apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Survey: How Do You Roast Your Chicken?

2009_03_24-chicken.jpgRoasting a whole chicken is about the chickeniest thing we can think to do with a bird. It's not the easiest, though (getting the skin crisp, keeping the meat moist...) And there are many, many methods. Do you salt your bird and let it sit overnight, Zuni-style? Do you use lemon? Inside or out?

 
 

We find that the Zuni method of salting and drying out the bird results in fewer grease splatters on the inside of our oven. But we also love to mash up soft butter with a bunch of herbs and spread it under the skin.

We have a family member who fills syringes with melted butter and injects his Thanksgiving turkeys. Maybe that's a trick for chickens, too?

What are your best roasting tips? Let us know!

Related: Tip: Finishing Undercooked Chicken Breasts in the Oven

(Image: Flickr user freeloosedirt, licensed for use under Creative Commons)

Tags

Surveys, roast chicken

Share

Comments (30)

I like to put butter underneath the skin. One time I also basted the skin beforehand with a mixture of honey and oil. It turned out quite well.

posted by Kitalita on March 24th 2009 at 9:10am
view Kitalita's profile

My roast chicken is Chinese style:
-rub with cooking wine
-rub with dark soy
-spice rub: ginger powder, fine ginger powder (aka "sand ginger"), garlic powder, salt and a little sugar

Best when it marinates overnight before roasting.

posted by Michelle of Montreal on March 24th 2009 at 9:20am
view Michelle of Montreal's profile

I put Herbes de Provence and Garlic under the skin and roast it upright--the skin gets crisp, the meat stays moist, and there's almost no mess, provided that you put a roasting pan under the doohicky that keeps the bird upright.

posted by bocadelperro on March 24th 2009 at 9:49am
view bocadelperro's profile

Hammersley's Walk Away Roast chicken is lovely, though I've adjusted the recipe a little. SO easy!
Recipe is here on the new Pithy and Cleaver:
http://www.pithyandcleaver.com/?p=135

posted by maggie (p/c) on March 24th 2009 at 9:50am
view maggie (p/c)'s profile

Exactly like bebklyn.

posted by PrettyKitty on March 24th 2009 at 9:50am
view PrettyKitty's profile

Usually I empty the chicken of gibblets, wash it and pat it dry, then salt it, pepper it, add basil, thyme and oregano and maybe a little red pepper flake. Toss it in the oven for an hour at 350-375. When it comes down, I take a stick of butter and rub it all over the skin (the whole stick doesn't get used...it just makes a good handle). Comes out perfect everytime!

posted by bfootnovellista on March 24th 2009 at 9:59am
view bfootnovellista's profile

Sometimes I stuff with lemons, sometimes I rub with Penzey's Northwoods Fire Seasoning (generally don't bother with blends, but that one I love), but if I want a plain chicken, I use a trick I found in an old cookbook. I blend butter with equal parts dry mustard, ground ginger and salt, and rub that under the skin. That blend of flavors does something lovely to the chicken - it tastes more "chickeny," without actually tasting like any particular spice. Very useful if you want a basic roast chicken for use in another recipe (like a chicken salad), or if your side dishes have a lot of pizazz and you want to keep the chicken on the quiet side. (If I have the chicken the night before, I rub the salt into the skin and let it sit, then I skip the salt in the butter mix).

posted by pyewacket on March 24th 2009 at 9:59am
view pyewacket's profile

I roast (usually) chicken legs, but I've tried this method with whole chickens and works just as nicely.

1. Place chicken on an oven dish/tray/wherever.
2. Crumble a bouillon cube (chicken) over it.
3. Juice a lemon (bottled lemon juice doesn't really work well) over it.
4. Ready to roast.

It's so easy, you don't add any fat and the results... just try it before judging.

posted by xieta on March 24th 2009 at 10:08am
view xieta's profile

Huh. I don't find it that difficult. :)

I always brine my birds first, then stuff the body cavity with whatever I have available (ranges from herbs from my garden, to garlic, to lemons, to apples ... or any combination of the above), then rub the skin with olive oil and salt.

