The Under-the-Radar Site That Fiesta Collectors Need to Know About

published Sep 13, 2021
We independently select these products—if you buy from one of our links, we may earn a commission. All prices were accurate at the time of publishing.
Post Image

Fiestaware has a huge fan following, and for good reason: The popular brand offers dinnerware, serveware, and glasses that are affordable, fun, colorful, and infinitely collectible. Every piece is bright and cheery, from their soup bowls to their entertaining trays. We also love that they’re easily mixed and matched, so you can grow your collection steadily over time. 

Although Macy’s is our usual source for all new Fiestaware items, we’ve recently been crushing on Replacements, Ltd., a website that sells all things dinnerware and serveware. They’re an unexpectedly brilliant source for rare, unique, and seasonal Fiestaware items. All of the items on Replacements’ website are limited in stock, but the good news is that there are always new pieces cycling through. It’s kind of like shopping at a well-curated vintage store: The perfect piece is just waiting for you to discover it. 

This is the place to shop for Fiestaware fans who seemingly have everything, and it’s a fun way to add a little holiday spirit to your dinnerware. Here are 11 must-have Fiestaware finds from Replacements… we’ll race you for the Halloween cat mug!

1 / 11

This deep blue set was introduced in 1986, but like most of Fiestaware’s pieces, it has aged well and looks timeless. The 5-piece set includes a dinner plate, salad plate, and bowl, and — this is fun! — a mug and saucer set. As with every item on Replacements, each piece is inspected for quality.

2 / 11

This 9-inch plate is iconic Fiestaware. The flamenco dancer’s dress is colored in the brand’s signature bright and cheery shades and the black rim around the plate adds just the right amount of contrast. It would make a fun statement piece, but if you want to order a full set, don’t wait — there are only 24 plates available.

3 / 11

Snap up this set of mixing bowls and you’ll never use anything else for baking. Included in the set are an 8-inch, 9-inch, and 11-inch mixing bowl, perfectly sized for all types of recipes and all in a mix of Fiestaware’s cool colors. These are highly sought-after pieces and, not to be alarmist or anything, but there are only four sets left.

4 / 11

Generously sized at 12 inches, there’s no questioning what this holly-jolly plate was made for: COOKIES! Add this one to your cart and use it to display sweet treats all holiday long. Or, if you really want to score brownie points with someone in your life, gift it piled high with these sugar cookies. Four left! Run! Don’t walk!

5 / 11

Stemless wine glasses have a special place in our hearts. They’re easier to wash and much harder to spill. This price is a steal for one of Fiestaware’s most popular color combinations. Add a few of the same style in warm sunset colors, or round out your set with a double old-fashioned glass.

6 / 11

This entertaining set in the iconic “Cools” color scheme inspires us to host all of the parties — or at least, make a dinner out of dip and chips. It contains four trays for veggies, crostini, crackers, or other snacking items, and the center bowl is generously sized for a heaping serving of your favorite spread. Now, you just have to choose what kind of dip to serve. Queso? No, Romesco! Wait, hummus...

7 / 11

This. Color. Is. EVERYTHING. Deeply red and cozy (just like your favorite red wine) this dinner-sized plate is just the thing for chilly winter nights. If you like Fiestaware’s Cinnabar color, you’re going to fall for this one, too.

8 / 11

All right you cool cats and kittens, this mug is way too adorable to pass up. The “Halloween green” color gives off all of the spooky vibes, but the cat is so cute, we’d sip on coffee out of this mug all year long.

9 / 11

This bowl is paws-itively a must-have for Fiestaware-loving pet owners. We appreciate that it’s printed in dog language (the bottom and side are patterned with “woof,”) It’s on sale for almost 40 percent off, so hop to it. Our hearts are also melting over this “Best Friends” dog bowl.

10 / 11

Retro-chic friends: You need this pitcher. Colored in a rusty red Fiestaware calls Persimmon, this 6-inch piece is a true collector’s item (it was made to mark the company’s 60th anniversary in 1996). Although there’s nothing quite like this piece, you can also browse a handful of other items in Persimmon — it’s an underrated Fiestaware color.

11 / 11

This plate says it all: Pumpkin spice and everything nice. It’s 6.5 inches, making it perfect for apps and snacks at a Halloween party — or just your “every day” plate during the month of October. Even if you’re a pumpkin Grinch, it’s hard not to smile at the whimsical font and creamy pale orange color. It was discontinued in 2017, so if you’re interested, don’t sleep on it: This piece may not be available for much longer.