apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Poll: Do You Salt Your Watermelon?

2007_07_02-Watermelon-Salt.jpgIn our watermelon thread last Friday, a commenter asked a question we were thinking about too: who puts salt on their watermelon? This was a very strange and foreign concept until recently when we tried it, and the piquancy of the salt did indeed bring out a little more of the melon's sweetness, concentrating the juices . If you want to try it yourself, just sprinkle a bit of salt on a cold wedge of watermelon, or get fancy and try this Watermelon with Fennel Salt recipe from The Splendid Table.

Will you put salt on your watermelon this July 4th?

 
 

Tags

Surveys, Summer, Ingredients - Fruit

Related Links

Share

Comments (53)

I put salt on all my fruit, especially melons, pineapple and strawberries. Granted, I'm a salt addict, but I think they taste better that way.

posted by Kassie on July 2nd 2007 at 7:18am
view Kassie's profile

Growing up in Texas, most of my family members put salt on their watermelon and canteloupe. It was never my thing though.

posted by iheartveggies on July 2nd 2007 at 7:31am
view iheartveggies's profile

This is also a very asian thing to do, but I never bought into it either.

I am a huge fan, however, of squeezing fresh lime juice over watermelon slices and fruit salad. I've been doing it all summer, and its great. I like the sour/sweet over the salty/sweet.

posted by Rog on July 2nd 2007 at 7:34am
view Rog's profile

The very BEST way to eat watermelon is with Greek feta cheese. Cut up the watermelon into bite-sized pieces and sprinkle feta cheese over it. So delicious.

posted by Sea on July 2nd 2007 at 7:34am
view Sea's profile

I used salt when I was a kid, because my Southern family always did. I stopped as an adult.

posted by Kelly H on July 2nd 2007 at 7:38am
view Kelly H's profile

My (asian) family likes to put salt on fresh pineapple, but I'd never heard of it on watermelon....seems very strange to me in either case.

posted by Michelle of Montreal on July 2nd 2007 at 7:39am
view Michelle of Montreal's profile

Rog-
Try mixing up a couple lime juice, honey and shredded fresh mint (all amounts to taste) to make a dressing for your watermelon - it is the only way we eat it! Yum, now I want some!

posted by Jeni_Rae on July 2nd 2007 at 8:01am
view Jeni_Rae's profile

One parent is asian and the other is southern, so yes... Salt on the fruit, absolutely.

Definitely going to try feta cheese, never heard of it but it sounds delicious!

posted by mjoe on July 2nd 2007 at 8:40am
view mjoe's profile

i never did, but it's a very southern thing to do. i have some watermelon in my fridge, maybe i'll give it a try. :)

posted by thinkingwoman on July 2nd 2007 at 8:44am
view thinkingwoman's profile

iheartveggies, my family put salt on cantaloupe too. I was wondering if this was a regional thing but I grew up in CT, with family from CT and Maine, and it seems like most of the other commenters who grew up eating melon this way were/are from the South.
When I asked about this in response to Vanessa's earlier post I forgot about the combination of prosciutto and cantaloupe - a classic combination of something salty with melon, and a very good one - it must have been in the back of my mind because that's what I had for lunch on Saturday!

posted by Tiny Banquet on July 2nd 2007 at 8:46am
view Tiny Banquet's profile

I had no idea that most people DIDN'T put salt on their watermelon.

