apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Personal Taste: Do You Like Sweet-Savory Combinations?

2009-09-22-SweetSavory.jpgFall seems to bring on a lot of dishes that combine sweet and savory flavors: butternut squash in pasta, roasted meat with stewed fruit sauce, even desserts spiced with herbs like rosemary and thyme. Do you like these kinds of dishes?

 
 

We're always a little cautious when making (or eating!) a sweet-savory dish. These dishes can so easily go from an intriguing play of flavors to a disaster of syrupy sweetness. The key is getting the sweet and elements balanced in just the right proportions.

Here are a few recipes we're curious to try:

Stuffed Chicken Breasts with Grapes, Hazelnuts, and Parmesan, from the Kitchn
Braised Short Ribs with Chocolate and Rosemary, from Epicurious
Slow Roasted Pork Shoulder with Melted Apples, from Simply Recipes
Butternut Squash, Sausage, and Sage Lasagna, from Sustainable Table
Grilled Orange Salmon, from Taste of Home

What sweet-savory combinations do you like?

Related: Chocolate's Savory Side: Don't Wait for Dessert!

(Image: Flickr member [puamelia] licensed under Creative Commons)

Tags

Inspiration, Fall, Ingredients - Meat, Ingredients - Fruit, fall flavors, sweet-savory

Related Links

Share

Comments (34)

I really like the sweet/savory combo. More so in apps/entrees than in desserts, though. I've made the Stuffed Chicken Breasts w/ Grapes, Hazelnuts and Parmesan recipe that is linked in the post and thought it was delicious. Very easy to prepare as well.

posted by Daisy11 on September 22nd 2009 at 11:03am
view Daisy11's profile

My all time favorite sweet/savory meal is Cinnamon Short Rib Parpadelle. The buttery, salty bite of short rib layered with sweet, spicy cinnamon makes such a lovely fall dinner. Here's the recipe: http://www.clovesandcream.com/2009/06/cinnamon-short-rib-parpadelle.html

posted by cloves and cream on September 22nd 2009 at 11:10am
view cloves and cream's profile

I'm a huge fan of fruit in salads, and adding fruit to pork.

But I still don't really like savory herbs in desserts.

posted by orchidgirl1979 on September 22nd 2009 at 11:12am
view orchidgirl1979's profile

Do not like! I don't even want sweet and savory on the same plate, lest they accidentally touch.

posted by ShellyIN on September 22nd 2009 at 11:15am
view ShellyIN's profile

For those who aren't a fan of a savory flavor in something that is predominately sweet: I mostly agree with you, but have found that rosemary seems to be my exception to the rule.

In Chicago, the chain Orange serves delicious orange/rosemary french toast, and I've gotten some wonderful peach/rosemary lemonade at Whole Foods recently. It doesn't overpower the sweetness, it just adds some depth to the flavor.

posted by akay on September 22nd 2009 at 11:24am
view akay's profile

I'm with ShellyIN. So glad to know I'm not alone! I'm of the opinion that food should either be sweet or savory, not both.

posted by ohiokavr on September 22nd 2009 at 11:39am
view ohiokavr's profile

If by "sweet-savory" you mean "eat dessert and the main course at the same time, even off the same plate" then yes, I like sweet-savory combinations. :-)

posted by Akino luna on September 22nd 2009 at 12:06pm
view Akino luna's profile

Love sweet in an otherwise savory dish, so long as it's balanced and not too sweet. Ate at a Mario Batali restaurant this weekend where the gnocchi with figs and walnut pesto got this exactly right.

posted by Heidz on September 22nd 2009 at 12:06pm
view Heidz's profile

I find the idea of sweet meats and savory items disgusting. Why turn savory items into desserts and another excuse for a sugar fix?

posted by lona on September 22nd 2009 at 12:22pm
view lona's profile

Salted caramel comes to mind. I have come to like sweet-savory combinations, but I think the key is to be clearly on one side or the other. For savory dishes with a sweet note and for desserts with a savory element.

