apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Do You Ever Use Egg "Products"?

2008_11_10-EggProduct.jpgWe've never actually cooked with egg products or liquid eggs like EggBeaters, preferring to stick with whole eggs that we can crack ourselves. But every once in a while we come across a recipe that calls for them. Is there a time and a place for egg substitutes?

 
 

Egg products and egg substitutes are loosely defined as eggs that are removed from their shells before being processed. They can be liquid, frozen, or dried, and they usually have one of two functions: to provide a low-fat/low-cholesterol alternative to whole eggs or to provide pasteurized eggs.

The low-fat kind are mostly egg whites with extra ingredients added to give the color, consistency, and flavor of whole eggs. As you might imagine, this is a common ingredient in low-fat recipes and dieting guidelines.

Pasteurized eggs are primarily used when serving high risk populations including young children, pregnant women, older adults, and people with compromised immune systems. The pasteurization process eliminates any bacteria or diseases that could be harmful to these people. Pasteurized eggs can also be a good choice in raw-egg preparations like mayonnaise and classic buttercream frosting.

Personally, we tend to be suspicious of egg substitutes in our regular cooking because we never know exactly where the eggs came from or how they've been processed. Many egg products are made with eggs that have been graded B or below either because they're older eggs or are flawed in some way. All in all, we prefer the incredible edible egg while it's still in its original shell.

Do you regularly use egg substitutes? Or are there special times when you'll use them over whole eggs?

Related: Eggs, Eggs, and More Eggs: Best Egg Recipes and Products

(Image: Flickr member spike55151 licensed under Creative Commons)

Tags

Surveys, Health, Dairy Products, Food Science, eggs, egg products, egg substitutes, pasteurized eggs

Share

Comments (23)

I have found I prefer real eggs. They are less costly and have much less sodium than most egg products.

posted by VeryDelishVeg on November 10th 2008 at 10:16am
view VeryDelishVeg's profile

Indeed! It's all about moderation. You won't go cholesterol crazy if you take it easy on the serving sizes. But if you're gonna eat eggs, eat eggs lol :)

posted by thehalfie on November 10th 2008 at 10:26am
view thehalfie's profile

I've used them a few times, but the flavor is never quite right. Plus I prefer to buy cage-free, so real eggs are much more appealing to me.

posted by confusednazgul on November 10th 2008 at 10:35am
view confusednazgul's profile

I use them when I'm baking occaisonally. For example, if I'm I'm splitting a pancake recipe in half that calls for one egg, measuring out fake eggs is easier than trying to use only half an egg.

But that's the only time I use them. Never as a substitute for scrambled eggs, etc.

posted by strawny92881 on November 10th 2008 at 10:40am
view strawny92881's profile

I purchase my eggs weekly at the farmers market and this time of year, buy more than one dozen as my baking intensifies. However, I almost always keep a small carton of the substitute product in the fridge and find it useful when I am making a breakfast casserole or something else that calls for more eggs than I have on hand.

posted by rosebud on November 10th 2008 at 10:43am
view rosebud's profile

i've never bought a canister of egg whites, or egg beaters... and most likely never will... Just seeing it in a carton makes me feel like its much more processed and less natural then when its just straight from the egg...

posted by MikeyV on November 10th 2008 at 10:46am
view MikeyV's profile

I actually buy them in a six-pack and keep them in the freezer until I need them. I use real eggs for most everything, but the liquid ones are too convenient for me to resist. It's so easy to dump them in a recipe when I just want to taste some chocolate chip cookie dough, and soon. (Not that cookie dough is labor-intense, but you get the point.) It saves a few steps in cleanup and keeps potential contaminants from, well, contaminating. Unscrew the lid, pour in the eggs, put the cap back on.

