apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Survey: Do You Use a Shopping Cart or a Basket?

2009_03_03-CartBasket.jpgI have a pathological aversion to shopping carts. I don't like being burdened with this giant cart, squeaky in the wheels and awkward in the turns. Regardless of the shopping list, I almost always grab a basket instead. This leads, of course, to strained muscles as I drag along an overloaded basket with bags of flour, jugs of milk, and eggs perched precariously on top. How about you? Do you have strong feelings one way or the other about shopping carts versus baskets?

 
 

I must say that Whole Foods baskets are among the best; have you tried their round, swingy baskets with the netted sides? They are a little hard to carry, but they do hold a lot more. Also, come to think of it, Whole Foods' mini-carts are pretty great too. They are the only carts I'll use there.

Anyone else have idiosyncratic favorites among baskets and carts?

Related: Hot or Not: Self-Checkout Stations at the Grocery Store

(Images: Germes Online; Ernesto Recommends

Tags

Supermarkets, basket, shopping, shopping cart

Share

Comments (38)

I like the Safeway mini-baskets as well. So does the boyfriend, since then he doesn't have to carry the heavy basket! :)

posted by cptnruthless on March 3rd 2009 at 2:35pm
view cptnruthless's profile

I've never really thought about my cart phobia until reading this post. I think it has something to do with freedom of movement, but I always use the baskets. However, I have been known to send my husband for another basket when one got too full half-way through the store.

posted by suthernbell on March 3rd 2009 at 2:42pm
view suthernbell's profile

Definitely a basket if I'm walking or taking public transportation home so I don't end up buying more than I can carry. But if I'm driving and have a long list, I'll grab a cart, although I hate getting into traffic jams with them or having to leave them somewhere to squeeze into a crowded aisle.

posted by Joanna on March 3rd 2009 at 2:44pm
view Joanna's profile

I like the small, double-decker carts at Whole Foods. They're easier to maneuver in tight spaces than traditional carts and the two areas let you separate heavy items from things that would be squashed, like bunches of herbs.

posted by heather77 on March 3rd 2009 at 2:45pm
view heather77's profile

When you are only cooking for one or two its pretty easy to get away with just a basket. Especially if you run to the store on a regular basis for fresh produce etc.

Also I have found it helps me keep me from buying stuff I don't really need if I have a basket rather than a big over sized cart. When faced with the idea of having to lug guilty pleasures like ice cream or soda in a basket they loose almost all of their allure! Ok so sometimes I swing back and grab one or the other as I'm about to check out but it certainly curbs it...

Once in awhile when I am restocking on items I buy in bulk ill grab a cart, usually i'll grab the S.O. as well to push it around for me too!

posted by adamwa on March 3rd 2009 at 2:57pm
view adamwa's profile

I don't know how to drive a car, and that seems to translate into complete incompetence using a shopping cart, so it's basket all the way. Except when I can't find one, which is reasonably often in my pedestrian-friendly neighbourhood.

posted by Michelle of Montreal on March 3rd 2009 at 2:57pm
view Michelle of Montreal's profile

I love the tiny carts too! Theyre turning up in a ll our grocery stores her in the city - as if the grocery store people have figured out that not everyone is shopping for 4.

posted by fib on March 3rd 2009 at 2:57pm
view fib's profile

I prefer to use only a basket, but sometimes that's impossible. Making more frequent trips would allow the use of a basket, but then sometimes I end up coming home with more anyway. I guess that's my fault though. I wish stores had more of the smaller carts.

posted by Melissa A. on March 3rd 2009 at 2:59pm
view Melissa A.'s profile

I like carrying a basket, but usually buy heavy enough groceries that I need a cart. When the store is extremely busy, I'll take a cart regardless, because I've been pinned by other shoppers' carts enough times to know I need the cart for defensive purposes.

posted by Julie on March 3rd 2009 at 3:15pm
view Julie's profile

I bring my own shopping cart with me for shlepping the groceries home. So as I'm shopping I put the heaviest, non-fragile items straight into it, and carry a basket on top of it for the smaller, more fragile stuff.