That's pretty much it. Easy and fast.

(ps - Any time I try to post a comment from any browser other than IE, I get a "500 Internal Server Error" message.)

posted by KaraSP on March 24th 2009 at 10:07am
view KaraSP's profile

what timing, I just roasted a chicken last night. Outside: lemon juice, olive oil, s&p. inside: the remaining lemons, fistfuls of thyme, rosemary, and garlic, and I'll also stuff some of this under the skin. I roast on top of some veggies, whatever I have around that day, and have always deliciously browned skin with very tender meat.

posted by phu on March 24th 2009 at 10:30am
view phu's profile

Funny you should ask! I actually put my method down as a step-by-step process in case anyone needs that much guidance:

http://danamccauley.wordpress.com/2008/09/23/how-to-roast-a-chicken/

in a nutshell: I'm an oil and seasonings on the outside and aromatics on the inside kinda girl.

posted by Dana McCauley on March 24th 2009 at 10:47am
view Dana McCauley's profile

@KaraSP -- I was doing a little work on the comment server this morning. It's been a bit overloaded lately, so I had to rework some of the internals. If you're still having trouble, try visiting the logout link:

http://www.apartmenttherapy.com/superlogout

... and then try to login again. If that doesn't work, you can email me at scott@apartmenttherapy.com

posted by Scott T. on March 24th 2009 at 10:49am
view Scott T.'s profile

Mmm, this is making me crave a roast chicken RIGHT NOW...

posted by Brooklynnina on March 24th 2009 at 10:54am
view Brooklynnina's profile

I usually rub a paste of garlic, salt, olive oil, pepper, rosemary, paprika, and lemon juice as far under the skin as possible, and put lemons and garlic in the cavity.

posted by heather77 on March 24th 2009 at 11:03am
view heather77's profile

Balthazar style - herb butter under the skin, herbs & garlic inside. Sear the outside before roasting for a great burnished look and crispy skin.

posted by preppycuisine on March 24th 2009 at 11:47am
view preppycuisine's profile

Just roasted some legs and thighs a few nights ago. Cut potatoes, onions - toss them in olive oil, salt, pepper. Add chicken - toss in olive oil, salt, pepper, regular ol' italian seasoning mix, and then drizzle everything in balsamic vinegar and lemon. Slow roast for about an hour - fall off the bone goodness. And if you're going to reheat, do it in the oven, low and slow. sooo good.

posted by chusmabilly on March 24th 2009 at 11:59am
view chusmabilly's profile

Zuni style indeed. The key is high heat. Cooks fast, crispy skin, moist inside. I usually bake at anywhere from 475 up to nearly 500 degrees. 20 minutes breast up, 15 flipped over, and 15-20 up again.

posted by s and the r on March 24th 2009 at 12:14pm
view s and the r's profile

I always, ALWAYS butterfly it ala Cooks Illustrated. Use a shears to snip the carcass down the center of the back and then open it up so it lays flatish on a sheet pan/rack or layer of veg.
Cooks in about 1/2 the time and much more evenly, plus you get 100% of the skin nice and crispy. Best method ever and almost impossible to screw up, regardless of the oven temp you use.
For seasonings, I'm partial to dry rosemary/herbs, garlic, salt, and pepper ground to a paste with a mortar and pestle plus enough olive oil to make it spreadable. Smear over the whole carcass, inside and out.

posted by splatgirl on March 24th 2009 at 12:34pm
view splatgirl's profile

I learned from my father and his father. You take your chicken wash it then sprinkle the whole exterior with season salt (peprika, salt, garlic powder, chili powder), then some Mrs Dash type stuff on the inside. Tye the legs together and place it breast down, (so that the jucies flavor the white meat) straight onto your hot bbq over a nice bead of coals. No turning nessicary if you get the temp around 300/350 and let it cook till it falls apart. The skin is super crispy and the meat is juicy and smokey.

posted by Aquablood on March 24th 2009 at 12:48pm
view Aquablood's profile

I usually do butter, mustard, garlic and tarragon or thyme under the skin, and onion with some type of citrus fruit in the cavity.

