The Best Cake Pans, According to Our Resident Baking Expert

The Best Cake Pans, According to Our Resident Baking Expert

Meghan Splawn
Apr 10, 2018
(Image credit: Joe Lingeman)

Good cake pans aren't nearly as expensive as a stand mixer, and they last virtually forever, yet many of our kitchens are packed with thin, cheap cake pans that we picked up at the grocery store or had handed down to us. Get yourself something better!

A quality cake pan will give you cakes that bake up more evenly — no more wildly humped tops or burned bottoms — and come out of the pan better without any extra effort on your part.

Are you ready to become a better cake baker in one easy step? Here are three of our favorite cake pans that everyone should own.

What Makes the Best Cake Pan?

Professional bakers use two-inch-deep aluminum cake pans for just about everything from wedding cakes to biscuits. The aluminum heats quickly and evenly, while the high sides give cake batter plenty of room to rise while keeping the cake from overbaking.

As for what shapes and sizes to keep on hand, there are three that you'll use over and over again: a 9-inch round (two of these, ideally, if you've got the room), a 13x9-inch rectangle pan, and an 8-inch square. More on each of these below!

(Image credit: Amazon)

9-Inch Rounds

Again, it's really best if you have two of these. Most layer cakes call for either an 8- or 9-inch pan and require the batter to be split into two pans for baking. I prefer to skip a nonstick finish on these pans so I can also use them to bake biscuits and dinner rolls (the nonstick surface inhibits rise during bread proofing). Luckily, these are usually sold in sets!

My favorite: Wilton Aluminum Performance Pans, $11 for two

(Image credit: Amazon)

13x9-Inch Rectangular Pan

A ceramic casserole dish is not a cake pan, so you cannot use the two interchangeably for cakes, but you can use this metal baking pan for casseroles and egg bakes. I have tried a lot of rectangular pans and this one is by far my favorite — especially for baking sheet cakes and icebox cakes to feed a crowd.

Buy: OXO Good Grips Nonstick Pro Cake Pan 9x13-Inch, $22

(Image credit: Calphalon via Amazon)

8-Inch Square

This quintessential brownie pan is also awesome for Rice Krispies treats or making caramels at Christmas. A very square — rather than slightly rounded corner — will give you more professional-looking results.

My pick: Calphalon Nonstick Bakeware Square Cake Pan, $14

More posts in Party Cakes
You are on the first post of the series.
Kitchn supports our readers with carefully chosen product recommendations to improve life at home. You support us through our independently chosen links, many of which earn us a commission.
moving--truck moving--dates moving--dolly moving--house moving--cal Created with Sketch. moving--apt