How To Make the Best Cheesy Quesadillas

updated Mar 8, 2023
How To Make the Best Cheesy Quesadillas

Fill it with plain cheese and beans or with shrimp and avocado; the quesadilla is whatever you want to make it.

Serves4

Jump to Recipe
We independently select these products—if you buy from one of our links, we may earn a commission. All prices were accurate at the time of publishing.
Post Image

The humble quesadilla wears many hats. It’s a quick weeknight meal that can transform yesterday’s leftovers into something new and tasty. It’s also a fuss-free snack that will satisfy a group of hungry teenagers — or the crowd at your next cocktail party. Fill it with plain cheese and beans, leftover roast chicken, or with quick-sautéed shrimp and avocado; the quesadilla is whatever you want to make it.

Making Quesadillas at Home

Making quesadillas is about as easy as it comes. Warm a flour or corn tortilla in a skillet and top with cheese and fillings. Wait until everything is warm and gooey, then fold and dig in.

When using store-bought tortillas I prefer using flour tortillas for quesadillas — you can usually find the larger 9- or 10-inch size, which makes them easier to handle. They also fold easier without splitting or crumbling.

If you prefer corn tortillas, choose high-quality soft tortillas for best results. Corn tortillas crisp beautifully, and the flavor is brilliant with melted cheese.

Coating the Pan with Butter

One trick — a surprising trick! — is to use only a little bit of butter or oil in the pan when cooking the quesadillas. Too much and I find the tortilla ends up soggy and greasy instead of crispy. Just a half teaspoon or so to coat the bottom of the pan ensures a crispy tortilla with golden-brown spots.

Of course, if you’re using a comal or cast-iron pan, you do not need to use any oil or butter at all.

Medium vs High Heat

Play with the burner temperature, too. On my electric stove, medium heat will cook the quesadilla in a few minutes, with the cheese melting and the tortilla crisping almost simultaneously. On gas stoves in former apartments, I usually cooked the quesadillas over slightly higher heat.

Fillings for Quesadilla

My only other word of advice is to keep it simple with the fillings. Stick to just a few ingredients and only use about 1/2 cup or so per quesadilla. The melted cheese will hold the filling in place once the tortilla is folded and help prevent it from tumbling out on the plate. Don’t feel limited to just Mexican ingredients either! The quesadilla is really just a vehicle for whatever combinations of ingredients your imagination can create.

Do you love quesadillas? What are your favorite fillings?

How To Make the Best Cheesy Quesadillas

Fill it with plain cheese and beans or with shrimp and avocado; the quesadilla is whatever you want to make it.

Serves 4

Nutritional Info

Ingredients

  • 2 to 3 cups

    filling: leftover cooked vegetables, cooked meat, crumbled tofu, cooked beans, fresh or frozen corn, cooked rice or grains, or any other leftovers

  • 2 teaspoons

    butter or vegetable oil, divided

  • 4

    large flour tortillas (9-inch to 10-inch)

  • 2 cups

    shredded cheese, such as cheddar, Monterey jack, colby, fontina, or any favorite melting cheese

Equipment

  • 12-inch skillet or griddle

  • Spatula

  • Paring knife

Instructions

Show Images
  1. Prepare the filling. Pick a few of the suggested filling ingredients above, enough to make 2 to 3 cups of total filling. If combining leftovers, warm them briefly in the microwave or in a skillet over medium heat. If using raw ingredients, cook before making quesadillas. Transfer the filling to a bowl and cover to keep warm.

  2. Melt 1/2 teaspoon butter or oil in the skillet. Ironically, the key to a crispy quesadilla is less fat in the pan, not more. Too much fat will make your quesadilla soggy instead of crispy. Use just enough to coat the bottom of your skillet — about 1/2 teaspoon of butter or oil. Warm it in the skillet over medium to medium-high heat.

  3. Add the tortilla and top with cheese. Place 1 tortilla in the skillet and sprinkle all over with 1/2 cup of cheese.

  4. Add the filling. Spread about 1/2 cup of filling in a single layer over just half the tortilla. Don't use too much or the filling will fall out as you try to eat it. Spreading the filling over half makes the quesadilla easier to fold, and adding it as the cheese melts gives the filling time to warm if it has cooled.

  5. Watch for the cheese to melt. Once the cheese starts to melt, begin lifting a corner of the tortilla and checking the underside. When the cheese has completely melted and you see golden-brown spots on the underside of the tortilla, the quesadilla is ready.

  6. Fold the quesadilla in half. Use the spatula to fold the quesadilla in half, sandwiching the filling.

  7. Transfer to a cutting board and cut into wedges. Slide the quesadilla onto a cutting board. If serving immediately, let cool for a minute or 2 for the cheese to set, then cut into wedges. If preparing several quesadillas for a crowd, slide the un-cut quesadillas onto a baking sheet and keep warm in a 200°F oven, then slice into wedges just before serving.

  8. Wipe the pan clean and repeat. Wipe the pan clean if needed, melt another dab of butter, and continue cooking quesadillas as described above.

Recipe Notes

Favorite filling combinations:
→ Diced onion, diced red peppers, black beans, corn, and cheddar
→ Sautéed sliced mushrooms, shredded chicken breast, wilted spinach, and fontina
→ Pulled pork, caramelized onions, and monterey jack cheese
→ Sautéed shrimp, red onion, avocado, and queso fresco

Storage: Leftovers can be refrigerated in an airtight container for up to 5 days.