apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Apartment Hunting: Is Proximity to a Grocery Store Important?

2009-06-12-GroceryStore.jpgWhen looking for a new apartment, we foodies often have a long list of "ideals". We want ample counter space, decent storage, good natural light, and a gas stove, too, if you please. After all, we're spending a lot of time in there! There's one other factor that we might not always think to consider: how close the place is to a grocery store.

 
 

My fiancé and I have been in the throes of apartment hunting these past few weeks. Proximity to a grocery store wasn't one of our original criteria, but the more we searched, the more important this came to be. It was never upgraded to the deal-breaker category, but distance to the nearest grocery store (or co-op) was definitely something we were sure to note.

We finally did find a great place, and as luck would have it, there's a grocery store less than two blocks away! I couldn't be more thrilled. At our previous apartment, we had to drive to the grocery store, which limited us to one shopping trip a week and meant that we had to be careful to plan out all our meals. That wasn't a bad thing, but we're curious to see how having a store so close by will change our eating and shopping habits.

Is living close to a grocery store important to you? Would this become a factor when looking for a new place to live?

Related: How to Save Money by Shopping at Whole Foods

(Image: Flickr member KitAy licensed under Creative Commons)

Tags

Supermarkets, apartment, grocery store, rental kitchen, grocery

Share

Comments (55)

I live in an adorably tiny town in VT with a locally owned grocery store almost directly in my backyard (well, I have to walk through a small field). When I go in to get my morning banana (they must be perfectly greenish-yellow - no buying in advance), the produce guy, Miguel, wishes me good morning by name. I can be there in 3 minutes, by foot, if I need something - before the pasta water even boils. Exaggerations aside, I will cry if we ever have to leave!

posted by MissKatieMay on June 15th 2009 at 2:04pm
view MissKatieMay's profile

When you're a student who bikes and busses, it is SO important. What would take 30 minutes if you had a car (or a cute little moped...) can take an hour by bike or even longer if you have to take 2 busses both ways.

posted by thehalfie on June 15th 2009 at 2:06pm
view thehalfie's profile

Since I don't have a car: yes. Especially if the area doesn't have reasonably-priced grocery delivery. Having to rely on public transportation or the goodwill of friends can get old fast. It is wonderful to have a grocery store within walking distance, especially if you have a small apartment without much storage space.

posted by slowdown on June 15th 2009 at 2:06pm
view slowdown's profile

yes. i stop at the store practically every day on my walk home from the train, and if i forget something then, it's only 3 avenues to the good store, or one avenue to the crappier one. i used to live in a neighborhood without a store in walking distance, and i distinctly remember one night that i started baking something, realized i didn't have an ingredient, and spent over an hour taking a train to and from the store at around 11pm. of course, i could have just scrapped my baking plans, but that's not my style....

posted by BrooklynBaker on June 15th 2009 at 2:25pm
view BrooklynBaker's profile

I used to be *this* close to a Whole Foods, a Trader Joes and a greenmarket... no car needed, thank you! Now, I have to remember to stash the canvas bags in the car, remember what I have (potentially) rotting in the fridge, remember what leftovers we have... and what I've already planned out for this week's meals. Ugh. There's really nothing like saying, "hey, I feel like fish tonight" rather than looking on the MENU posted on the fridge: "Oh, it's meatloaf night". *sigh*

posted by keltrue on June 15th 2009 at 2:25pm
view keltrue's profile

It's definitely one of my criteria. Luckily, we live within 1 mile of 6 grocery stores, including our favorite coop.

posted by wesaturtle on June 15th 2009 at 2:27pm
view wesaturtle's profile

we ix-nayed a little place for being too far from the grocery store. but i will warn... having a grocery store near by can sometimes lead to some slacking in the meal-planning dept. a trip to pick up forgotten broccoli can turn into broccoli and nutella and some sparkling water and yogurt-covered raisins. three to four trips like that can put a serious dent in the pocket-book.

posted by aneelee on June 15th 2009 at 2:30pm
view aneelee's profile

I never really thought about it in part because I grew up in a town where you had to drive everywhere, grocery store included. I miss living right across the street from a nice one, though. I don't think it would be a dealbreaker for me since I try to do a single grocery trip a week as it is.

posted by Tiamat_the_Red on June 15th 2009 at 2:39pm
view Tiamat_the_Red's profile

this is my grocery store! i recognize the signage. how bizarre.

posted by Jeni_Rae on June 15th 2009 at 3:02pm
view Jeni_Rae's profile

Very important - supports meal time creativity, an ability to pick up fresh ingredients on the way home, and it saves hugely on gas. It is even more important if you are buying a home versus renting.