posted by Porkbelly on September 22nd 2009 at 12:26pm
view Porkbelly's profile

This is one of the few food preparations I don't like! I think it's because I just prefer salty foods in general. So meat cooked with fruit, no (or sugar in pasta sauce, gross!) But salted caramel, heck yes!

posted by ladidi on September 22nd 2009 at 12:28pm
view ladidi's profile

I love savory desserts (apple pie and cheddar, anyone?), but PLEASE leave my main course alone. I don't even like barbeque sauce.

posted by yellowrice on September 22nd 2009 at 12:34pm
view yellowrice's profile

I love sweet/savory, but I cannot stand citrus/meat. Keep your lemon chicken and orange glazed pork to yourself, plzkthx.

posted by kestrel127 on September 22nd 2009 at 12:36pm
view kestrel127's profile

Oh man, totally yes! I'm sure having a palate of an Eastern European used to sweet/savory dishes in meat stews as a kid also let me experience and love all sorts of other things-like Thai food, etc... there's a world of possibilities out there and I agree with Porkbelly-there has to be a balance-otherwise, it's just bad.

posted by edava72 on September 22nd 2009 at 12:51pm
view edava72's profile

Porkbelly,
Salt is a flavor enhancer, so it's not inherently savory. I put it in caramel sauce all the time, and one of my favorite sweet combos is chocolate and peanut butter, mostly because of the sweet salty.

BBQ sauce, though? Totally unacceptable! Heck, I don't even eat ketchup on french fries, because it's offensively sweet.

posted by ShellyIN on September 22nd 2009 at 12:53pm
view ShellyIN's profile

I love strawberry-basil smoothies. Does that count?

posted by dsquared on September 22nd 2009 at 1:37pm
view dsquared's profile

Fruit meat = no. Always. Except maybe a little prune or fig in a sauce, but I think that almost doesn't count.

posted by PhoebeArt on September 22nd 2009 at 3:19pm
view PhoebeArt's profile

That should be fruit *plus* meat. Not sure why it ignored my plus sign...

posted by PhoebeArt on September 22nd 2009 at 3:20pm
view PhoebeArt's profile

I love the sweet/savory combination and have been playing with it a lot all summer. This past weekend, I made a pear tart with caramelized onions and gorgonzola that had just enough of a savory element to keep it from being dessert-ish. Our biggest problem was deciding when to eat it.

http://chimeraobscura.com/mi/tarted-up/

posted by MinimallyInvasive on September 22nd 2009 at 3:30pm
view MinimallyInvasive's profile

Butternut squash soup with ale and sharp cheddar...does that count? I guess that's more salty-sweet. Still damn good though. I also make a vodka sauce with a lot of heavy cream and blue cheese.

That squash, sage and sausage lasagna is getting eaten this weekend. But beware to anyone trying to make a bechamel like they're making it....8 tablespoons of butter is NOT two sticks!!

posted by Oneisco on September 22nd 2009 at 4:18pm
view Oneisco's profile

Oh and anyone else who loves a good savoury meal with a hint of sweet should try out Jamie Oliver's Milk Chicken. It was featured here a few weeks back and is out of this world. Sage, milk and cinnamon combine to give the whole thing a sweet, perfumed taste. But the garlic and roast chicken ensure that it's still a chicken roast, no matter how you dress it up.

http://www.jamieoliver.com/recipes/chicken-recipes/chicken-in-milk

posted by Oneisco on September 22nd 2009 at 4:21pm
view Oneisco's profile

I like sweet-savoury main dish combos as long as they are also spicy. Like apricots in curried chicken, or raisins in a zippy chickpea tagine. I also like pork with apples. And spicy/sweet chutneys like tomato and raisins with fennel. And sweet potato soup with cinnamon and hot peppers.

But sometimes carrots in a vegetable soup are too sweet for me, as is almost any commercial pasta sauce.

So go figure.

