Last week we sampled a pair of festive holiday punches - and our readers shared some of their own great recipes as well. This week we're going to take a look at one last important detail: Ice.
Last week we sampled a pair of festive holiday punches - and our readers shared some of their own great recipes as well. This week we're going to take a look at one last important detail: Ice.
When it comes to keeping a large bowl of punch fresh and cool for an evening, not just any ice will do. Regular ice cube tray ice melts too quickly, letting things warm up and get watered down much too soon. If you want ice to last as long as possible, the trick is to go big.
Earlier this week, I did a few experiments with some really big ice. This is what I learned:
Choosing a Container
After poking around my cupboards at home, I chose three different containers to use as ice molds: a 16-ounce supermarket deli container, a square food storage container, and a tall plastic jug. (Bundt pans and jelly molds, if you have them, would make great shapes too.) I tried each out in the bowl I'd be serving the punch in. The key, I discovered, was to go as big as possible, but to still leave enough room in the bowl to maneuver the ladle.
Adding Fruit
I added fresh pineapple slices and a handful of cranberries to the water in the square container, for a little extra decorative flair.
Freezing Time
More water means a longer freezing time, so for peace of mind, it's best to start things the night before.
Ready to Serve
Run the sealed container under hot water briefly to release the ice block, and you're ready to go!

Nora Maynard is a longtime home mixologist and an occasional instructor at NYC’s Astor Center. She is a contributor to The Business of Food: Encyclopedia of the Food and Drink Industries and is the recipient of the American Egg Board Fellowship in culinary writing at the Writers’ Colony at Dairy Hollow. She previously covered food and drink in film at The Kitchn in her weekly column, The Celluloid Pantry.
Related: Good Question: Know a Great Holiday Punch?
(Images: Nora Maynard)
I made the spiked apple cider (from last week's post) for my cookie competition and it was a total hit. As usual, I froze some juice to use as the ice to keep the punch from getting watery. This year I made the ice in the Williams-Sonoma small presents cake pan, so I had frozen bow-wrapped apple juice packages floating in my punch!
view girl42's profile
girl42 - brilliant!
view hmr's profile
I usually either freeze some of the punch, iced tea, ginger ale (some component of the drink) to use as ice. I find fun shapes as well -- like I use a snowman muffin pan to make ice for my Christmas party.
view jennipearl's profile
i wonder what would happen if you froze your punch bowl half-filled with punch the night before, and then filled up the rest the next day? Eventually the ice would pop off the bottom and float to the top, but that would be fine, right? hmmmm...
view anb's profile
A side note to girl42's solution:
If you're making a very boozy punch, remember that alcohol's freezing point is much lower than water's. To make sure your ice cubes fully freeze, use your mixer (juice, tonic, what-have-you) and not the punch itself.
A friend made this mistake with a punch that was chock-full of, uh, "holiday cheer", and the ice cubes were very hesitant to form. Unless you're using a very high proof liquor -- like Everclear (eek) or Bacardi 151 -- this probably won't be an issue, but keep an eye on the cubes to be sure.
view akay's profile
Super Ice-Making Tip #437: For pretty, crystal clear ice, use distilled water.
view AlanMcCoy's profile
I like punch to look like my grandma's punch from my childhood--I use a bundt-shaped jello mold to freeze the juice or gingerale and pieces of fruit.
view BetterBombshell's profile
AlanMcCoy is right! For clear cubes on an ongoing basis, empty your (cooled) teakettle into your ice cube trays each time you make a fresh pot of tea.
view tasterspoon's profile
your tea kettle does not contain distilled water. in fact it has concentrated the salts and minerals in your water.
if you want cooling without dilution: use dry ice but be sure that no one puts any in their cups - lip burns may result.
view sciencegeek's profile
Another way to do it is to use an ice cream container- the plastic kind. My mum makes a fruit based punch and we freeze a mixture of juice and fruit in the container then drop it in the punch before serving, this way there is no watering down of the punch when it melts but rather just more flavour!
view bkk's profile
Respectfully differ with sciencegeek. Boiled water does make clear ice. Yes it is not distilled water but is not concentrated in minerals [unless you have boiled it a long time and reduced the volume.] It makes clear ice because it de-gassed by boiling. Gas [CO2, O2, Cl,...] nucleating out and forming tiny bubbles as the ice freezes this the main reason for cloudy ice. This is apparent in the appearance of the ice - the last water to freeze has the least clarity because of increasing concentration of dissolved gas in the water.
view phoxx's profile
Warm water contains more dissolved gases than cold water.
view sciencegeek's profile
My bad, I didn't mean to suggest that boiled = distilled. All I meant to say was that cooled boiled water gives me clear ice cubes. I don't give it further thought.
view tasterspoon's profile