The Can’t-Miss Treats to Order from Goldbelly’s Annual Ice Cream Sale, According to Kitchn Editors

published Jul 9, 2021
We independently select these products—if you buy from one of our links, we may earn a commission. All prices were accurate at the time of publishing.
Scooping ice cream into a bowl with an OXO scooper
Credit: Sarah Crowley

I scream! You scream! You know the rest … and right now, we’re yelling from the rooftops about Goldbelly’s annual Ice Cream Sale. That’s right, the editor-loved company is offering up to 30 percent off sweet treats from some of the country’s most iconic ice creameries, shipped right to your door! I’m talking mouthwatering pints, sundae kits, ice cream sandwiches, and more hailing from everywhere from Philly to San Francisco.

Goldbelly is a deliciously convenient way to try new foods from places you’ve been hearing about for years, and it’s also the perfect way to savor the flavors you love and have been missing. Our editors scoured the sale for their favorite brands included in the sale, and these are the ones we’re most excited about — read on to see why.

1 / 5
was $79.95

"As a Cincinnati native, I was fortunate to grow up with Graeter's in my backyard," says deputy food director Grace. This package comes with six pints, and you can choose from irresistible options like Madagascar Vanilla Bean, Mocha Chip, and Mint Chocolate Chip, among others. "The ice cream itself is impossibly rich and creamy, but the real star is the chocolate chips, which are often the size of your spoon." Yum.

2 / 5
was $109.00

"I'm from a small town outside of Buffalo, NY and grew up going to Anderson's," reminisces tools editor Riddley. "You can't go wrong with any of their flavors. I like the Black Raspberry, and you should also absolutely try the Watson's Sponge Candy Ice Cream. (Watson's Chocolates is another local institution and makes amazing candy, especially sponge candy, a speciality of the area.)" This scrumptious sundae party pack comes with three pints (options include custard and ice cream), along with chocolate fudge, chopped nuts, rainbow sprinkles, M&M's, and even a scooper.

3 / 5

I lived in Philly for years, and one of my absolute favorite spots is Reading Terminal Market. That's where you'll find Bassett's Ice Cream, a storied brand that has been churning out mouthwatering treats since 1861. When I saw that they were included in this sale, I added this DIY ice cream sandwich kit to my cart. It comes with three flavors (you pick), along with 16 ready-to-bake portions of chocolate chip cookie dough from Famous 4th Street Cookie Company, which just happens to be located steps from Bassett's. I can't wait to dig in and feel like I'm back in one of my favorite cities.

4 / 5
was $89.00

What's an IT'S-IT ice cream sandwich? Allow lifestyle director Lisa to explain. "It's vanilla ice cream sandwiched between two baked oatmeal cookies and dipped in dark chocolate. It's perfection. It's also a Northern California thing and can be hard to find in my East Coast neck of the woods, so I'm going to be placing an embarrassingly large order in the next few minutes." This package includes 24 vanilla ice cream sandwiches. That should last her at least 24 days ...

5 / 5
was $79.00

"I count myself as lucky to live close to San Francisco-based ice creamery Humphry Slocombe," says lifestyle editor Michelle. "I remember waiting in line years ago to try their popular, signature flavor Secret Breakfast — rich, creamy, vanilla-based ice cream infused with bourbon and cornflake cookies." Um, yes please. "Now, their pints are available to anyone, anywhere — without the wait!"