• Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams
Usually I'll advise you to make your own holiday goodies; what's more special than a treat from your own kitchen? But I'll make an exception for Jeni's, based in my own hometown of Columbus, Ohio. This collection lets you and your sweetie have something special on Valentine's. It includes the award-winning Cherry Lambic Sorbet (boozy!), Wildberry Lavender, Ugandan Vanilla, and not one but three chocolate ice creams: Askinosie Dark Milk, Dark Chocolate (extremely fudgy), and - my favorite chocolate ice cream of all time - The Milkiest Chocolate in the World, with good milk chocolate, and local Ohio cream and honey. Splendid does not even begin.