Tip: The Secret to Baking Perfectly Browned Cookies Every Time

Tip: The Secret to Baking Perfectly Browned Cookies Every Time

Anjali Prasertong
Dec 16, 2013
(Image credit: PJ Hamel/King Arthur Flour)

You've double-checked your oven temperature. You're using a reliable recipe. Yet your cookies are coming out too brown on the bottom, or perhaps pale and under-baked. What gives? The savvy folks at the King Arthur Flour blog may have found the problem — as well as a simple solution that ensures perfectly browned cookies every time.

The short answer: it's all about the pan you use.

PJ Hamel at King Arthur Flour's excellent baking blog decided to run some side-by-side cookie tests using aluminum sheet pans with various surfaces, including one with a very shiny finish, a standard half-sheet pan, a specialized King Arthur Flour baking sheet, and a much-loved sheet pan blackened by years of use. She baked on each pan both with and without parchment paper, and the results can be seen in the above-left photo.

The pans used, from top to bottom: old and blackened pan; King Arthur Flour pan; standard half-sheet pan; and shiny finish pan.

As you can see, the old, dark-finish pan turned out cookies that were far too brown, while the pan with a very shiny finish produced pale-bottomed cookies. Parchment paper helped, but the real solution, says Hamel, is taking the surface of your baking sheet into account when determining baking time. The above-right photo shows cookies baked on the same pans, with adjusted cooking times — a little shorter for the darker-colored pans and longer for the shiny pan — which produced evenly browned cookies. (Half-sheet pans, our favorite kitchen workhorses, needed no adjustments.)

Bottom line: if you're in the market for new cookie sheets, half-sheet pans are the way to go. But if you already have a stockpile of less-than-ideal cookie sheets, there's no need to replace them. Just remember to line them with parchment paper and adjust the baking time accordingly when making a batch of cookies.

Read more: The Secret to Perfectly Browned Cookies at Flourish, the King Arthur Flour blog

Do you have any tips for baking better cookies?

KitchnVideo of the Day
Group 12 Created with Sketch. Untitled-2 Untitled-3 rss