
The question over what kind of salt to use, and why there's such a difference in price between the various varieties, comes up often.
First Anne asked what the difference was between Morton's and sea salt. Pat responded that sea salt is expensive stuff, and suggested using kosher salt for finishing a dish instead.
The easiest way to think of salts is to break them down into three categories: table salt, regular sea salts and kosher salts, and finishing salts. I keep all three around: table salt for baking, kosher/sea salt for cooking, and finishing salt for serving.
Table salt (the fine white stuff you're used to seeing in a round cardboard container) usually has additives like iodine (to prevent thyroid disease) and an anti-caking agent to prevent lumping in humidity. Table salt without iodine is available, especially in health food stores. We use Hain without iodine for baking and go through a 26ozer once a year at the most. Most brands costs under $1.
Sea salt is not necessarily expensive - the specialty varieties like Fleur de Sel are expensive, and we'll talk about that in a moment. For cooking, regular old sea salt is superior to table salt. A 26.5oz container of La Baleine Coarse Sea Salt will run about $3.00. Considering the amount of time it takes to blow through this quantity of salt, you really won't notice the difference unless you're pinching pennies big time.
Like sea salt, kosher salt is preferred by chefs for cooking because it has no additives and is coarsely grained and leaves more salty flavor-bursts in the food. The flakes of kosher salt are a bit lighter than sea salt, so kosher salt is often preferred for seasoning sautés, brining meats, and salting water. Experiment; choose your favorite. It usually comes in large boxes (48oz) and runs about $2.
Finishing salts are the upper echelon of sea salts and should be used only on finished food - not while cooking. I prefer Fleur de Sel, which is made from young crystals that bloom naturally on the surface of salt evaporation pond. The consistency is light and flaky - coming across a little nugget of Fleur de Sel in your food is a pleasure. It brings out the flavor of the food without dominating it with an overly salty flavor. It costs much more than table salt or kosher salt (about $10 for 8 ounces), but once you try it, you'll see why it's worth the extra expense.
Beyond the above mentioned salts, there are dozens more. But so much choice can simply confuse. The most you need is three varieties, and even that, I admit, is a bit excessive. If you want to read more about salt, here is an article I wrote - Salts of the Earth (Washington Times, October 5, 2005)
And if you really want to read more about salt, I highly recommend Mark Kurlansky's Salt: A World History.
TW Salt Mill by Wil...

this is an excellent treatise, miss sk. i have but one question: what kind of salt do you recommend for baking, rather than cooking? does it matter?
Baking = table salt
Baking recipes measurements are made with the idea that the chef will be using table salt, using kosher salt (which has less salt for it's volume) will give undesirable results.
Lisa,
I actually did mention it early on - I use table salt without iodine. Only because it's fine. You could also use fine sea salt, but then that's having four different kinds - too much! Pick one or the other - as long as it's a fine grain.
Cheers!
So cool that you're talking about salt. As a special treat to me, I bought the Zuni Cafe cookbook. I had an amazing dinner there when I was in SF two weeks ago.
I was up late last night ready the cookbook in bed, like it was a hot novel! There's a very interesting part of the preface all about salt. I think the whole cookbook is worth the $35 for the intro alone.
I second the rec for the Zuni preface on salting food. I've pre-salted according to its instructions for roast chicken, and it unfailingly results in superb, moist chicken.
Zuni is my tip top most favorite cookbook - we'll be talking about favorite cookbooks soon, so Chris and GM, stay tuned and chime in.
Power to the Zuni Roast Chicken.
Sara Kate, that was really helpful. I didn't understand what all those salts were for but now I think I'll go out and buy some to experiment. Thanks.
I have to say that Morton's "When it rains it pours" Kosher salt is the best of them all, even if it's not included in the picture above. The Diamond Crystal pictured in the box on on the far right is just not as good.
Eddie - tell us more! Have you done a taste test?
I agree wholeheartedly with everything in this post. My love affair with finishing a salad w/ fleur de sel will never end.
There was an episode of Barefoot Contessa where Ina Garten does a salt "taste test"...dipping a moistened finger in a different salt and tasting, nothing but salt. I've tried this in my kitchen in a less official manner, just tasting a new salt when I open it. It's pretty amazing how "harsh" table salt is in comparison to sea salt/kosher salt, let alone fleur de sel.
I've been looking for Lavender Sea Salt forever...I'm not really sure why, except that I have an interesting recipe for pork w/ lavender sea salt and a couple others. Plus, I'm really intrigued by cooking with lavender in general.
Any tips on where to find Lavender Sea Salt in LA, or on the web?