I lived in a neighborhood in baltimore for years where they were promising to put in a grocery store. After 3.5 years in that neighborhood, i got disgusted and left. They finally opened it about 2 years later and now that whole neighborhood is starting to pick up activity.

posted by theripetomato on June 15th 2009 at 3:20pm
view theripetomato's profile

I think this is always a concern in NYC. One of my friends turned down an apartment because when she asked what the nearest grocery store is, her realtor replied, "well, Target sells food now." She ditched the realtor also.

I live near two crappy grocery stores (all within a 5-minute walk) and exactly one mile from Stop & Shop and Costco. I try to do all my shopping at those two places, but if I need a last minute ingredient I go to one of the crappy stores since I don't have a car and rely on walking/public transit for everything.

posted by groupie on June 15th 2009 at 3:33pm
view groupie's profile

ehh... what about the proximity of a grocery store if you work in a city?
as long as I work where I do, I can always grab things last-minute for dinner (right by a Dominick's and Fox & Obel; Trader Joe's and Whole Foods only a few blocks/bus stops away). but also, at home I'm near a bodega and small neighborhood grocery store where I can get basics if need be.

posted by any such name on June 15th 2009 at 3:35pm
view any such name's profile

I used to live around a corner from a good grocery store and loved the close proximity. I shopped 3-4 times a week and threw out less food that way too.

Next month I'm move to a new city. Since I'm not familiar with the neighborhoods, my search criteria has been to find a place near a Whole Foods. In addition to it being great living near a WF, I also figure there will be sufficient yuppie density so I don't wind up living in a crack den.

posted by ilovebutter on June 15th 2009 at 3:39pm
view ilovebutter's profile

I didn't consider this when I moved into my apt and am bumming about it. Next time I move it will be a major criteria. I'm a ten minute drive on the freeway to the nearest grocery store -- a Kroger that is not very new or nice, and doesn't have the selection of some of the newer Signature Krogers. Or I can grocery shop at Walmart -- a 10 minute drive on the freeway in the opposite direction. And that's it. Those are my choices unless I want a 30 minute or more drive, or unless I stop at the 7-11.

Very much of a bummer, considering that I was part of an organic co-op, had 3 great natural food shops near at hand, and bought my eggs straight from the farm before I moved.

Scope out your grocery options -- farmers markets, CSA's, Co-ops, big box discounts, pit-stop convenience, and regular old supermarkets before you commit. And if you drink, where the nearest spirit or beer shop is. I'm 25 minutes from the nearest gin and tonic, and on a hot day in Dallas, that's a cryin shame.

posted by mlleErica on June 15th 2009 at 3:46pm
view mlleErica's profile

Proximity to a grocery store is unimportant to me.

Proximity to a good (which most of the time means small) grocery and farmers market is very important to me.

What good is it to be close to Safeway/Keyfood/Van's or most other huge brands if you cannot even find good (from grass-fed cows/organic) milk in there?

posted by LuckyMonkey on June 15th 2009 at 3:47pm
view LuckyMonkey's profile

very important to have a grocery store, a bank, a post office, drug store and a hardware store all close to your new home. well, for me, it's important. i'm lucky to have a fairly large grocery store and an italian specialty food store blocks from home.

let's not forget those bodegas - 24-hour "everything" stores. You never know when you might need milk at 1AM!

posted by mikeinbrooklyn on June 15th 2009 at 3:53pm
view mikeinbrooklyn's profile

I used to live in a mixed-used development that included at 24-hour Harris Teeter supermarket. Being able to pop in for something at 3am on the way home from being out was great. The best of all, though, was being able to walk though an indoor corridor to get to the market during a major snowfall that shut down almost all traffic - I did not even have to put on a coat. So, yes, living close to the grocery store is pretty super.

posted by brittany on June 15th 2009 at 4:26pm
view brittany's profile

There's a small grocery store just down the street from me and I *love* having it so close. It means I can pop down for 1 or 2 things just when I need them, rather than filling up my kitchen with food I might not eat. Your food will probably be fresher too since instead of week-old items at the end of the week, you can be buying something that was just made or brought in that day.

posted by angorian on June 15th 2009 at 4:37pm
view angorian's profile

Absolutely! I must have at least a small market that carries basics within a 5 minutes walking distance... I'm very spoiled because at the moment I live a few seconds from a huge grocery store that carries tons of produce and a variety of Jaimaican, Latin American and African products!

posted by gabrielaskitchen on June 15th 2009 at 4:46pm
view gabrielaskitchen's profile

Until recently, this wouldn't have even entered my mind. But now, living sans vehicle, I have to plan shopping around what I can carry (or plan for "big groceries" in the boyfriend's car on weekends).