(Yes, I'm a southerner.)

posted by fuzzy on July 2nd 2007 at 10:36am
view fuzzy's profile

Fuzzy, I was thinking the same thing.

posted by magnuson on July 2nd 2007 at 10:40am
view magnuson's profile

I'm in Minnesota and I salt my watermelon. Heck yes. Fresh ground sea salt on ice-cold, vine-ripened watermelon? Better than life itself.

posted by Bx on July 2nd 2007 at 11:08am
view Bx's profile

What a disgusting idea. Like we don't get enough salt in our food now.

posted by Jaie on July 2nd 2007 at 11:30am
view Jaie's profile

I'm Mexican, so I put salt, lime and powdered chile on all kinds of fruit and jicama ;-)

posted by MamaChilanga on July 2nd 2007 at 12:03pm
view MamaChilanga's profile

I just had this conversation with my boyfriend's family. I had never heard of it, but they -- Jews from Manhattan all -- didn't quite swear by it, but were certainly familiar with it as a way to bring out flavor, citing its similarity to (as mentioned above) cantalope and proscuitto.

posted by calyx on July 2nd 2007 at 12:34pm
view calyx's profile

My first thought - yuck no! But then, I grew up eating cantaloupe with cottage cheese, which is delicious, so perhaps I'll have to give it a try. At the least, watermelon and feta does sound yummy.

posted by Green Me on July 2nd 2007 at 12:49pm
view Green Me's profile

I never knew it was a southern thing until I moved away for school, and people looked at me like I had two heads when I asked for salt for my watermelon. However, those yankees did teach me about the joys of vodka-infused watermelon. Big syringe bottle of vodka watermelon x overnight to soak = yummy goodness :-)

posted by margie on July 2nd 2007 at 1:20pm
view margie's profile

My mom spotted the watermelon/feta combo at an event and has been making it at home ever since. It's MUCH better than it might sound...and she's been adding teeny bits of basil as well. All together, watermelon, feta and basil are really really good. Sounds strange, tastes delicious.

posted by liseah on July 2nd 2007 at 1:35pm
view liseah's profile

Sea: I disagree. The very best way to eat watermelon is to simply eat watermelon. Preferably in over-sized slice form, so one can wear an embarrassingly wide, wet, pink smile.

posted by thebeahive on July 2nd 2007 at 4:57pm
view thebeahive's profile

so, i sprinkled a little kosher salt onto my leftover cubed watermelon from lunch. it was quite good. i might be doing that from now on!

posted by thinkingwoman on July 2nd 2007 at 5:34pm
view thinkingwoman's profile

I'm a southerner too. We always put salt on canteloupe, but we didn't put it on watermelon. Irelate putting salt on melon to the idea of serving it with prosciutto. The salt really brings out the sweetness of the melon.

We ate canteloupe at the dinner table, like a vegetable. We always ate watermelon as a dessert or a treat, which may explain why we didn't salt it.

posted by Charlotte on July 3rd 2007 at 3:28am
view Charlotte's profile

Ice cold watermelon and salt. Now, that's summer.

It seems that the pro-salt group in this line of commentary has a variety of fruity salty recommendations. How great is it that we all have different ideas about this particular combination? I'm going to try these new, fabulous recipes.

An aside observation: it is hot and muggy in the southeast. If one has been working or playing outside all day, a salted watermelon is a perfect way to rehydrate. Perhaps we could consider it an early form of the sports drink? Does anyone else find it a funny coincidence that Gatorade was developed at a university in Florida?

posted by Lucille in CA on July 3rd 2007 at 4:07am
view Lucille in CA's profile

my granddad used to put salt and pepper on all fruit. he also would eat a stick of butter with syrup poured on it. i may be from alabama, but i don't eat like that! and i've had salt on walamelon (as i like to call it) but i like walamelon because it feels so hydrating when you eat it - and i'm a salt fanatic, too, but these two need to be kept separate for me!

posted by elizabeth in AL on July 3rd 2007 at 4:36am
view elizabeth in AL's profile

Sure I salt my watermelon - not all the time as it depends on what I am craving at the moment.
My mom's family always salted watermelon and grapefruit.

posted by Alex in DC on July 3rd 2007 at 8:17am
view Alex in DC's profile

Fresh squeezed lime juice & grated fresh ginger on watermelon is my favorite. I just tried the salt thing & I see the attraction (it's like getting thirsty and quenching your thirst at the same time), but I still prefer the sour/sweet versus the salty/sweet.