Aunt Beep -
In LA - try Wally's
http://www.wallywine.com/ps-13763-631-girl-and-the-fig-lavender-sea-salt-2-oz.aspx
on the web:
http://www.lavenderfarm.com/products/salt.htm
http://www.faeriesfinest.com/B306.html
With regards to lavender sea salt, I haven't seen it anywhere, but I have made my own lavender sugar, and I would think that the same principle can be applied. Basically get a jar with an air tight seal on it, put the sugar or salt in it with a few sprigs of fresh lavender. Let it 'marinate' for a couple of days and give it a try, I think I just left the lavender in the sugar when I last made it. It should have a nice flavor but not too overpowering.
der, SK, you did mention table salt for baking. my blog-reading skills at work are clearly impaired. carry on, diligent ones! (oh, and i always find my lavender salt at farmers markets in new england.)
Sarah, thanks for the tip!
How long does something like that keep? I'm assuming that the lavender eventually dries, and can be treated like a dried spice, but I'm wondering if humidity would cause it to go funny after awhile.
I can't wait to try - and lavender sugar sounds yummy! (I suppose I can also do the same thing with honey)
Thanks!
mmm... Zuni Cafe Cookbook... just have to put in my two cents: Judy Rodgers is a wonderful writer. I will hunt out some of my favorite phrases when we actually talk about the cookbook.
Also, her orange currant scones, they are the best. I mean, so, so, so good. (how's that for adjectival writing? :-)
I brought 20 containers of Fleur de Sel back from a trip to France a few years back (before it could be found readily here) and hooked all my friends and loved ones--despite being expensive salt, it makes a very cheap (and very tasty) gift!
It's all in your head! Read "What Einstein Told His Cook", it's an amazing book. There is really no difference between kosher salt and expensive sea salt once you put it in food. It's all the same chemical compound.
A well stocked kitchen simply needs kosher salt and table salt.
Being that our taste buds are on our tongues and not in our stomachs, shouldn't we be more concerned about the sensory experience than how it ends up?
Indeed it is always NaCl; salt, a compound that accentuates/carries flavor, these flavors are further enhanced by the texture, shape and size, along with whatever trace minerals may be present due to environment. So the differences listed in Sara Kates post are actually very important in enhancing our overall enjoyment of food.
I read that book too! Very funny in places.
Here's my memory of his point, with regard to salt and sea salt. Basically, it is that any salt sold for human consumption has to be at least 97.5% sodium chloride. So the chemical makeup of sea salt, rock salt, kosher salt - whatever - are all precisely the same, and any additional flavors, unless they are allowable trace minerals left over from their origin or added later, as in the case of lavender salt, are indeed "in your head."
So he's not talking about these very expensive finishing salts, with their very real flavors imparted by algae and minerals. What he's talking about is the complete non-difference between pure, fine grained "table salt" and "sea salt."
So, like jd said, what SK is talking about here is the difference caused by texture and shape. Table salt has tiny crystals, regular in shape, and therefore has a specific sort of effect on the tongue. Other larger crystals, especially those with irregular shapes, cause a small "explosion" of saltiness on the tongue that is very different from the saltwater created by the instant dissolving of regular old "table salt." All of the things SK mentioned as distinctives about the salts above seem to have to do with this latter set of qualities, the size, shape and texture, which do indeed have a great effect on taste.
But I certainly do agree that it is a waste to buy expensive, fine-grained "sea salt" for baking; in that case it is certainly the same chemical as trusty Morton, give or take some iodine. And that book is worth a read, especially that salt section...
Trace minerals in sea salt compose such a small fraction of the salt mixture that they are inconsequential. I would lay good money on the line that anyone preparing two identical dishes with two different types of sea salt, or sea salt and kosher salt would be unable to tell the difference between the salt varieties used.
In any sort of warm food with a liquid content (and in many cold foods if liquid is present) those crystals are going to disolve, rendering the texture/shape/size a moot point.
There is certainly a difference between kosher salt and table salt because of structure and adatives. My point of contention is that the difference between kosher salt and various "exotic" sea salts is razor thin.
Good question Aunt Beep, I had my sugar around for about a month I think, did it last spring for a recipe and only had a bit left over. But as I recalled it kept well so long as you keep it in a cool dry space. I live in CA and we don't really have a humidity problem out here. Good luck with the salt and if you try honey as well.
I would venture to disagree about the differences between sea salt and kosher salt. Kosher salt is flaky whereas sea salt is granular; this is a significant difference.
Regardless I am a salt-lover and keep on hand four or five different types at all times to suit my whimsical fancies. My favorite "exotics" being: Fleur de Sel, which tends to be moist, grey with some mineral tones and Hawaiian red algae sea salt, which is hard, granular and bright. The differences between these two, my Mortons, the Kosher and the way too expensive truffle salt I bought on a binge at Dean and Deluca a few weeks back are pretty phenomenal. Do a taste test for yourself.
