It's Ice Cream Month here at The Kitchn and that means we're hitting the ice cream maker every few days. The freezer is filling up with assorted containers of ice cream, some blog-ready, some not.
It's chaos. I need to give some away but want to present it in something classier than an old piece of Tupperware.
Here's the challenge...
The challenge is to find plain paper ice cream containers, preferably pint-size, without any writing on them to pack my homemade ice cream into and store, or give to friends. You would think it would be easy, but it's not.
I've found a few sources for containers in bulk, but none with more reasonable minimum orders. I'd be willing to split a case of 50 or so with a friend, but that's my limit.

• GelatoMarket.com has a pint container, but aside from its 250 minimum order ($95), there are holes on the top of the lid, which I thought defeated the purpose of sealing the container. It's not a pint of soup!

• Stanpac General Store carries white paper ice cream pint containers (scroll to bottom right of screen), but the minimum quantity is 1000, at a price of $695. Ouch. While you're there, check out all their cool glass milk bottles.

• IceCreamProducts.com whose name alone had me feeling optimistic, has unprinted paper pint containers in minimum order quantities of 20 or 25 (scroll down to item 5678), but the killer is that you can't buy fewer than 500 lids. What?!?
Any ideas?
I've been grappling with this same issue... no luck. I'll be hanging on every comment.
view Kelly H's profile
I bought an ice cream maker last week and am now facing the same issue. I reused a plastic takeout soup container for one batch, and just tupperware for another.
What about paper Chinese takeout boxes? I'm not sure if the gift kind you'd get at Michael's would work, but they might.
view OneWallKitchen's profile
I'm looking for them too. Keep us posted.
view TripkeHughes's profile
Try going to a restaurant supply shop, www.restaurantdepot.com.
view michi41's profile
I hadn't thought of that before. I've been putting my ice cream in tupperware for years - maybe this would take away some of that iciness that sprouts up after a few days (humidity?)
view lunettes's profile
I give out ice cream to friends in containers they can reuse, like a Tupperware. It's not pretty, but better than tossing a bunch of one-use containers in the trash. I also reuse large plastic yogurt or cottage cheese containers. I make my own ice cream labels to wrap around them.
Not sure if paper Chinese takeout boxes will work too well - you want a container that can be tightly sealed and prevent leakage.
view bipolarbear's profile
I second the quart-sized yogurt container suggestion. They work great!
view quercus's profile
I buy these containers for soup all the time at my local restaurant supply store (Surfas in Culver City, CA) - usually in 10 packs. They have several different sizes.
view christianne's profile
How about pint-size glass canning jars?
Kerr, Ball, and Mason all make them.
view Aimi's profile
I know where you can get them, Smart & Final. I bought a bunch of them for just this purpose, and they are perfect. I forget the exact number per pack but definitely more than 10 a bag, and the covers are sold separately.
view RJD's profile
I buy cases of wide mouth pint mason jars. You can get 12 for less than $10, especially at this time of year, and you can use them over and over. Add some fabric to the top before you screw on the top and you have a pretty package!
view ehme's profile
christianne: the problem with soup containers is that they have little holes punched in the top to let the steam out. For freezing, you don't want any holes, otherwise you get instant freezer burn. I love Surfas, though! A toy store for me.
Aimi and ehme: Glass wouldn't do well in the freezer.
RJD: The Smart & Final suggestion is great, if you live in Arizona, California, Idaho, Nevada, Oregon or Washington. They don't have an e-commerce site. Someone in one of those states want to ship me some?!
view Sara Kate's profile
I live in Oregon and I would ship you some, but our store is called "Cash & Carry" (from their website). Wonder if it's the same?
RJD: Is there a product number? What exactly is the item name?
view bootsygro's profile
i have found the perfect site!
they have plastic containers in the all the right sizes.. from smaller than half a pint (8oz) to larger than a gallon (128oz).
they have skirted lids, recessed lids (for easy stacking), and regular flat lids!
there is no minimum order, although for total orders less than $50 they apply a $10 charge.
the site?
www.containerandpackaging.com
view orchidmusiq's profile
After trying from yogurt to Ziploc containers, I still think ice-cream looks better in pint-size paper containers when I give it away. I will be ordering from GelatoMarket.com and stick a waterproof label on the lid (with the name of the flavor) to cover the holes and to prevent freezer burn. I live in the Boston area and would be willing to split the order if anyone is interested.
view papillonmosaic's profile
I found them at www.thinkgarnish.com and you can buy just one if you want to.
view qbee's profile
You can find these containers at Wholesale paper supplies
http://wholesalepapersupplies.com/index1.html
The min order is 500 and lids are ordered seperately.
view modernorganicmama's profile
oh. I am just reading the thread now. papillonmosaic, did you end up buying from gelato market? I am in the Boston area too.
view missbidon's profile
I like to eat my ice cream out of my favorite ice-cream bowl or right out of a pint size container. I can understand wanting to give away your gifts away in something that looks the same way as you enjoy it.
I found these ice-cream tubs (1 pint size) on Amazon and I think I'll get them because the times where I have given ice-cream to friends in ugly tupperware they usually give me back my tupperware (it's the polite thing to do) and they request more. So really, they never throw it away, they give it back to you when they want more, and hopefully they reuse it (maybe it can hold soup?). But they are $12 each. I'm sure a nice waterproof label can be added to the tops, side or even discreetly on the bottom.
http://www.amazon.com/Zak-Designs-Cream-White-Pint/dp/B001LBFDZE/ref=wl_it_dp?ie=UTF8&coliid=I2LDFONRZ2KPAK&colid=28KD4MTDRYZ5A
view gnomette's profile
I found these a few weeks back, sooo cute and cheap!
http://www.sweetblisscontainers.com/
view roxyy84's profile
The container with holes in the lid looks perfect! Why not use a sheet of Saran wrap under the lid?
view EmeryJ's profile