The Best Deep Fryer for Most Home Cooks

updated Dec 17, 2019
We independently select these products—if you buy from one of our links, we may earn a commission. All prices were accurate at the time of publishing.
Post Image
Credit: Nadine Greeff/Stocksy

While the rest of America is all “air fryers this” and “air fryers that,” there are plenty of people who believe that there’s no substituting for the real thing. (A deep fryer just gets that crispy, crunchy crust that no other appliance can.) If you are one of these people, we totally get it. And that’s why we looked into the best deep fryers for home use. Because, sometimes, it’s nicer to enjoy a plate of fresh-out-of-the-fryer mozzarella sticks from the comfort of your own home than out at, say, a sports bar. And while you can totally deep-fry with several cups of oil in a Dutch oven, that’s more of a once-in-a-while solution — not ideal for frequent fryers.

So, here goes. We looked to see which deep fryers other food experts had to suggest. And then we weighed in with our own thoughts.

The Best Deep Fryer, According to Wirecutter

After 60 hours of research and testing, the folks at Wirecutter picked this machine from Cuisinart. They said it’s easy to operate, comes with a decently large frying basket (making the fryer great for parties), has a built-in timer, and the temperature-control dial is clearly labeled. The best part? Its heating element keeps oil at a consistent temperature — even after frozen food is dropped in. Other machines they tested saw a drop in oil temp by 90 degrees, but this one only dropped 60 degrees — and made the most perfectly golden-brown foods.

The Best Deep Fryer, According to Cook’s Illustrated

Testers at Cook’s Illustrated said that this fryer had results that were “almost always perfect” and worked just as well as the Dutch oven method. They liked its large basket, how easy it was to lift and lower foods, and that the high walls contained messes. They warn that it has a lot of parts to clean, but the built-in filter and oil storage container make the process a little easier — especially when compared to other models.

The Best Deep Fryer, According to Good Housekeeping

Our friends at Good Housekeeping picked the same machine that Wirecutter liked. They loved that it makes up 2.3 pounds of food and has a timer, a clear control dial (from 175°F to 375°F), and a viewing window that lets you track your food’s progress. Plus, the basket, oil container, and lid are all dishwasher-safe.

The Bestselling Deep Fryer on Amazon

The first few “bestselling deep fryers” on Amazon are actually air fryers, but this is the first legit deep fryer to appear on the list. It has a 4.3-star rating and more than 1,000 five-star reviews. Shoppers like that it churns out reliably golden-brown food, is easy to clean and put away, and comes at a great price. “This little deep fryer works great. No mess. No oil splatters. It holds the temp a lot better than I expected,” one reviewer says. 

Kitchn’s Thoughts on the Best Deep Fryer

Get the Cuisinart model that Wirecutter and Good Housekeeping like. The whole point of getting an electric deep fryer is to have a machine that automatically monitors and adjusts the oil temperature (a Dutch oven setup does not help with that), so you want one with a well-calibrated thermostat. We agree with these two outlets that the Cuisinart stays consistently steady and has the best rebound once frozen food is dropped in. Plus, the price is super reasonable.