Morton's v. Diamond Crystal. First, Morton's dissolves better on foods and doesn't clump up like the Diamond Crystal. Second, the Morton's container is more manageable and lasts longer -- which is no small issue; the Diamond Crystal boxes start falling apart as soon as I get home. As for taste, Morton seems to be more mild, while the Diamond Crystal tastes like something you should pour on the sidewalk after it snows to prevent ice from building up. I even prefer Morton's Kosher to Sel de Mer.
I'm *addicted* to Kalyustan's Bengal Grey Sea Salt that comes in large jars. It smells like the sea and India and tastes heavenly. I recently cut my budget trying to save for a trip and I couldn't give up my salt. I've been wanting to try Hawaiian salt since it apparently has the taste of earth, ever since I saw it used with hot chocolate on iron Chef America.
Funny, I just bought the Zuni cookbook and also "Cooking by Hand" by Paul Bertolli. Waiting for them to come in the mail.
I totally agree with you Max, its so weird, all my friends newest raves salt, expensive salt, and I don’t get it, honestly i don’t, vie had high level chemistry in school (what Americans would call high school i guess), and the basic thing is that salts salt, i don’t matter how expensive or flaky it is, the one thing where i think there might be a different taste sensation is if you put it on an cold egg, and that’s because of the structure of the salt and not the quality of the salt (there is no such thing as quality of salt, its salt and that’s it)
Okay, so - here's another salt-related question... what's the difference between white salts and *gray* salts? Is it due to the fact that white salts are purified or cleaned or something else? Something I've been curious about ever since I saw gray salt mentioned on Food Network...
I love the honest skepticism of Max and Kristian. While is is generally a great rule to focus on the keeping things simple when trying to eat, think and live well, the belief that "there is no such thing as quality of salt" is no more true than contending that there is no such thing as quality of an egg or quality of a fish or quality of a wine or quality of a butter.
There are at least three quantitative differences between fine salts such as finishing salts and common table salt, adding up to immeasurable qualitative differences: 1, finishing salt is often rich in trace minerals, which bring nutrition value and flavor complexity; 2, finishing salts have hyper complex crystal structures, creating much more satisfying reactions (varying intensities, varying rates of assimilation, and varying inflections) with food as you chew; 3; finishing salts have the startling beauty, intriguing texture, and nuanced scent that can only come from nature.
By comparison, the factory refined sodium chloride (often mixed with sodium ferrocyanide and/or artificial whiteners) that constitutes koshering and table salts is one-dimensional, homogenous, and even dull.
On more political or "karmic" levels, it can gives more pleasure to use a product that is hand-made, all natural, and has rich cultural and historical associations than to use something mined from the earth or bulldozed from the sea shore by very large companies who sell the majority of the sodium chloride products as ingredients for PVC pipe manufacture, road de-icing agents, agricultural products (Molluscicide, Herbicide, Insecticide, Microbiocide).
We have daily tastings at The Meadow, our shop in Portland Oregon, and I can tell you there is nothing more rewarding than watching skeptics (who are essentially advocates for truthfulness), exclaim with excitement at the discovery of a newfound pleasure, and then, almost invariably, take home a new salt or two. My humble recommendations to any skeptic: try Halen Mon flake salt as a finishing salt on salad, Tidman's rock salt as a koshering salt on meat, Fleur de Sel de l'Ile de Re on fish, Sel Gris de Noirmoutier on lamb, Hawaiian Alaea salt on swordfish or fruit salad, and Maine Apple smoked sea salt on roast ANYTHING. See, touch, smell, bite, taste, smile!
Try this site -
http://www.jdfinefoods.com/gourmet_sea_salts
If you want to try something really amazing, try a smoked sea salt. If you put this on meats it gives it an amazing flavor and aroma. Definitely worth giving these salts a try
Late comment on this post, but I wanted to note that iodised salt is important in some regions - here in NZ we have iodine-deficient soils, so people who don't eat iodised salt are more likely to develop goiter. I hope other places with similar issues inform their citizens of the need to use iodised salt.
oh boy...everybody is talking about the Zuni cookbook and here I am with my own copy sitting on a shelf for months...I haven't even peeked at it! :-( Unfortunately I am in between homes...only a couple more months until I have my own kitchen again and the Zuni Cafe book is the FIRST one I will have to crack open *cannot wait*!!!
You don't need salt with iodine added if you use salt that hasn't had it removed in the first place. Morton's, among others, bleach their salt, and then replace the naturally occurring nutrients artificially. Kosher salt does not have the iodine removed and thus does not need to be "iodized." It also contains significantly less sodium. Morton's = BAD.