I don't usually use them for applications where the eggs are meant to be tasted and seen (like a frittatta), but in baking, yes.

posted by Sprouted in the Kitchen on November 10th 2008 at 10:57am
view Sprouted in the Kitchen's profile

World War II

posted by Lesley - London on November 10th 2008 at 11:03am
view Lesley - London's profile

A carton of egg whites has 1 purpose in my kitchen but it's a vital one: cocktails! Egg white cocktails are trendy, and while it's arguably a little cooler (and cheaper) to just crack and egg and separate the white, it's a lot easier with the carton. It also helps if people are nervous about salmonella (despite the overwhelming odds of not contracting it) as cartoned whites are pasteurized.

posted by Schwartz on November 10th 2008 at 11:27am
view Schwartz's profile

I'm sorry, but it just creeps me out.

posted by moptop on November 10th 2008 at 11:34am
view moptop's profile

Camping! The only time I've used these was on a 10-day rafting/camping trip in Idaho. I took pre-cooked bacon, too! I don't use either at home, but five days down the river, those scrambled eggs with bacon tasted pretty good!

When I had chickens, though, I would freeze beaten eggs in ice cube trays to use during the winter when the hens weren't laying many. So, theoretically, I could do that for camping as well....but I'm not quite that organized.

posted by wvlinz on November 10th 2008 at 11:49am
view wvlinz's profile

I'm not against them, but I'm slightly more paranoid about having an open carton sitting in my fridge than uncracked eggs safely in the shell. Makes no sense, I'm sure, but the eggs are somehow easier to handle portions wise.

If I'm making raw egg goodies for friends, though, I definitely buy boxed egg whites. I know the possibility is very small, but I'd still hate to get someone sick.

Keeping them around for cocktails is an awesome idea - I love gin fizzes, but it's almost impossible to find a place that will serve them.

posted by Kaete on November 10th 2008 at 1:57pm
view Kaete's profile

I love Eggbeaters for the lower number of calories. I've only ever tried the original kind, and I haven't gotten them since they changed their recipe to include some of the yolk. I tried off brand egg whites in a carton once, and they were really gross. I pretty much only use whole eggs for baking or for when I just really want a fried egg.

posted by suzyblue on November 10th 2008 at 2:11pm
view suzyblue's profile

Since I'm a single person household, and I have a sweet tooth, I keep them on hand for single serving baked goodies. (Much easier to measure out 2T than half an egg.) I freeze them in 1 or 2T cubes to and just grab a couple to thaw when I'm in the mood for something.

posted by cara_mia on November 10th 2008 at 2:11pm
view cara_mia's profile

I used the carton of pasteurized egg whites to make buttercream for a baby shower cake, and I'd hope anyone else making frosting for a pregnant woman, young children, or other vulnerable people would do the same.

posted by renata on November 10th 2008 at 2:43pm
view renata's profile

They're really not bad. And if you've ever eaten a fast food breakfast (which I'm sure none of you saints have) than you've eaten egg beaters.

posted by jakelegs on November 10th 2008 at 6:01pm
view jakelegs's profile

*then not than

posted by jakelegs on November 10th 2008 at 6:01pm
view jakelegs's profile

We use them sometimes for omlettes

posted by Nudik on November 10th 2008 at 6:44pm
view Nudik's profile

I see them as a logical replacement in baked recipes if you're worried about getting sick, but I have yet to use them. I'm thinking it might be a wise idea if I wanted to keep some raw cookie dough around as a sweet treat. Maybe freezing them in individual sizes? If I'm cooking eggs for breakfast, however, there is NO way I will use a carton. I buy cage free eggs and they are the best I've had.

Emily

posted by Emily Sneds on November 11th 2008 at 4:01am
view Emily Sneds's profile

Two nutritionists told me to put them into my smoothies because they are pasteurized. I cringed both times.

posted by Mya on November 11th 2008 at 4:07am
view Mya's profile

I don't routinely use them but if a recipe calls for them, that's what I'll get---haven't had any problems.

posted by sally599 on November 11th 2008 at 5:52am
view sally599's profile

I just bought my husband a bag of peeled, hardboiled eggs from Trader Joe's. Mainly because I was just fascinated by the idea of a BAG of hardboiled eggs ;o)

posted by stlellen on November 11th 2008 at 12:18pm
view stlellen's profile

I eat egg beater omelettes all the time, and I like them fine. For most egg dishes, I find egg beaters to be barely distinguishable from real eggs. They are less rich, and this can be noticeable. Certainly, the reason to choose them is that here are very few foods so high protein but low in calories and cholesterol.

posted by yolio on November 11th 2008 at 2:32pm
view yolio's profile