posted by NYKate on March 24th 2009 at 12:55pm
view NYKate's profile

I cook mine just like splatgirl. I started spatchcocking (butterflying) the bird a year ago, and never looked back. It's the best! I also put lemon slices under the flat carcass - they caramelize and get sweet, and the juice is lovely squeezed over the crispy skin.

posted by pingarina on March 24th 2009 at 1:05pm
view pingarina's profile

I do roast chicken one of two ways --

Either following Simon Hopkinson, with butter, lemon and herbs, usually a "wet roast" with white wine (I sit the chicken on very thick slices of onion -- something I picked up from Martha, which are delicious) --

http://www.seriouseats.com/recipes/2008/01/sunday_supper_simon_hopkinsons_roast_chicken.html

Or, "Bud's Roast Chicken" from Norma Darden's book, Spoonbread and Strawberry Wine, with mustard, herbs, and lemon:

http://www.marthastewart.com/recipe/buds-sunday-roast-chicken?autonomy_kw=bud's%20roast%20chicken&rsc=header_2

posted by mschatelaine on March 24th 2009 at 3:13pm
view mschatelaine's profile

PAPER BAGS!

My secret is roasting the chicken in a paper bag. Rub the outside of the bird with a little bit of crisco, rub the inside of the bag with crisco as well. Stuff whatever you want into the bird, season with any seasonings you choose, place in paper bag and staple shut.

Roast in oven at 350 for 12 minutes per pound or until internal temp reaches 165.

Golden brown, moist and juicy, LOVE IT.

posted by Hannah Ruth on March 24th 2009 at 3:58pm
view Hannah Ruth's profile

Someone showed me this years ago and claimed it was a "heritage trailer trash recipe": Make a paste of olive oil and Lipton dried onion soup mix. Slather chicken and roast. It turns out surprisingly well.

posted by Paladin on March 24th 2009 at 5:40pm
view Paladin's profile

I have been known to use: oil, soy sauce, herbs, garlic, salt, pepper, mecap sauce, onion, lemons...

posted by buda on March 24th 2009 at 6:27pm
view buda's profile

doesn't really matter, but i wonder where my post went... it must have been up earlier, PrettyKitty referred to it.

just thought i'd point out there might be a glitch.

posted by bebklyn on March 24th 2009 at 6:39pm
view bebklyn's profile

I rub it down in bacon fat! Yummmmm. then whatever herbs my kid comes back with from the garden. honestly, she can't tell the difference between oregano and thyme. geez.

posted by little green on March 24th 2009 at 8:53pm
view little green's profile

i brine it for an hour in a sugar/salt water, butterfly the chicken, rub 1 tbl butter on it and sprinkle liberally with salt and pepper. before i started to butterfly it the thighs and drumsticks were always dry and tough. now everything is perfectly cooked! we make it once a week.
i cook it on a broiler pan. if we're feeling really naughty we fill the bottom of the pan with carrots and potatoes. they cook in the drippings and are amazing. greasy, but amazing.

http://threadtrace.wordpress.com

posted by cassiopia on March 24th 2009 at 9:43pm
view cassiopia's profile

Mmmmmmmmm.....lots of garlic, kosher salt, and then whatever I'm in the mood for. Sometimes chili powder, sometimes rosemary, sometimes paprika...

Some of my favorite recipes lately are:

http://thepioneerwoman.com/cooking/2009/03/braised-chicken/

http://www.kayotic.nl/blog/?p=2351

posted by AlaskaTeacher on March 25th 2009 at 1:53am
view AlaskaTeacher's profile

I'd use the elaborate basting/buttering/seasoning approaches if I were stuck cooking a chicken-in-a-bag that I had to *make* taste good an moist.

But then I tried a really good free-range bird, and now I only use Thomas Keller's simple recipe from Bouchon: pat that sucker as dry as you can, rain a good coating of kosher salt over it, and roast it in a hot oven (450) for about an hour. Eat it with unsalted butter and good dijon mustard.

Unbelievably tasty.

posted by elvedon on March 25th 2009 at 3:35pm
view elvedon's profile