posted by Brooklynnina on March 3rd 2009 at 3:23pm
view Brooklynnina's profile

on my own - i use basket
if i'm with my husband and we're doing a big shop then i make him drive the shopping cart - I used to be a "Courtesy Clerk" (grocery bagger) that helped people to their cars with the groceries and that is where I developed my aversion to pushing carts.

posted by gleam on March 3rd 2009 at 3:28pm
view gleam's profile

It's always been baskets for me, for years (especially in very crowded Fairway), but now the grocery store where I live has introduced the tiny carts, and I'm addicted to them. Best of both worlds.

posted by Joan A. on March 3rd 2009 at 3:28pm
view Joan A.'s profile

I use a shopping cart, but always leave it at the aisle's end-cap and grab whatever I need from the aisle unencumbered by the cart. This strategy helps me avoid getting stuck in cart traffic within the aisles.

posted by Steve D on March 3rd 2009 at 3:31pm
view Steve D's profile

I figure that if I can carry the basket in the store, I can carry the groceries home. But this is only a strategy I've adopted since living in New York.

posted by ottan on March 3rd 2009 at 3:35pm
view ottan's profile

Hee, I thought I was the only one with an aversion to shopping carts! Basket. Always a basket. I figure if it doesn't fit in there, I don't need it.

posted by chez shoes on March 3rd 2009 at 4:04pm
view chez shoes's profile

I like baskets at Trader Joe's because at ours (Pittsburgh) the pasta/oil/staples aisle is too narrow for two carts to pass! It's the busiest aisle in the place, too! However, I like the mini carts at our local chain (Giant Eagle) except I always bang my shin on the crossbar! I can't win. :)

posted by Jeni_Rae on March 3rd 2009 at 4:07pm
view Jeni_Rae's profile

I always shop using a basket, because I have to carry what I buy home on my back.

posted by MollyMayhem on March 3rd 2009 at 4:12pm
view MollyMayhem's profile

Basket. I shop for my groceries weekly so I really don't stock up on items.

posted by justveggingout on March 3rd 2009 at 4:42pm
view justveggingout's profile

depends on my shopping list and also depends on if I have any kids with me. Usually use the cart though.

posted by goodLife{eats} on March 3rd 2009 at 4:54pm
view goodLife{eats}'s profile

Anyone who carries a basket is a sucker. As soon as one puts a thing of milk in the basket, one immediately regrets it. Carrying around that much weight when the cart is easy.

posted by Nebagakid on March 3rd 2009 at 5:08pm
view Nebagakid's profile

Mini-carts are the way to go! Yay for stores who have realized some of us don't have 8 people to feed!

posted by mf1192 on March 3rd 2009 at 5:29pm
view mf1192's profile

If I know I'm getting a lot of canned goods and booze, I go for the cart, but I try to go for the basket as much as possible. I love the maneuverability, and I know it prevents me from having a dozen bags of groceries to unload.

Inevitably, though, I end up with about thirty pounds of wine and canned tomatoes weighing down one end, a precariously balanced dozen eggs hanging off the other, and a six pack of beer in my free hand.

posted by Tangledgray on March 3rd 2009 at 5:46pm
view Tangledgray's profile

We had some of those double-decker mini carts at the local Price Chopper for a while, but it's near the headquarters, and they've re-allocated them to other stores. :( Hannaford has smaller versions of the regular carts, which are a very good size. They're about 4" shorter in height and length, and narrower, as well.

posted by cara_mia on March 3rd 2009 at 5:51pm
view cara_mia's profile

you captured exactly my feelings! I *never* use the cart. And, if basket are missing, sometimes I just juggle stuff on my arms... not always a brilliant idea

posted by plch on March 3rd 2009 at 6:16pm
view plch's profile

I'm a huge fan of the little basket carts that allow you to roll around with two baskets in the cart. When I go to trader joe's I have a basket only policy - that store should NOT have regular carts!! On the rare occasions I make to a regular grocery store, I never buy enough to actually need the cart so it works out.

posted by ninamachina on March 3rd 2009 at 6:47pm
view ninamachina's profile

Sigh, I wish my Whole Foods had mini-carts.

