Costco’s Giant Peanut Butter Chocolate Pie Is Back and Flying Off Shelves

published Jul 26, 2023
We independently select these products—if you buy from one of our links, we may earn a commission. All prices were accurate at the time of publishing.
Costco Peanut Butter pie on white surface.
Credit: Mara Weinraub

Costco is beloved for having great prices on bulk purchase items, but the store is also known for offering some larger-than-life baked goods. Whether it’s the giant muffins or huge pumpkin pies, no one is going to be left hungry after one of these sweet treats.

Social media was in a frenzy earlier this year when Costco added a peanut butter chocolate pie to shelves. These pies, which sold out so fast that stores could hardly keep them in stock, were an unbelievable 4 1/2 pounds of chocolate peanut butter perfection. Those who were lucky enough to find it at their Costco bakery had to pay just around $20 for the 16-serving pie.

Said to be “dangerously delicious,” these pies were hard to come by and then seemingly disappeared — but now eagle-eyed social media users are beginning to report return appearances of the pie!

This news has created such a frenzy that there are even Reddit threads devoted to discussing the pie’s return.

If you have a hankering for the combination of salty peanut butter with rich, sweet chocolate, head to the refrigerated section of the bakery of your nearest Costco. Because these pies are hard to come by and may only be back temporarily, you just might want to stock up now! 

If you are not lucky enough to find this pie at your local Costco, don’t be too disappointed — this copycat Costco peanut butter pie recipe should feed the craving!