I have a bone to pick with Thanksgiving. Every year, November 1st rolls around, and even before the Halloween candy has been divvied up, Thanksgiving blows through the door (never mind that there are still nearly four weeks before it's due) and sucks all the air out of the room. Magazines, newspapers, blogs (yes, us too!) dive headlong into cranberry sauce, turkey, stuffing and gravy.
I want to know: Who decided that we should spend an entire month preparing for just one meal? That's what Thanksgiving is, after all. One big meal. An important one, yes, a meal full of tradition and joy and fellowship, but still just one meal. I count at least 89 more meals in November — what about them?
There are a couple problems with this all-Thanksgiving-all-the-time stretch in November. The first problem is the most ironic: For all the talk of Thanksgiving recipes, we probably already know exactly what we're cooking that day. If there is one meal bound in a cast iron-clad fist of tradition, it's Thanksgiving. Give up Mom's rolls for something new? Grandma's sweet potatoes? No way! We might sneak in a slaw or a fresh dessert, but in many ways, Thanksgiving is the simplest meal of the year, with recipes we know nearly by heart. As Regina Schrambling put it in her funny and all-too-true 2008 grouchfest at Slate, Why food writers secretly hate the November feast, "We whip ourselves into a lather trying to make Thanksgiving trendy, but no one really wants to mess with the hoariest menu."
The other problem is those 89 non-Thanksgiving meals. While I do enjoy planning the Thanksgiving feast, today and tomorrow's meals are more pressing. November is a time when the whirl of activity speeds up, from holiday planning to projects at work, and nourishing oneself is even more important as the days grow chill and busy. I am grateful for the fullness of life that November brings — the vibrant colors of autumn, the glorious foods in season: Brussels sprouts, bok choy, late eggplant, kale, Kabocha squash, tart apples and sweet potatoes are spilling into our laps.
So let's talk thanksgiving instead of Thanksgiving — thanksgiving for these foods, and for the daily pleasure of nourishing ourselves and our families, even in the midst of the pre-holiday whirl. We know that Thanksgiving itself will always be a hot topic, and we will bring you more help and details on throwing this big feast (I do admit that no matter how many times we do it it's still fun to talk about) but for now, let's put Thanksgiving gently back outside the door and look at nourishing ourselves today.
Here are a few meals and recipes that I am enjoying as the weather grows chillier. It helps to always have a pot of soup in the fridge, an easy meal to heat up and slurp after a long day at work. I have been making many batches of these simple whole wheat muffins — tasty and nourishing for the mornings. And I love the vegetables that are so abundant at the markets. Last Saturday I splurged greedily on Brussels sprouts, collard greens, Asian eggplant, tiny turnips and apples. These hearty vegetables are so simple; just a roasting pan and some salt are all you need.
And just to be clear: I'm no Thanksgiving grinch. I'm so happy planning my own feast right now. I just don't want to forget to enjoy the rest of this beautiful month. Here's my own pre-Thanksgiving menu; I'm thankful for every bite of it.
BREAKFASTS
• Quick, Easy and Moist Whole Wheat Muffins - An old favorite in my house. These are tender and moist, and if you keep them well-wrapped they stay tasty all week. The whole wheat in them makes them a little heartier than your average muffin.
• Steel-Cut Oatmeal - Hearty and filling, made ahead of time and portioned out in jars for easy reheating throughout the week.
• Basic Oven Omelet - A simple dish of baked eggs with herbs or other mix-ins, quick to make and good for reheating.
SOUPS
• Tuscan Bread and Tomato Soup (Ribollita) - This may be my personal favorite soup. I add a little bacon to the otherwise vegetarian recipe.
• French Onion Soup - This is another fall favorite in my house; it's so satisfying and delicious.
• Hot and Sour Mushroom, Cabbage, and Rice Soup - A cure for the common cold, and just about any other minor ailment.
VEGETABLES
• Collard Greens Stew with Chorizo and Garlic - We eat this with pasta, rice, polenta — whatever is around.
• Hashed Sprouts with Hazelnuts and Fried Capers - After simple roasting (and indulgent braising in cream) this is my favorite way to eat Brussels sprouts. They stand alone as a side dish, or you can put them over pasta.
• Creamy, Smoky Whipped Rutabaga - This rutabaga is just heavenly — an ode to one of fall's less appreciated treasures.
• Squash Braised in Cream - This is a good way to turn squash into a satisfying meal all by itself. It's rich and hearty, and even good for breakfast (plop a poached egg on top, or just eat dusted with cinnamon). You can also use it as another polenta topping.
What are you cooking and eating in these days before Thanksgiving? What foods are you most grateful for this time of year?
Related: Autumn Dinner Party Menu: A Polenta Bar!
(Images: Faith Durand; Leela Cyd Ross; see linked recipes for full image credits)










Straw Mat from The ...

I have to say that I *love* when food writers come up with new ideas for Thanksgiving, but I haven't had what one could call a traditional Thanksgiving for a long time. My partner and I hosted my parents, and often my brother and sister-in-law, at our house for five years and had a vegetarian Thanksgiving dinner that usually had some traditional dishes and flavors, but we always tried new things and loved being able to offer a mix of classic flavors and new dishes every year.
I live on the other side of the country from my family now, and this may be the first year we've had Thanksgiving with just the two of us, but we're still going to make a nice meal, and I'm still going to be hunting down new interpretations of classic dishes. I would remind food writers that a lot of folks in nontraditional families or with different food restrictions love hearing new takes on Thanksgiving. =)
I do agree that it can get a bit overwhelming, though. In November I love to hear about delicious, vegetable-based cold weather food, with as much pumpkin, sweet potato, and brussels sprout action as possible.
