Brew
- Drip coffee machine
- Brews 8-, 12-, and 16-ounce single-servings and a full 8-cup carafe
- Drink settings include express cold brew, hot and iced coffee, black tea, white tea, green tea, and herbal tea
- All tea options can be brewed hot or iced
- Automatically adjusts time, temperature, and water based on the coffee or tea type
- Includes double-sided scoop, coffee basket and filter, tea basket and filter, and glass carafe
- 17.91×7.48×16.14 inches
Design Features That Stand Out
The Mr. Coffee Perfect Brew is a smart coffee and tea maker with a sleek design that streamlines the process of brewing ground coffee and loose-leaf tea. The machine uses a single dial to select your drinks and integrated buttons to start a brew, delay a brew for later, or set the time, which is displayed directly on the front panel. The Perfect Brew auto-detects whether you’re using the coffee or tea filter, so you don’t mix them up, and while the pieces are dishwasher-safe, you can use drip coffee liners to make cleanup even easier.
As you program your drink selection, the brewer tells you how much coffee grounds or tea leaves you need to spoon out with the included scoop. One side of the scoop is for coffee and the other is for tea, which takes all the guesswork out of measuring for the best flavor. It even steeps the tea for you based on the type of tea you’ve selected and brews both tea and coffee at their optimal temperatures.
How It Performed
I haven’t had a carafe coffee maker in years, and honestly, I was missing it. Single-serve coffee has its perks, for sure, but I forgot all about the convenience of refilling my cup without having to run another brewing cycle. Mr. Coffee’s Perfect Brew filled the void. Additionally, as someone whose stomach doesn’t always agree with coffee, I was incredibly curious about the tea features. We have a ton of loose-leaf tea at home, and while a calming tea ritual is nice, sometimes I want a more hands-off approach. I also could spend my entire day drinking tea, so being able to brew more at a time was just an added bonus.
The Perfect Brew turned out to be exactly what I didn’t know I needed! Even though it doesn’t take pods, making coffee couldn’t be easier, and I don’t even have to measure the grounds myself. The ability to brew tea is also a HUGE benefit since I don’t have to worry about pulling out my variety of infusers or reusable tea bags. I can just pour the loose tea directly into the filter basket! The machine has become a part of my everyday routine that I look forward to, no matter the hour.
What I Loved
- Smart Filter System: The Perfect Brew’s color-coded filters and baskets ensure that your coffee tastes like coffee and your tea tastes like tea. Plus, since the machine also displays which filter is inside of it, there’s little to no chance of you mixing them up.
- Brews Large-Batch Tea: I love that I can make a full carafe of tea because not only do I drink a lot of it, but I’m also not the only one in my household who drinks it. By brewing a carafe, everyone gets to enjoy it without the need to resteep or reheat the water for another small bag.
Good to Know
This coffee maker is unable to automatically brew a half-carafe, so you would have to brew two 16-ounce beverages to achieve it. Additionally, the warming plate only activates when using the carafe and shuts off automatically after an hour.
Should You Buy the Mr. Coffee Perfect Brew?
If you’re in the market for a new carafe brewer, I’d recommend the Mr. Coffee Perfect Brew to anyone who:
- Alternates between drinking coffee and tea regularly
- Is looking for a brewer with single-serve and carafe options
- Is looking for a coffee maker with a slimmer profile
- Doesn’t mind that the warming plate has an auto-shutoff at 60 minutes
Where to Buy the Mr. Coffee Perfect Brew
You can grab your own Mr. Coffee Perfect Brew at Amazon for $199.99 (normally $299.99).
HOW WE SHOP FOR YOU
Our writers and editors put hundreds of products to the test every year to determine which ones get our stamp of approval and are really worth your time and money. If we love it, you’ll hear about it.
WHY YOU SHOULD TRUST US
Our team is made up of writers and editors with years of experience in the home, kitchen, and parenting consumer product space, and who are always testing for new tried-and-true staples.
HOW WE TEST PRODUCTS
We put products to the test right where they matter: at home. We bring these products into our personal spaces and test them for weeks and even months to see if they live up to their claims. At the end of the day, we’re consumers, too, so we’ll provide you with all the information we’d want — and then some.
Read more about our team and how we choose products.