apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Recipe Review: Ina Garten's Lemon Cake

2009_04_13-Cake03.jpgEaster is one time of year when I am seized with the desire to bake a pretty cake. I always feel that the Easter meal should be one of the most special of the year, and what's more special than a lovingly decorated spring cake? So this year I jumped in feet-first and went looking for the best lemon cake recipe and the best buttercream, and then I even dared to try a Martha Stewart icing technique!

Read on to see a few cake decorating tips, and our thoughts on this lemon cake.

 
 

2009_04_13-Cake03.jpgFirst, all about the recipe. I was looking for a really good lemon cake recipe, with plenty of lemon zing and not too difficult to whip up. I found review after review of Ina Garten's lemon pound cake recipe, which is usually baked in a loaf pan and drenched with lemon syrup and drizzled with glaze.

So I went for it, and baked the recipe in two 9" cake tins, and they baked up beautifully. They were easy to put together, and the pound cake texture was a great thing to work with when leveling and frosting the cakes. The crumb is finer and denser, while still soft.

And the lemon syrup gave this such a kick of lemon! The cakes already had the zest of about seven lemons, but the syrup put it over the top. Tender, sweet, and so tangy.

2009_04_13-Cake02.jpgI used a basic Swiss buttercream for the icing, and this was very light and creamy -- not too sweet. I substituted about a cup of shortening for some of the butter; this can help the buttercream emulsify. It also just felt lighter and creamier than an all buttercream icing.

A few more tips from the icing process:

1 Level the dome off the cake - This cake doesn't have much of a dome, but slicing it off will help you get an even, flat top. Freeze the top and save up your cake scraps to make a batch of cake pops in the future.
2 Use a rotating cake base - Even an inexpensive rotating cake base like this one will make icing a cake so much easier.
3 Do a crumb coat on the cake first - I almost always do a thin layer of icing (called a crumb coat) on the cake and let it sit in the fridge for an hour. Then I do a second coat over that smoothed-out surface to polish it off.
4 Set up all your icing ahead of time - When doing some more involved decorations like flowers or piped dots, set up each color in a disposable bag with the appropriate tip. It's such a pain (and often messy!) to try to change tips or set up bags while in the middle of a project.
5 Practice decorations on wax paper first! - I was so smitten by those chrysanthemum cupcakes from Martha Stewart that I wanted to try my own. I experimented with the flowers first on wax paper, though, to get a feel for them before trying them on the cake.

I still don't think my flowers looked quite like Martha's (of course!) but I did love the bright colors and the fun three-dimensional flowers. I don't know if I would call them chrysanthemums (sea anemones, perhaps)? But my Easter guests loved it, and the cake itself with the tangy lemon and light, creamy icing was a wonderful way to end an Easter meal.

2009_04_13-Cake01.jpgGet the cake recipe: Lemon Cake by Ina Garten at Leite's Culinaria
Get the frosting recipe: Basic Cooked Buttercream Frosting or Swiss Buttercream
Chrysanthemums! Chrysanthemum Cupcakes

Related: How To Make Individual Easter Egg Cakes

(Images: Faith Durand)

Tags

Sweets, Holidays - Easter, Recipe Review, baking, cake, Barefoot Contessa, Ina Garten, lemon cake

Share

Comments (14)

That's one gorgeous cake, boss!

posted by Dana V on April 13th 2009 at 4:58pm
view Dana V's profile

Beautiful! The description of the lemony tanginess made my mouth water.

What is a crumb coat?

posted by heather77 on April 13th 2009 at 5:13pm
view heather77's profile

@heather77 - I updated so that is a bit more clear.

posted by faith on April 13th 2009 at 5:18pm
view faith's profile

For flowers that are that full or other buttercream decorations you can also make them on wax/parchement paper and then freeze them. This works best when you put the paper on something metal like a sheet pan or a tray or something. Then you just slip a metal spatula or knife with thin blade underneath to remove and pop them onto the cake. This way you don't have to worry about messing up the final product. This won't work with thin flowers with a single layer of petals but would be perfect for these.

posted by travers on April 13th 2009 at 7:50pm
view travers's profile

Great tip, travers! Thanks!

posted by annaholl on April 14th 2009 at 3:18am
view annaholl's profile

So nice! I'm on a sudden cake-kick this year and this one goes on the list.

posted by cmcinnyc on April 14th 2009 at 9:46am
view cmcinnyc's profile

Thank you for explaining the crumb coat. I was envisioning coating the cake with crumbs ;-)

posted by heather77 on April 14th 2009 at 10:14am
view heather77's profile

The cake looks lovely but I am really entranced by the cake stand. Do you care to share where one might find something like that?

posted by figbash on April 14th 2009 at 2:12pm
view figbash's profile

Wow - that is beautiful!

posted by david @ justveggingout.com on April 14th 2009 at 2:35pm
view david @ justveggingout.com's profile

@figbash, my sister gave it to me for Christmas. I think she found it at TJ Maxx?

posted by faith on April 14th 2009 at 3:00pm
view faith's profile

You should have spring flowers on an Easter cake, not fall-blooming chrysanthemums. I was going through a pile of clipped recipes for Easter ideas recently, and found instructions from an old MSL for making daffodils from cut and candied lemon peel. I finally decided to make one of her desserts of the month for Easter, a lemon-yogurt mousse tart, topped with stewed rhubarb. It was springlike and excellent, even without lemon peel daffodils.

posted by ellenwillmott on April 14th 2009 at 7:20pm
view ellenwillmott's profile

Very pretty! Thanks for sharing the recipe, I've been hoping to find a recipe for a more sturdy lemon cake. Dorie's perfect party cake is delicious, but not really sturdy enough to stand up to fondant covering, this looks like it will work beautifully.

posted by jennywenny on April 15th 2009 at 11:39am
view jennywenny's profile

@jennywenny, yes - this is definitely sturdy enough for fondant. It would be a great cake for carving, too.

@ellenwillmott - I did actually have that same thought, but wanted to try out the chrysanthemum technique. I don't worry too much about seasonality when the flowers are made out of frosting - LOL! I will have to check out the lemon peel daffodils, though - they sound lovely.

posted by faith on April 15th 2009 at 8:12pm
view faith's profile

Ina's cake is divine. I have made it many times and it's always a hit. The frosted version looks fun.

posted by Kit on May 12th 2009 at 2:41pm
view Kit's profile