apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Sweet Cornbread: Delicious Treat or Vicious Crime Against Southerners?

2008_06_04-cornbreadsouthernliving.jpgSoutherners take cornbread seriously. There are long impassioned debates about whether or not to include eggs and buttermilk, what kind of fat to use (and how much), and even whether it's best to bake it in a skillet or a pan.

But, at least amongst the southerners we know, one thing that's generally agreed upon is that sweet cornbread is for yankees.

 
 

Oh sure, you might eat a sweet corn johnnycake at breakfast, or have a sweetened corn pudding, but as far as this writer's concerned, a piece of proper southern cornbread has no added sweetener at all. It should sing with the full flavor of corn, and the caramelization of its deep golden brown crust. (Those of us with a strong sweet tooth have been known to save a piece to drizzle it with honey or molasses for an after-dinner treat.)

At our southern family's tables, as soon as that basket of fresh-from-the-oven savory cornbread is set down, we're reaching for a piece. But here in the north, we've learned to politely just say no, after being surprised one too many times by a dessert-worthy extra-sweet piece of corncake.


Related: Yeast Raised Cornbread

Image: Charles Walton for Southern Living

Tags

Surveys, bread, sweet, cornbread, johnnycakes, quickbreads

Share

Comments (15)

No sugar, no flour, bacon grease, iron skillet. Anything else is not cornbread to me.

posted by norma on June 4th 2008 at 6:00am
view norma's profile

I'm not a southerner. The closest I've ever gotten to the south is Washington DC.

I find that sugary stuff disgusting. The things they sell as cornbread at Boston Market should be frosted and sold as cupcakes.

In our household, all members of the house except me cut open their cornbread and pour syrup or honey on top. I think that is so disgusting I can hardly stand to be at the same table as the rest of them, but to each his own. I also don't care for cornbread except maybe once or twice a decade, but we have to have it once or twice a month. Oh well. Sacrifice is the passion of great souls, as someone somewhere said.

posted by ADonuts on June 4th 2008 at 6:09am
view ADonuts's profile

Bacon grease is the secret, fo' sho'. But then again, doesnt bacom bmake everything better?

posted by marthachick on June 4th 2008 at 6:19am
view marthachick's profile

I'm a southerner, and I like both! Definitely ate no-sugar cornbread growing up (in the cast iron molds shaped like ears of corn...) but one of my favorite recipes now is from the Richmond, Va. Junior League cookbook. Blue Ribbon Cornbread- and it has a touch of sugar. Love them both.

posted by Elizabeth P on June 4th 2008 at 6:42am
view Elizabeth P's profile

It varies. Southerners make both dry/salty cornbread and sweet/moist cornbread. (I refer you to my two Georgian-born-and-bread grandmothers. One makes it sweet and cakey; the other salty and sandy. The debate - hell, fight!- will last to the death. Literally.)

Although "sweet" by Southern standards does not seem to be the same as "sweet" by Northern standards. Southerners use sweeteners (usually honey) to enhance the corn flavor; in some Northern cornbread, it's the only flavor. Really, I think that's the key. For Southerners, corn - usually fresh - is the star of the show. Cornmeal alone just doesn't cut it.

posted by katiebug on June 4th 2008 at 6:59am
view katiebug's profile

I prefer savory cornbread myself. But I think Palapa Azul's Sweet Corn ice cream has to be the best thing ever made from corn:

http://www.palapaazul.com/product.php?pid=16

posted by hazelnut_spread on June 4th 2008 at 7:00am
view hazelnut_spread's profile

I like both - I used to work at a restaurant that made a sweet, moist, cakey cornbread to die for. I also like it super old-fashioned dipped in molasses!

But I also like it a little drier and savory with sage or bacon and collard greens.

posted by faith on June 4th 2008 at 9:58am
view faith's profile

Any recommendations for fats to use in cornbread if no bacon fat is available?

posted by Michelle of Montreal on June 4th 2008 at 10:24am
view Michelle of Montreal's profile

michelle: lard is first choice. the drippings out of a cast iron pan that has had any salty meat cooked in it (cut with canola oil if you need more), sausage drippings, etc. will also do. barring that, you can find some 'healthy' shortening at some grocery stores, basically a cleaned up version of crisco that doesn't have hydrogenated oils in it.


and why can't i answer the survey? (#3!)

posted by lindsey kathlene on June 4th 2008 at 2:41pm
view lindsey kathlene's profile

I hear all the debates,but can someone post the recipe for the cornbread in the photo please? Thanks

posted by jaudre on June 4th 2008 at 5:34pm
view jaudre's profile

Jaudre - it's there in the image credit.
http://find.myrecipes.com/recipes/recipefinder.dyn?action=displayRecipe&recipe_id=257354#

Enjoy!

posted by NinaC on June 4th 2008 at 6:15pm
view NinaC's profile

I grew up in Pennsylvania and I hate sweet corn bread. I have given up on most restaurant corn bread because they are always too cakey. The one exception is Perkins. They make really good corn muffins - just the natural sweetness of corn and the grittiness of real corn meal in every bit. Delicious grilled and buttered. Sadly they do not seem to have them at every location.

posted by ChapstickAddict on June 4th 2008 at 10:06pm
view ChapstickAddict's profile

I'll take cornbread of any style: savory, sweet, cakey, dry, full of veggies and herbs, cheese, from the skillet... all of it. There's a kind of cornbread for any meal.

posted by Miss Pea on June 5th 2008 at 12:56pm
view Miss Pea's profile

My Grandmother was from Louisiana, she passed on sweet cornbread to my mother, both sides of my Texas family have always had it sweet. I have never heard that sweet cornbread is for Yankees.

posted by Siren223 on June 5th 2008 at 1:46pm
view Siren223's profile

Growing up my mom would buy those little mixes (Jiffy, the blue box) and man were they sweet. My dad loved it! I moved out years ago, and he still talks about the cornbread I'd make...

posted by ashleym (aka autzve on flickr) on June 6th 2008 at 1:13pm
view ashleym (aka autzve on flickr)'s profile