The Ultimate List of Where to Buy Seafood Online

updated Dec 11, 2023
We independently select these products—if you buy from one of our links, we may earn a commission. All prices were accurate at the time of publishing.
Post Image
Credit: Joe Lingeman

Did you know that you don’t have to necessarily make the long trek to the fish market to pick out the day’s fresh catch? Yep, you read that right — there are now tons of online retailers who can get high-quality, fresh seafood delivered right to your door. Smell something fishy, like maybe a hefty price tag? Fret not! These companies offer incredibly competitive prices, low shipping fees (or in many cases, free shipping), and many even have subscription programs that will help you get your monthly stock without breaking the bank. Plus, their seafood is sustainably sourced, flash-frozen, and expertly packaged to ensure long-lasting freshness. Below, we’ve rounded up a list of some of the best online seafood delivery services that should be on your radar today.

Did we miss out on your favorite online seafood store? We want to hear all about it. Tell us about your go-to spots in the comments below and we’ll keep updating the list!

1 / 10

Studio Food Editor, Jesse is a huge fan of FarmFoods, an online retailer that conveniently delivers premium meats and seafood straight to your door. Besides selling sell pork, chicken, beef, and even turkey, FarmFoods has a wide selection of seafood options to choose from, including several varieties of wild-caught salmon, Alaska halibut, and Pacific cod. You can also always opt for the Meat Variety Pack that includes a good mix of meats and seafood.

2 / 10
Wild Alaskan Company

The monthly seafood membership club delivers wild-caught seafood and lets you choose between a 12-pack ($145) or a 24-pack ($267) of the wild salmon box, wild white fish box, or wild combo box, which includes an assortment of both. Everything is individually wrapped in eco-friendly insulation, so it's easier to defrost and cook. Plus, right now they're offering free shipping off, and you can cancel or skip shipments anytime you choose.

3 / 10
Luke's Lobster

If you've devoured one of Luke's Lobster's delicious lobster rolls, you'll be thrilled to know that the iconic eatery is now selling their sustainably caught seafood online — including their epic lobster rolls! Luke’s online menu is just like the one you might see at one of their “shacks.” Depending on what you order, your seafood will be delivered to your home fresh or flash-frozen, with detailed instructions on thawing and other best practices to ensure a delicious experience. Besides their buttery good lobster rolls, you can also pick from a wide range of fresh seafood, including scallops and clam chowder. The site provides a helpful delivery chart that lets you plan your order in advance for a specific day or event, and since Luke’s works directly with fishermen, the prices are a lot lower than what you would find at grocery stores.

4 / 10
Thrive Market

Looking for another incentive to sign up for Thrive Market? They also stock fresh, sustainably sourced seafood! The Build Your Own Seafood Box lets you mix and match a variety of seafood options like Alaskan sockeye salmon, sweet scallops, wild shrimp, and more. Each bundle ships completely frozen in biodegradable packaging to maintain optimal freshness. There's also a Build Your Own Meat and Seafood Box that's great for those looking for a monthly mix.

5 / 10
Omaha Steaks
was $449.95

Besides prime steak cuts, the folks at Omaha Steaks also stock an exhaustive variety of fresh and marinated seafood. There's also the option to build your own combo box using a variety of seafood or even meats, seafood, and pre-prepared meals. Additionally, they run daily specials, so you have the opportunity to snag premium seafood at up to 50 percent off. Orders over $139 ship for free, and right now, you can expect your package to arrive anywhere between 5 to 7 days.

6 / 10
Vital Choice

Vital's Choice probably stocks one of the biggest varieties of seafood options we've spotted online. You can choose between wild fish and shellfish, canned and pouched options, subscription boxes, and even seasoning for your seafood. We particularly love the Wild Seafood Box option, which comes packed with the ocean's most delicious seafood picks. We're talking salmon, fish, shellfish, salmon burger patties, and more!

7 / 10
Lobster Anywhere

You really don't have to make a trip to Maine to enjoy some fresh lobster. Get the delicious goodness delivered right to your door with Lobster Anywhere. Choose from lip-smacking options like Jumbo Lobster Tails, Lobster Rolls, Boston Lobster Bake, and more. You can even pick grill-ready combos, like Surf and Turf Dinners that include lobsters, shrimp, and premium filet mignon cuts. And while you're at it, don't forget to add a creamy seafood soup like lobster bisque or clam chowder to your order.

8 / 10

Rastelli's is famous for its premium, all-natural options that are vacuum-sealed and blast-frozen before being delivered to your home. Right now, you can pick among the Faroe Island Salmon Filets Box, Wild-Caught Gulf Shrimp, Wild-Caught Icelandic Cod Box, and Crab Cakes, which are packed full of premium blue crab meat and blended with the perfect amount of tangy mayo, zesty breadcrumbs, Dijon mustard, and lemon. Orders over $200 ship for free, and take anywhere between 7 to 12 days to get to you.

9 / 10

The online grocery delivery service also stocks various types of fresh and pre-prepared fish and shellfish options. You shop based on weight, and prices are accordingly adjusted during checkout. They also provide you with a freshness window so you can easily meal plan based on your seafood's shelf life.

10 / 10

Sizzlefish gives you the option to buy single packs of fresh seafood or even build your own monthly box with an assortment of premium-quality, wild-caught seafood. Their selection is extensive, and besides the usual fish and shellfish varieties, they also stock options to suit specific dietary requirements.