Whether dry-aged or wet-aged beef is better has actually become quite a debate in certain foodie circles. Dry-aging has centuries of tradition on its side, while wet-aging is really the new kid on the block. Is one really better than the other? You decide.
All meat benefits from some amount of aging before being sold and consumed. In the days after slaughter, enzymes go to work on the muscle tissue, breaking it down and making it tender. Chicken needs a few days, while pork and lamb needs a week. Beef can be aged for quite a bit longer.
Dry-Aged Beef
For dry-aging, whole sides of beef or primal cuts are hung in open air at a temperature just above freezing and left to age for several weeks. Not only are the enzymes working on the muscle tissues during this time, but the meat is also slowly dehydrating. This concentrates the meat and changes the texture and flavor.
The benefit of this process is very tender meat with an intense flavor. The downside is that you lose quite a bit of the meat due to moisture loss, which decreases the yield and increases the cost per pound. Also, the surface of the meat usually needs to be trimmed away before the beef is portioned and sold, resulting in further loss of volume.
Wet-Aged Beef
Wet-aging is a relatively recent technique that developed along with advances in plastics and refrigeration. In this process, cuts of beef are vacuum-sealed in plastic and shipped to the market. The aging takes place in the 4-10 days between slaughter and sale while the meat is in transit.
The enzymes still have time to tenderize the meat enough to make it acceptable, and the biggest plus is that there's no weight-loss in the meat due to dehydration. Wet-aging also costs less for the manufacturer since the meat doesn't need to be stored or monitored, ultimately resulting in a lower consumer cost.
Which is Better?
Honestly, it's a matter of preference. The biggest difference between the two kinds of meat is in the flavor. Dry-aged beef can be described as having a roasted, nutty flavor, while wet-aged beef can taste slightly metallic and lacks the same depth of flavor.
Unless the beef is specifically labeled as dry-aged, the meat you buy in the store has almost definitely been wet-aged. Most of us have come to associate the flavor of beef with wet-aged meat, to the point that dry-aged beef might not taste as palatable anymore.
You should definitely try some dry-aged beef if you have the opportunity. It costs a lot more and is harder to find, but it's worth knowing that there are other options out there.
What do you think?
Related: Good Beef: How to Find Local Meat
(Image: Flickr member fortes licensed under Creative Commons)
One thing about dry aging that makes it very good is that it is only done with prime grade meat. So, the end result is kind of a double whammy--super good quality meat that's been carefully aged for maximum flavor and chew.
In order to really appreciate the effects of wet aging, it should take no less than 28 days. But of course, any grade of meat can be wet aged. This may sound rather gross but if a piece of meat is sitting in "juices" in the cryovac, that purging means that wet aging has been taking place for awhile and may have positive results.
Dry-aging beef well takes quite a bit of energy. Humidity, temperature and air flow have to be constantly monitored and then careful butchery of the final product has to take place. There are not too many processors devoting the time and energy to dry aging anymore. I've seen grocery stores with small setups (but they're grocery stores). The best dry-aged cuts come from meat packers who hand pick the primals for dry-aging.
view art's profile
Wet aging makes meat taste like slime and that, combined with modern intensive feedlots, give it its distinctive livery-spongy flavor.
There is no comparison to dry aging. YUM.
view JudiAU's profile
I have a feeling that in the not-too-distant future we are going to be warned about cryovac'ed food, especially raw meat. It seems like every day there is a new revelation on the dangers of BPAs, so vacuum packing raw meat into plastic seems a likely hazard, even though nothing has surfaced yet about it being an issue...
The dry-aged chickens here in France are phenomenal -- a totally different meat to cook with than what we know as chicken in North America, even the free-range kind.
view mschatelaine's profile
I have to disagree on the idea that only prime steaks can be dry aged. I have read many articles on this subject and people continue to repeat what they have read. I have built my own patent pending chamber for dry aging beef and have been dry aging well marbled choice strip steak on the bone. After 21 days the steak is tender juicy and tastes great. Prime is the best cut but you can definately dry age choice. I have been doing this for almost two years and have not had a bad steak yet.
view Steak Man's profile
No doubt you can dry age your own steak Steak Man! You're the man. I was just talking about the commercial dry-aged market. More info on that dry aging chamber?
view art's profile