Recipe Review

I Am Fully Obsessed with These Blueberry Cookies and Will Definitely Make Them Again

updated Apr 16, 2021
We independently select these products—if you buy from one of our links, we may earn a commission. All prices were accurate at the time of publishing.
Post Image
Credit: Sara Tane

Have you ever fallen in love with a cookie at first sight? That’s exactly what happened to me when I stumbled upon Justine Snacks’ blueberry cookies on TikTok. I mean, look at them! How could you not be captivated by their bright violet hue? Once I realized they were in the scope of my baking capabilities (read: painfully easy), I had no choice but to give ’em a go.


Reply to @beepbopbooppoo Blueberries or nothing 🤩 ##ad @littlebluedynamos #c#ookierecipe #b#lueberries #f#rozenblueberries #b#aking #b#loobs

♬ Central Park – Matt Beilis

How to Make the TikTok-Famous Blueberry Cookies

This cookie recipe is about as simple as any run-of-the-mill homemade cookie: You cream together the wet ingredients, add the dry ingredients, throw in some chocolate chips, chill the dough, and bake. Because they’re vegan, you’ll use vegan butter and no eggs. But the one addition that really sets them apart is thawed frozen blueberries. Justine says she specifically calls for frozen blueberries because “when you thaw frozen blueberries, they become soft, jammy, and sweet, and are the perfect addition to the wet ingredients.”

When I thawed my frozen blueberries in the microwave they seemed watery, so I was apprehensive to add them to the batter — but I took a leap of faith. The blueberries turned the batter a delightful blue color, which looked even prettier after I added a handful of white chocolate chips. Next, I gave the batter a quick chill in the freezer before rolling them into balls and baking them.

Get the recipe: Blueberry Cookies from Justine Snacks

Credit: Sara Tane

My Honest Review

These. Were. Amazing. I’m honestly shook that I haven’t attempted to make blueberry cookies before today. Blueberry-flavored desserts are very nostalgic for me — growing up, I always loved a good blueberry muffin, blueberry buckle, or blueberry doughnut — and I still sometimes treat myself to a blueberry munchkin at Dunkin’. These cookies had that exact same blueberry flavor.

The cookies also had a lovely light and fluffy texture, and I even liked the white chocolate chips even though normally those aren’t my favorite. I’ve never baked with vegan butter so I wasn’t sure what to expect, but it creamed up nicely and I didn’t run into any issues. And to my surprise, the bright blue color of the batter was barely altered after baking.

There are plenty of recipes that look good on TikTok but don’t taste right, and this was not one of them. My roommate and I could not stop eating them. You have been warned.

Credit: Sara Tane

3 Tips for Making TikTok’s Blueberry Cookies

  1. Play around with the frozen fruit. I am fully obsessed with these cookies and have every intention to make them again. I want to play around with the fruit and try it with frozen strawberries, raspberries, and maybe even peaches.
  2. Add some lemon zest. Blueberry and lemon are a divine pairing in the world of desserts, so if I made these again, I might throw in some lemon zest. They certainly don’t need them, but I have no doubt it’d add a subtle flavor boost.
  3. Double the recipe. Friends don’t let friends make teeny tiny batches of cookies. As written, this recipe makes 12 cookies, although I am greedy and prefer a bigger cookie, so my batch only turned out eight cookies. This was simply not enough. Did my roommate and I scarf the whole batch in one sitting? That’s a secret I’ll never tell. That said, I would probably double the batch next time — and after you try these cookies, you will understand why.