I thankfully live about 2 blocks away from a FABULOUS little Mexican grocery store, lovingly dubbed "The Supermercado". The produce is extremely cheap (20 limes for a dollar, seriously?!), and quite fresh. It's not exactly Whole Foods' pristine quality, but it's fresh, good, and astonishingly less expensive.

I will probably cry when I have to move away from it; and I will darn well have to move somewhere I can easily get to a good grocery store. I define this as 5 minutes travel time, either in a car or by foot.

http://www.abreadaday.com

posted by eprewitt on June 15th 2009 at 4:51pm
view eprewitt's profile

It's very important when you don't have a car! I just signed a lease after apartment searching for weeks. To aid in my search, I used the "My Maps" feature on Google Maps. I plotted the locations of all the grocery stores and farmers' markets in the area, as well as the library, gym, etc. It really helped me make a decision - now I have an apartment within walking distance to TJ's and Whole Foods!

posted by peachpearplum on June 15th 2009 at 5:42pm
view peachpearplum's profile

When we moved to our current apartment, we were hoping to cut down on our vehicle use and unnecessary reliance on mega-stores. Being close to things like a grocers or a market was on our "must" list, and we found our little slice of heaven walking distance from a cheese deli, an organic market, the weekly farmers market, a handful of big box grocery stores, a bakery, and an amazing selection of local shops.

You couldn't pay me to move back to the burbs. You could, however, pay me to move near the Supermercado. 20 limes for a dollar?? Heaven.

posted by Graceless on June 15th 2009 at 6:27pm
view Graceless's profile

We have it really good. The almost-best year round farmer's market is close by on a Sunday market. We fill in at the Whole Foods (walking distance) and at the Trader Joes (longer walking distance but we usually drove). But then, drum roll, a Trader Joes opened up within two blocks. It is very very cool.

We go to a regular grocery store once a month maybe. I stop by the good cheese store or bakery on my way home from work sometimes.

posted by JudiAU on June 15th 2009 at 6:38pm
view JudiAU's profile

I live in Chicago w/out a car so it is very necessary. My building is basically on top of a Treasure Island which is perfect for grabbing the little things I forget when I make the bi-monthly big grocery trip to Trader Joes and Dominicks w/ my friend that has a car.

I'm also VERY lucky to live close to the Green City Market where I get all my produce and such twice a week during the summer!

posted by WhitinChi on June 15th 2009 at 8:42pm
view WhitinChi's profile

It's very important to me. I walk to buy vegetables every 2 days. It's 10 minutes walk away and I get to pick out the best and the cheapest.

posted by buda on June 15th 2009 at 10:16pm
view buda's profile

It was important to me in my recent apartment search. A bonus, but not a necessity, is a farmer's market nearby.

posted by romateamo on June 16th 2009 at 6:46am
view romateamo's profile

So important! We have stayed in a decent, but pretty plain apartment for years because we can walk to Central Market and bike to the cheaper grocery store. I agree that a *good* grocery store is essential; being near a normal grocery store is definitely better than nothing, but it would take some getting used to, although I would take a well-stocked traditional grocery store. In our previous apartment we were very close to Whole Foods, but I had to walk over a really large bridge with lots of traffic, so that pushed me into driving more often--but it was an extremely fast drive.

posted by meeatman on June 16th 2009 at 7:07am
view meeatman's profile

Deal-breaker! When we bought our first home years ago, a good selection of grocery-purchasing options nearby was high on our "checklist". We'd already ditched my car, as it's so much better for my health (sedentary computer job), and we went for a "village" feel in an urban neighbourhood when we went househunting. Half a mile from the mainstreet, that's just the right distance for me.
I think that's one of the issues that can absolutely make or break your option of aging gracefully in place. One should probably ensure access to several grocery-buying options, just to cover off the odds that some will migrate away in years to come.
On the other hand, guys, I suppose there's web-based delivery nowadays, too. But that's no good for the 1 liter of milk at 1 am crisis. Nor for the built-in exercise benefit.

posted by DeborahMcP on June 16th 2009 at 7:46am
view DeborahMcP's profile

This is probably one of the last things I think about. I suppose I'm more concerned about the location/which part of town I want to live in and whether the apt is something I want to live. I recently moved to a new place as well and am now about 6 blocks from a large grocery store and 4 from a local CoOp. I still make the stop by target b/w on the way home from work. I suppose grocery proximity isn't as important b/c I tend to shop different stores to get the best deal on select items. Each store has its purpose

posted by brdnkchr on June 16th 2009 at 8:16am
view brdnkchr's profile

I live in Texas, so as most of you probably know, I drive to get pretty much anywhere. So having a grocery store near by isn't too much of an issue. I lived in England for a while though, and having to haul several bags worth of groceries on the bus was no treat! I'm hoping to be moving up to Boston within the next month or so though, and selling my car, so I would have to say yes, having a grocery store near is definitely key.