posted by robyn on July 3rd 2007 at 8:39am
view robyn's profile

Well as an African-American growing up in Kansas many years ago, we always salted our watermelon and cantaloupe when we ate it and when I moved to Florida as an adult, I realized it was a Southern thing to do also. When I visited Southern California during summers as a youth, I didn't see many others salting the melons like I did.

posted by jumper on July 3rd 2007 at 11:43am
view jumper's profile

liseah - watermelon, feta and mint, v good too - and works well on cocktail sticks with drinks. As a salad adding a few black olives and a drizzle of olive oil can be good on occasion.

Can't wait to try salt.

posted by Lesley - London on July 3rd 2007 at 12:58pm
view Lesley - London's profile

Having family from the South and Asia, we always had salt on our melons. If there's salt, I do, if there's not, I don't.

posted by hs on July 3rd 2007 at 8:27pm
view hs's profile

Delicious, I don't do it all the time, but being Asian and growing up partially in the south, it just went hand in hand. I love ANYTHING with watermelon in it. I too, make the feta watermelon salad a lot--a little feta goes a long way and I always add basil, mint and thinly sliced red onions too!

posted by kimmie on July 4th 2007 at 8:05am
view kimmie's profile

Sal, chile and limon on watermelon "muy chingon!" mamachilanga.
Once you've tasted the latin trifecta there's no turning back.

I think a little mango, jicama, watermelon and cucumber will be on my agenda this evening.

posted by art on July 4th 2007 at 9:41am
view art's profile

Oh, a quick pickling of red onions on watermelon is especially good.

Red onions sliced very thin and marinated with salt, sugar and red wine vinegar.

posted by art on July 4th 2007 at 9:42am
view art's profile

Wow, art, that sounds great. I might be trying that sometime this summer.

posted by thebeahive on July 4th 2007 at 10:28am
view thebeahive's profile

Art - sounds amazing. What do you recommend for comparative quantities - onion to melon? Thx

posted by Lesley - London on July 4th 2007 at 12:51pm
view Lesley - London's profile

Lesley-London,
The onion is used sparingly as a garnish to add a little sour punch to the watermelon. So go as light or heavy as you like. If you were to add goat or feta cheese you may want to go heavier on the pickled onion to cut through the fat of the cheese. I like to make this with toasted hazelnuts, mint, salt and a little bit of extra virgin olive oil and red wine vinegar.

posted by art on July 5th 2007 at 6:12am
view art's profile

Thanks Art, what a lovely recipe. Will do, ideally as soon as the rain relents and we can eat outside again.

posted by Lesley - London on July 5th 2007 at 11:32am
view Lesley - London's profile

Salt, basil and feta for my watermelon salad!

Salt on a fresh slice!

Yum!!

And I'm definitely NOT from the south. I learned to speak french from the canadian channels we got on tv, with better reception that the US stations.

posted by Blue_roses on July 6th 2007 at 9:11am
view Blue_roses's profile

YES, mamachilanga! Salt, chile, limon in a bag with apple slices, yum. But I grew up in southern Arizona, and that was just how the Mexican side of my family ate fruit - I had no idea it was eaten like that anywhere else.
Salt is perfect on pretty much any fruit... but tart crisp apples with the tiniest bit of salt has to be the most perfect flavor in the world to me.

posted by melanie on July 6th 2007 at 9:24am
view melanie's profile

I'm Mexican, so I grew up putting salt on my watermelon as well. It's absolutely delicious! Mango with salt, chile piquin and lime is also fabulous.

posted by Alex on July 6th 2007 at 9:52am
view Alex's profile

I tend to not salt fruit or anything sweet for that matter... kind of defeats the purpose don't you think?

But I'm always ready to try new things so next time I eat watermelon (soon probably) I will sprinkle a little salt on it and give it a try.

