We Tried the $16 “Sponge” That’s Dividing the Internet

(Image credit: Lauren Volo)

I’ve been known to make some kitchen splurges, but if I’m going to spend more than $1 on something to clean my dishes, it better be worth it. This is my way of saying that I was intrigued when I came across The Laundress’ Copper Cleaning Cloth — for $16 (!!!). I love the brand’s laundry products and, frankly, I found this to be the prettiest sponge I’ve ever seen.

Could it be beautiful and totally functional? If the answer is yes, I’d be happy to spend a little more money. That’s a big if, though.

(Image credit: Amazon)

Here’s the premise: Copper is a metal, so it offers the abrasive benefits of other hardy scrubbers like a steel wool pad. But because it’s a softer metal than steel, it’s gentler on the items you’re cleaning, so you can use it on more fragile items — like copper pots or glass — without scratching things up.

There are other copper scrubbers on the market (notably the Chore Boy versions, which are closer to $1 per scrubber) but they don’t quite have the finesse of this one: It’s a two-ply cloth woven with copper threads, as opposed to a round scrubby. The Laundress recommends it for about 20 different surfaces, including stainless steel, china, glass, enamel, aluminum, and more. (Note: It’s not meant for Teflon or other nonstick surfaces.) Plus it’s 100 percent recyclable and machine-washable.

But the reviews are mixed. While some praise the cleaning cloth for getting rid of some tricky stains (bathtub rust, water scale on glass, etc.) without leaving a mark, others complained that it was too abrasive for enamel cookware. Some complained that it was overpriced and disintegrated quicker than the Chore Boy versions; others said they’ve used them for years with no disintegration at all. Confusing!

So I ordered one to try it out, and tested it on various surfaces over the course of the week.

In my experience, the sponge did a great job on my pans, ceramic mugs and plates, and even glassware. I had some Pyrex bowls that forever looked cloudy, and now they’re sparkling. I tried it on my enamel cooktop, and it did a great job removing grease, but I found I had to go over the surface again with a soft sponge to mop up the leftover soap and water. I scrubbed burnt stains off the bottoms of a few pots and my knives came out extra-shiny, too. By the end of the week, the cloth wasn’t quite as cute as before, but it didn’t look dingy, either. And it smelled like … nothing, versus the soapy-metallic smell of some steel wool scrubbers of the grossness that regular sponges can acquire.

So I’ll say I was satisfied. It scrubbed way better than the scrubby side of my Skura sponges, and reminded me that I should actually have a real scrubber on hand more often. But would I spend $16 on it again? Probably not. Next time I’ll try the cheaper-but-way-less-romantic-sounding Chore Boy scrubbers.

What do you think? Would you pay $16 for a sponge? Do you like the Chore Boy scrubbers? Discuss in the comments below!

We support our readers with carefully chosen product recommendations to improve life at home. You support us through our independently chosen links, many of which earn us a commission.