posted by EasilyAmused on March 3rd 2009 at 6:55pm
view EasilyAmused's profile

usually a basket, a cart if I'm... carting a heavier than usual load

posted by VeryDelishVeg on March 3rd 2009 at 7:09pm
view VeryDelishVeg's profile

Whole Foods out here has small carts---their top compartment is slightly larger than a basket. That's what I always use.

posted by Leisureguy on March 3rd 2009 at 8:30pm
view Leisureguy's profile

when i'm in nyc a basket
when I'm in texas - a cart! there is more room in the store compared to tiny grocery stores here in the city.

posted by witchbaby on March 3rd 2009 at 9:45pm
view witchbaby's profile

Basket. I hate grocery store cart-traffic (and stroller traffic when the strollers are 5x the size of any human) so I refuse to contribute to it.
I also know that if it doesn't fit in a basket I will either not be able to fit it into my backpack to carry home, or will have to use a credit card.

posted by Nolann on March 4th 2009 at 12:48am
view Nolann's profile

i hate baskets b/c they get heavy. I hate carts b/c I tend to want to fill them up and they are hard to maneuver.

Has anyone considered taking their own shopping cart? I have one i got at the container store that folds up and rocks b/c it's lightweight. I figured if I have a little cart, I can't bring home unnecessary items, and not have the weight issues that you would w/ a basket. :)

posted by purseho on March 4th 2009 at 2:56am
view purseho's profile

I love the stores like Whole Foods that have the convertible basket/carts. They're basically just slightly deeper baskets, with wheels and a telescoping handle like a suitcase so that you can either carry it, or pull out the back long handle and pull it like a cart.

They're super convenient because they fit a tiny bit more than an average basket, you can carry them when the store is crowded, and you can set them down and roll them if you throw in a milk and a few canned goods and realize you don't want to lug that much around the store.

The mini-carts are great too, but I prefer the rolly-basket just for versatility.

posted by Kaete on March 4th 2009 at 8:15am
view Kaete's profile

I use a basket for two reasons:
1. I am only shopping for one person and therefore
2. If it doesn't fit in a basket then I can't afford it all.

Added bonus: carrying my groceries gives me more of a workout while I do my shopping :)

posted by CallieKoch on March 4th 2009 at 11:36am
view CallieKoch's profile

Fairway is always sooo packed that it is always whatever is smallest and will allow me to squeeze through the crowds. I've been to known to suffer serious arm cramps after packing the basket full of canned tomatoes, milk, cheese, oils you name it! Carts and cars.. a luxury us NY'ers can't afford!

posted by sdnyc on March 4th 2009 at 11:51am
view sdnyc's profile

I use the double decker carts-- you put a basket in the top and bottom and go. I hate maneuvering a big cart, and carrying a basket with milk and veggies is just too much.

posted by Eliza on March 4th 2009 at 5:25pm
view Eliza's profile

I'm on a budget and cooking for 2. Using a basket USUALLY ensures that I leave with a bill of under 30 bucks!

Nancy
http://testkitchenette.wordpress.com

posted by charmedbynancy on March 5th 2009 at 9:51pm
view charmedbynancy's profile

i pretty much always use a cart, so that i have somewhere to dump my purse, reusable bags, and coat (seasonally), and somewhere to set down my list and pen. I rarely use a basket, mostly because those seem to be the times i run across a great sale on a canned item and need to pick up 4 or more of them.

I tend to shop during the non-busy times, so managing cart traffic isn't a problem for me.

posted by wndl on March 8th 2009 at 4:05pm
view wndl's profile

Basket all the way. I shop pretty frequently, every 2-3 days, so the basket is the right size. If the basket is too heavy, i'm buying too much/the wrong stuff. when the basket's full, it's time to stop shopping, so it helps keep the grocery bills down too.
Our local Metro store has new larger basket/carts with the telescoping handle and wheels. I find they are too tall and not wide enough, things end up getting piled on top of everything else, too much getting squished. Plus you end up bending right down to the ground to put stuff in them.

I've considerd taking my own basket to the store, one of the aluminum/nylon market baskets. I figure that way i'd save on the need for bags at the end.

posted by Pulse on March 9th 2009 at 3:45pm
view Pulse's profile