PS: How much salt?

posted by Pete ( modernflat.com ) on July 6th 2007 at 12:36pm
view Pete ( modernflat.com )'s profile

I had though about asking where the yes votes were coming from - curious to hear if it was regional. My mom's family is from Kansas and I grew up salting watermelon, grapefruit, cantalope and avocados. These days I'm like several of the posters above - it the salt's in front of me, I'll do it - if not, I won't.

posted by oceandreamer56 on July 6th 2007 at 12:52pm
view oceandreamer56's profile

PS - Pete - usually just a sprinkle - especially if you don't normally add salt to your food. But it's all a matter of taste.

And do sometime try cukes with salt, lime and chili as suggested above - it's making my mouth water just thinking about it.

posted by oceandreamer56 on July 6th 2007 at 1:48pm
view oceandreamer56's profile

I answered that I've never heard of this...but I just remembered when I was younger, my gramma taught me to sprinkle a tiny bit of salt on apple slices (I grew up in B.C. orchard country), so I guess it's a little similar....?

posted by Dorianne on July 6th 2007 at 3:12pm
view Dorianne's profile

Salt and...pepper...nothing Asian about it. I'm African American/Bahamiam.

posted by VickyA on July 6th 2007 at 3:35pm
view VickyA's profile

I used to put salt on apple slices when I was a kid, but salt on watermelon (or any other type of fruit for that matter) sounds very unappealing to me.

posted by krisnic on July 6th 2007 at 7:24pm
view krisnic's profile

For all the folks that are say it's disgusting....Please...Salt on watermellon is great. Salt on a fresh cold slice is just tasty. Before you use words like disgusting how about you try it first. You might like it!

posted by reesecupLIC on July 8th 2007 at 4:07am
view reesecupLIC's profile

i'd never heard of it till i was about 21. same w/ sugar on strawberries. i thought it sounded nasty, but it really enhances the flavor.

posted by mariegael on July 8th 2007 at 6:34pm
view mariegael's profile

I tried this over the weekend. It was rather tasty but nothing to write home about, in my taste opinion. I used regular table salt which seemed to just dissolve into the watermelon. Is the trick to use coarse salt??

posted by LunaC on July 9th 2007 at 5:06am
view LunaC's profile

I had never heard of this until an old roommate said she was shocked that I didn't put salt on watermelon. I tried it and all I could think of was that it tasted like blood. I told her that, and apparently she's never salted her watermelon since!

posted by MadameX on July 9th 2007 at 6:28am
view MadameX's profile

LunaC - nope - table salt and yes, it's supposed to dissolve into the melon. You're not really supposed to taste the salt (unless you really like salt and use a lot) - it's just supposed to enhance the flavor.

Next time, try using varying amounts of salt on each separate bite, until you hit the right amount. Or decide that it's just not for you.

Interesting discussion. Thanks for throwing it out here, Faith.

posted by oceandreamer56 on July 11th 2007 at 10:52am
view oceandreamer56's profile

Best way to eat watermelon: with someone you love and any damn way ya please ;)

I'll give the salt a try. Perhaps if I'm brave, with a sprinkle of the bacon salt I just ordered.

posted by gregory on July 24th 2007 at 8:53am
view gregory's profile

I am not a salt addict, but occasionally a sprinkle of sea salt does make the watermelon seem sweeter!

posted by changer1 on August 13th 2007 at 7:32am
view changer1's profile

Like fuzzy ("I had no idea that most people DIDN'T put salt on their watermelon.") it came as a surprise to find out everyone didn't salt their watermelon!

It was only when I was happily salting and eating and my English husband asked me what on earth I was doing that I found out! To be fair, he did try some and gagged, but I think it's wonderful.

This could be because I was raised in the Southwest by Southern mom but all my friends did too - I guess the Southwest is closer in nature to the South than elsewhere when it comes to fruit!

posted by DeucesWild on July 15th 2009 at 8:42am
view DeucesWild's profile