posted by allicoop86 on June 16th 2009 at 8:18am
view allicoop86's profile

To me it was very important living near a supermarket or grocery store when I was apartment hunting this past winter. In the area I lived in before I spent more time in my car than in my apartment. The apartment I finally ended up moving in is one block away from a commercial strip. Also, living close to the supermarket gave me the advantage to go grocery shopping early in the morning grabbing the freshest produce, freshly baked bread and any sale items before it was gone.

posted by RosaLily on June 16th 2009 at 8:19am
view RosaLily's profile

Absolutely. Especially living in New York, because groceries are heavy to carry and bringing them on the subway can be a huge hassle, especially if you run out after work (i.e., during the end of rush hour).

posted by degaussing on June 16th 2009 at 8:24am
view degaussing's profile

YES! considering I would need to carry all my groceries home, my current flat is within a 10 min walking distance to 3 supermarkets, a wet market, delicatessen and butcher. Then again I live in Hong Kong, where a big supermarket/drive everywhere culture just doesn't exist. My criteria is max 15 min walk to public transport and shops. It makes a BIG difference during the summer rainy season.

posted by tinafrog01 on June 16th 2009 at 8:54am
view tinafrog01's profile

Yes. For seven years we lived on the 20th floor of a building that had a major grocery store as its ground floor retail tenant. There's nothing like going downstairs without a jacket at midnight to pick up some late night snacks when its 20 below and snowing outside.

posted by Platypus on June 16th 2009 at 9:10am
view Platypus's profile

YES!! Living in a densely populated area, parking at grocery stores is at a premium unless it's 6am or 10pm (or later), so I do most of my grocery shopping on my way home from the subway. At my current apartment, it's about 3/4 mile from the nearest store and that can get a bit rough in the winter. I'm currently in the market again, and proximity to a food shopping is a huge consideration for sure.

posted by michpc on June 16th 2009 at 9:12am
view michpc's profile

Heck yes, it's important! What kind of question is that?!

posted by I, Lady Bee on June 16th 2009 at 9:47am
view I, Lady Bee's profile

Yes!
I'm considering buying a townhouse that's a little too close to an interstate overpass just because it's one of the few places in my town where you can safely (eg, no major streets) walk to a grocery store, restaurants, bars and pharmacy.

posted by LSUgrad03 on June 16th 2009 at 10:03am
view LSUgrad03's profile

I live in Ottawa, complete with -35 C winters, and a particularly irritating union for the bus drivers. This winter the bus drivers went on strike from Dec-Feb, the coldest and stormiest time. I was SO happy to live in the vicinity of 4 grocery stores in an under 30 minute walk in heavy snowfall. They are within a 20 minute walk when I am not knee deep in snow!
I also tend to eat a lot of raw foods in the summer, so I tend to make a few trips to the grocery store a week. I also considered Farmer's Market proximity when choosing a neighborhood- I love buying local organic produce! I considered this more than the grocery store actually, but quickly realized the plus of the closest grocery store being less than a block away.

posted by Nolann on June 16th 2009 at 10:09am
view Nolann's profile

I always live near a grocery store. I used to have to take public transit or walk an hour to get there...never again!

posted by alisaan on June 16th 2009 at 10:49am
view alisaan's profile

I lived close to a grocery store for years and loved being able to stop by to pick up a bag or two of groceries on the way home.

They closed a few years back when the landlord raised the rent - and now the place sits empty and I order groceries from Safeway.com.

posted by bepsf on June 16th 2009 at 11:26am
view bepsf's profile

It is one of my main deciding factors. The places I walk to on an almost daily basis are the gym and the grocery store. If I can't get to them in under 15 minutes, I don't want to live there.

posted by akay on June 16th 2009 at 11:29am
view akay's profile

When I have been car-less (which is most of my urban-living life and some of college) my MO was to live either within 3 blocks of a grocery store or have one that was en route home on my commute. I think it is very important to have one close to home, even if I only go once a week. Now I live farther from a full grocery store, but only 1 long block from an Italian grocery that has a full deli and a lot of freshly prepared foods as well as some Italian staples. However, I am also 1 block from my boyfriend and he has a car :-)

posted by Domestic Intellectual on June 16th 2009 at 11:41am
view Domestic Intellectual's profile