And I do not like herbs in my dessert. Or cheese with my pie.

posted by Bobolink on September 22nd 2009 at 4:39pm
view Bobolink's profile

I love the sweet/savory combination. Sharp cheddar and apple slices, eaten so that every bite combines apple and cheese, has been my favourite snack going right back to childhood (though I've never eaten apple pie with cheddar, oddly!). In fact, for sweet vegetables like butternut squash, I really can't understand why anyone bothers to prepare them in ways that enhance the sweetness instead of complementing it with something savory.

And as for sweet/spicy chutneys with my curry, or (decent) cranberry sauce with my turkey? This took me longer to learn to appreciate but I'm all for it.

posted by tariqata on September 22nd 2009 at 5:46pm
view tariqata's profile

Bacon-wrapped figs as an appetizer...and pickle and peanut butter sandwiches!

posted by betsyb on September 22nd 2009 at 5:52pm
view betsyb's profile

What's wrong with enjoying the delicate flavor of good quality meat, or fresh fish or garden vegetables? Why try to mask a truly good cut of meat with sauce or sweetness?

posted by lona on September 22nd 2009 at 6:34pm
view lona's profile

Iona: there's nothing wrong with it. But as an accent, a touch of contrasting flavour balances, it doesn't mask.

posted by tariqata on September 22nd 2009 at 7:15pm
view tariqata's profile

I do like sweet and savory together. They have a way of working together to set off the main flavor and add some extra interest. But one definitely needs to be dominant.

posted by Kakugori on September 22nd 2009 at 8:19pm
view Kakugori's profile

Some things. I have a "salt tooth" as opposed to a sweet one. Love roast pork baked with apples or pears, or alongside applesauce. Love broiled chicken with apricot glaze. Love chocolate-covered salty pretzels, M&Ms (especially peanut!) mixed into salted & buttered popcorn, and salted caramel.

But for some odd reason I cannot tolerate the sweet/savory pairings of specific things, like raisins in savory rice (like in certain Moroccan and North African dishes) or coconut in many savory/spicy Caribbean dishes. And no berries in my green salad, please. Interestingly, I can't get enough Indian food, which does pair sweet/savory fairly often.

posted by marchhare on September 22nd 2009 at 9:13pm
view marchhare's profile

oh man, I have a major issue with Fruit Apathy, even for tarts like these: http://tinyurl.com/lq4pdk

posted by BigGirlPhoebz on September 22nd 2009 at 9:15pm
view BigGirlPhoebz's profile

Flour Salt in SF has a rosemary panna cotta. I think panna cotta is a terrible dessert and with the rosemary it is awesome.

They also have a chocolate budino with fleur de sel. I dont like sweets so these are good for me.

posted by Tazer on September 22nd 2009 at 10:57pm
view Tazer's profile

@ShellyIn, I agree salt is a flavor enhancer and is in almost everything. I generally think of fat salt as savory and fat sugar=sweet. Caramel is interesting. It's essentially cooked sugar, but it can go either way, savory or sweet. We sear all sorts of proteins to caramelize them -- basically cooking the sugars to bring out the flavor, yet we think of them as savory. So I'd consider both salt and sugar flavor enhancers.

posted by Porkbelly on September 23rd 2009 at 12:00am
view Porkbelly's profile

I like them sometimes. There's always that risk that savory/sweet combos will be too sweet. My boyfriend, on the other hand, absolutely loves them and my dad hates them and pretty much refuses to eat any meat/fruit combo.

posted by Emily G. on September 23rd 2009 at 12:15pm
view Emily G.'s profile

Love myself the sweet/savory combo. I guess it's the hedonistic part of me that believes the more taste buds and olfactory receptors I can stimulate, the better (in a pleasing combination of course).

I didn't use to like sweet and savory combos, but I kind of grew out of my aversion of it. I like the alternation between the two with every bite.

posted by crazykj on September 23rd 2009 at 10:53pm
view crazykj's profile

Any time your dealing in contrasts the key is balance. Sweet and savory works when both flavors adequately fill he void left by the other. If any one flavor profile upstages the other then the dish as a whole tends to collapse.

posted by 7yler on September 24th 2009 at 5:20pm
view 7yler's profile