Weekend Pasta Report: Success!

We expected a bit of trial and error, perhaps a snafu or two. We hoped we'd end up with some good pasta, or at least a good story to share with you. Never did we imagine that making pasta would be so...well...easy!
Pin it button
We only made straight egg pasta a few times in culinary school, and I always remember it being a very laborious process. I'm guessing those memories are slightly colored by the general anxiety and sleep-deprivation I was experiencing those days. Plus, my personal standard of excellence is probably a bit lower than my chef-instructor's...

From start to finish, making this pasta took us about an hour and a half, including 30 minutes in the middle to rest the dough. I mixed the dough and kneaded it by hand, used a hand-cranked roller to make the pasta sheets, and then hand-cut the pasta into wide pappardelle-esque noodles. During cooking, the noodles floated to the top very quickly, but I let them boil for a few extra minutes to cook out the raw taste.

My guests and I ate about half the noodles straight out of the bowl with just butter and salt, but managed to save enough for dinner. These noodles were irresistibly chewy and made a nice backdrop to the beef stew we served as our main course. So good. We'll definitely be making pasta more often from now on!

Pin it button
Here are some afterthoughts:

• Have everything set out. We had the roller at one end of the counter with the cutting board right beside it. A sheetpan waited at the very end for the finished pasta. We had our tub of flour right in the middle for easy access at all times.

• Once you start to roll out the pasta, use more flour than you think you need. I stressed this in our tutorial last Friday, but apparently I have trouble following my own advice - there were a few close calls with sheets of pasta sticking to itself while waiting to be cut into ribbons!

• Work in small batches. This is also something that we mentioned last week, but I think it bears repeating. It would be easy to look at the little softball-sized piece of dough in your hand and think, "Ah, heck. Why not do it all in one go?" But that dough stretches out a lot. Even working with a quarter of the dough at a time, by the time we got to the thinner settings, we had two feet of pasta lying on our counter!

• If you're using a hand-crank pasta roller like ours, it really helps to have another person. I started off by myself, but quickly called in reinforcements to help turn the crank and feed the dough through the machine. Boy, do I miss those fancy Kitchenaid pasta attachments from culinary school...

• It's not necessary to always go down to the thinnest setting. We rolled our pasta to the second-to-last setting, and I would have liked it a little thicker. As a side note, I also would have liked the noodles a little shorter, but I think getting the hang of that will just be trial and error.

Did anyone else make pasta this weekend? How did it go?

Related: Dry Pasta vs. Fresh Pasta: What's the Difference?

(Images: Emma Christensen for the Kitchn)

12 Comments