I love a nice apple crisp this time of year and there is no way I would wait until Thanksgiving to have it either. Almost anything with all the great fall produce like pumpkin muffins or cake, homemade applesauce, pumpkin or butternut squash soup, roasted root veggies like carrots, parsnips, or brussel sprouts, and then adding pecans and walnuts to everything.
Thanksgiving for us has become more of a hassle than a great get together, I know that's sad, but our family is just having a hard time getting together and enjoying each other instead of tension and fighting. I like the idea of not focusing on what I like to think of as a dreaded holiday
I agree. Why wait for Thanksgiving. Getting together with family and friends can be done anytime. Make it special, make it count. It's all about spending time together and eating great food. My favorite "fried turkey".
We put so much emphasis on one day celebration, it is not even funny to remember all the stress it brings it on all the family. Trying to have a perfect setting with perfect food kills the mood.
I do enjoy lots of filling salads, soup and grilled cheese sandwiches until Thanksgiving and between Thanksgiving and Christmas. Only way for me to balance heavy casseroles and desserts.
I am so grateful for pumpkin this time of year and have feel like I have a mini desert every morning when I eat my oatmeal. I am also loving squash, soups, stews and other hearty and nourishing meals as it has finally turned cold here in Northern California.
My meals are totally pumpkin-based right now. Pumpkin cream cheese on my breakfast, pumpkin soup for lunch, pumpkin butter w/cottage cheese, pumpkin muffins, pumpkin stock in the freezer....I love it all! I pureed the pulp from 2 pumpkins we had on our porch once Halloween had passed, so I will have a very tasty pre-Thanksgiving November :)
I've never understood the mass freak out over Thanksgiving. You're right- its just a big meal. I think food sites (this one is just as guilty!) up the hysteria and make it a bigger deal than it is. Every food site right now is flocked with "NEW way to make your sweet potatoes!" and "the unique awesome, innovative cranberry relish of 2011, because canned cranberry is so passe!" type stuff and its like...why?
Yes, I get many of ya'll try new fun dishes for thanksgiving, but like Faith said, for the most part, we read this stuff but its still sweet potatoes, turkey, cranberry, repeat every year (whatever your family preferences are.) And not to mention all the panic and articles treating cooking a turkey dinner like its comparable to brain surgery. It makes people worry that wouldn't have in the first place!
At least in our house, thanksgiving gets zero forethought. Some time the week before, we hit the grocery and get all the goods- for the same dishes we always do. Day of, we cook. Casually. I'm sure if my family was of the more name cards and place settings type thanksgiving mindset we'd stress a bit more, but I don't see the point. Its a nice dinner together, why pretend were going to eat it any differently than we do dinner together any of the other 364 days of the year?
(Anyone notice the articles creeping in about how you should be freaking out about not having all your christmas cookies ready to go by now? Christmas is just as guilty of this!)
@jmorri26 well, I agree to a point, but as the author of the post, I do want to say that I wasn't knocking ALL planning for Thanksgiving. Having a bunch of people over IS an intimidating thing for a lot of people, especially new cooks (and go them for taking on a big feast like this - so fun!). So we do want to offer resources; we see lots of people searching for those things. Plus, for some folks, it's just really fun to plan certain aspects of a feast (I definitely geek out over table settings - not because I feel obliged to at ALL - just because I enjoy it).
So, my point is mainly that Thanksgiving isn't ALL that November has going on. And your relaxed Thanksgiving sounds totally wonderful - we should all be so lucky!
Faith- I totally agree (Didn't mean to come off harsh in my post!) I enjoy reading the planning posts all month. And yes, for newer cooks or those cooking for a large, hefty group, I know that it's quite intimidating and these things are tremendously helpful! I think my point was same as yours just a little rougher on the edges- November is already stuck between Halloween and already encroaching Christmastime and it's nice to not spend the whole month worrying over one meal when there's so much more to enjoy.
@jmorri26 totally!! I get so grumpy about cranberry sauce right about now. :) (And have you read that Schrambling piece - SO funny.)
I actually have a bone to pick with Christmas-- we have nothing between Halloween and Christmas up here in the Great White North (that's Canada) and the Xmas decorations/music/advertising is in full swing...November-friggin-first (I have seen Xmas ads on TV prior to Halloween, even). By the time mid-December shows up, I can't wait for Christmas to GTFO, already. It's insanity.
@modestalmond
We don't celebrate Thanksgiving, and even Halloween is still pretty much a non-event, so the shops and malls in South Africa get their Christmas stuff out at the end of October.
I store up ideas from this site and others for next year, since we're now heading into summer.
The comments from the international people is exactly why I REALLY love Thanksgiving...keeps Christmas madness (a little more, anyway) in check. If we didn't have Thanksgiving, everyone would be putting up their X-mas decorations right after taking down their Halloween stuff. Granted, I've seen a few houses do this anyway, but the general consensus is that those people are crazy.
This will be my third year of hosting Thanksgiving and I can't get enough of all the Thanksgiving recipes and guides. I'm totally addicted to them. Sorry! I like that they make it okay no to serve the same dish that your mom or grandmom did...especially for someone like me who's gluten-free and can't eat the traditional green bean casserole w/ the fried onions on top.
I like Thanksgiving, but all the pressure to have the perfect day, the perfect meal, is way too much. I always used to have the holidays with my parents and sister, but now that my father's in a nursing home, I think my mother and sister don't feel like there's anything to celebrate. So the last few years, my boyfriend and I have gone out to a nice buffet, then we bundle up and take a long walk before coming back to our little house and relaxing. And I'm really enjoying this new tradition--no pressure, no stress, just a lovely meal, enjoying the weather and each other. And it seems to get more to the heart of the holiday: celebrating and treasuring what's wonderful in your life.