I live in a Brooklyn neighborhood that only has a few supermarkets (all about 15 minutes walk or bike ride), therefore it was more important to have a simple produce store and a meat store within a block or two of my apartment than an actual grocery store. The produce store is open 24 hours and also doubles as a convenience store. I can get by on salads with protein most of the time, and I hit up Fairway (a large supermarket in Red Hook, a 20 minute drive) for specialty cheeses, groceries, seafood, cereals and staples maybe twice a month.

posted by designnerd on June 16th 2009 at 11:50am
view designnerd's profile

This is important to me, since I bike everywhere, but now that I've moved to a place with a 30 minute walk to the store, I've learned to make due. I buy heavy items in bulk from Amazon and get them delivered, and then I get fresh items every week at the farmer's market or on my way home from work. Once in a blue moon I get a zip car or bum a ride with a friend, but honestly, grocery store proximity isn't as important as I originally thought.

posted by wait wait, there's on June 16th 2009 at 12:21pm
view wait wait, there's's profile

*make do. :)

posted by wait wait, there's on June 16th 2009 at 12:22pm
view wait wait, there's's profile

i too am i bike rider, so yes, it is crucial to be near a grocery store! i don't have a basket on my bike, and travelling far with pounds of food on my back gets tough and leaves me out of breath, so i like to be within fifteen minutes of one. where i live now, the grocery store is five minutes away. score.

posted by claire_quilty on June 16th 2009 at 2:48pm
view claire_quilty's profile

It wasn't a priority when I moved recently, but it was a happy coincidence. I wanted to stick to a central area of the city with excellent bus service and off hand I can think of 6 grocery stores nearby, 5 accessible by bus in about 10 minutes and one I can walk to. No walk-to 24 hour corner stores though, which I would really like.

posted by Mlle Kate on June 16th 2009 at 4:03pm
view Mlle Kate's profile

It wasn't, but it is now. I didn't care when the mainstream grocery store near my house closed, since I prefer Trader Joe's or the local health-food store. But, recently, a Trader Joe's opened within walking distance, and it is SO convenient. When I have to move, I will be looking for something within reasonable distance of something similar.

posted by Stiletto on June 16th 2009 at 4:13pm
view Stiletto's profile

Absolutely! I have three grocery stores, a fish market, a bakery, a liquor store and two butchers all on the walk home from the train. I don't know what I'd do any more if I didn't; I've grown so used to picking up dinner on the way home each day and having fresh everything. They all deliver for free, too - important when there is no car and you want to do big shopping.

posted by Toomskt on June 16th 2009 at 4:14pm
view Toomskt's profile

It's pretty important and makes life easier when you have to carry everything back.

The reason I ended up eating much healthier three years ago was because there was a Whole Foods only a block away from my apartment in Boston.

posted by niami on June 16th 2009 at 5:56pm
view niami's profile

I have a grocery store on the end of my block. It's fantastic being able to run out and get what I need in just a few minutes. I call it my Kitchen-Annex

posted by sjvsjv on June 16th 2009 at 9:13pm
view sjvsjv's profile

I have a small Albertsons that I can get to in 3 mins on foot from my kitchen.

I also have a Posh Ralph's and a Giant Ralph's only a quick bike ride or 10 min walk.

And a liquor store across the street and 2 big gas station markets open 24/7 on the corner.

It's the stuff dreams are made of!

posted by marcspice on June 17th 2009 at 12:57pm
view marcspice's profile

It's totally a necessity, but it shouldn't be a problem for me. The neighborhood I'm looking to live in has a full-service grocery store—the only one in the area. So I consider myself lucky. I couldn't imagine having to drive just to pick up a gallon of milk. That's just mean.

posted by Alaricus on June 17th 2009 at 11:43pm
view Alaricus's profile

I live in a small appartment in Paris and I can't use too much place on food storage. So living next to a grocery store is crucial since I have to go shopping 3-4 times a week!
But I'm lucky : I have 4 different grocery stores 5 minutes away from my place!

posted by leila de monpetitappart on June 18th 2009 at 4:04am
view leila de monpetitappart's profile

i just moved to phoenix from nyc and i'm not a driver, so that was actually my dealbreaker when finding an apartment. brokers apparently didn't consider it though, bc every one i asked about whether supermarkets delivered were stumped. i ended up taking a place that's diagonally across the street from a small market, even though i would have taken a place with brand new appliances, amenities had it not been at least 2 miles from the supermarket.

posted by amandabug on June 19th 2009 at 12:53pm
view amandabug's profile