apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Top Chef Chicago: Were You Surprised?

2008_04_17-TopChef1.jpg 2008_04_17-TopChef2.jpg
Since the elimination challenge centered around tailgating at a Bears game, we'll go with some football terminology to describe our reaction... Quarterback sneak? Blitzed? It came out of left field? OK, it wasn't a complete shock, but we really did think we had the outcome pegged until Padma opened her mouth. What about you?


Note: We reveal the winner and loser after the jump...

2008_04_17-TopChef4.jpg 2008_04_17-TopChef3.jpg

Two things about last night's episode delighted us. One, after a few episodes of high-concept, Richard-esque food, we were happy to see them pairing beer with food (in the Quickfire) and grilling casual, satisfying dishes we could see ourselves cooking once the weather turns warm.

Two, they finally worked alone. Every contestant could cook his or her own food without succumbing to a bossy partner or being able to hide behind more talented team members. Everyone seemed to be having fun, finally.

The food got better, too. Did anyone else notice how many positive comments were flying around at the tailgate? The judges were positively giddy when talking to the top three: Antonia, Dale, and Stephanie. We wish Antonia had won — her jerk chicken sandwich with banana and pineapple sounded right up our alley. But you can't beat ribs at a football game, we guess, and Dale won the challenge with his Indian-style pork ribs.

As for the loser, we thought it was going to be Nikki, hands down. Her cooking seems to be the kind that's always satisfying but rarely inspiring. We feel she's squeaked by a few times by being on winning teams. And yes, Ryan served inappropriate, unfriendly food to a football crowd (poached pears?), but we thought they'd keep him around for entertainment value.

We were wrong. How about you?

More Top Chef Coverage:

(All images: Bravo)

Comments (13)

I also thought it would be Nikki. Every time I see her, I think to myself, "Who's that? Did they sneak in a new player while I wasn't looking?" She is utterly forgettable.

I'm also glad the players weren't sniping at each other as much this week. I know Bravo has a formula, but I'm there to watch the food.

Now, if they'll only get rid of Nikki and Lisa ...

posted by BrooklynEric on 2008-04-17 10:40:33
view BrooklynEric's profile

I'd be happy if they just got rid of Nikki, Lisa, Spike, and Andrew all in one shot. I'll settle for it that order though...

posted by charmon on 2008-04-17 12:09:46
view charmon's profile

Not at all.

We had Bears season tickets for years. Poached pears? Yeah, right. We saw that A LOT. Spike and his stupid hats are next.

posted by Peggasus on 2008-04-17 12:16:35
view Peggasus's profile

I'm just glad they didn't get rid of Mark, I'm a sucker for that new zealand accent. and yeah, get out of here Spike (and maybe get some Ritalin while you're at it?)

posted by Barbara S on 2008-04-17 13:06:14
view Barbara S's profile

Mark looked totally wasted when he was standing in front the judges' panel.

posted by cakekick on 2008-04-17 13:51:30
view cakekick's profile

i thought Nikki for sure and was having flashbacks to the block party episode: bad mac & cheese and now bad sausage peppers & onions. She prob didn't even CONSIDER making her own sausage.

posted by HazeL4844 on 2008-04-17 14:15:47
view HazeL4844's profile

I actually nailed this one. The second he began describing what he was making, I said "oh, he's gone."

Though, Tom's complete disgust at Mark's filthy workspace and habits had me thinking he was likely to go as well...

posted by kenboy on 2008-04-17 14:45:27
view kenboy's profile

Nikki has been around much longer than is justified. Until last night, she had mostly managed to stay under the judges' collective radar. Her sausage subs were really just assembled from store-bought ingredients.

I was desperately hoping she would get the boot after wasting a chunk of her team's food budget on flowers for the table during the animal challenge. I could tell her teammates were PISSED about that, as I would have been. Oh, and those grody mushrooms. Heh.

posted by graefix on 2008-04-17 14:48:33
view graefix's profile

Nikki = Rachel Ray.

posted by robinm on 2008-04-17 15:14:42
view robinm's profile

I thought all 3 should've packed their knives...Mark and Nikki took their lucky pills that morning, they're both on VERY thin ice...and what's with the Hat making out w/Richard b4 heading out?

posted by lele13 on 2008-04-17 17:13:46
view lele13's profile

I kind of knew he was going to go, even though the other 2 deserved the boot more, because he basically said to the judges, screw your challenge I'm just going to do what I want, and in the ned if you're going to try something like that you have to put forth something so utterly amazing that it's forgivable, and from the comments it wasn't all that great. The others might have sucked or been slobby, but at least their efforts smacked of trying to meet the challenge.

I mean if you're hired on to be the chef at a top Steakhouse you're not going to get very far if everytime someone asks for a Ribeye you make them tofu and soy subsititue, and claim you're bringing steak to your level.

posted by bonjourmiette on 2008-04-17 18:42:14
view bonjourmiette's profile

I was really surprised! I kinda liked Ryan. Here's what my sister and I think was the judge's thought process: none of those bottom three have a chance of being Top Chef, but Ryan rarely screws up so bad. So why not take the opportunity to get rid of him on this one failure, and take care of Nikki next time she tries to use Velveeta for mac n cheese and Mark next time he does something sloppy. Can't wait for Nikki to go, though, and when I saw Mark in the opening credits I thought Man, how much longer is this guy gonna manage to hang on?

posted by gogoalix on 2008-04-17 20:30:57
view gogoalix's profile

We were surprised that Ryan was asked to pack his knives in that particular challenge. Regardless of whether the pears were "tailgate food" at least it sounded like it was tasty. What great cooking has Nikki done? at any point?

posted by kdb on 2008-04-18 10:59:13
view kdb's profile
Buy Text Ads