apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Hot or Not? Individual Pie Slice Pans

2008_07_22-PieDish.jpgWe saw these individual pie slice pans at King Arthur Flour yesterday and we were both charmed and bemused. Individual pie slices - would you use these?

 
 

We could go either way on these. On the one hand, they are pretty cute, and we like firm crusty edges on our pie. These would give that crusty edge on every side. They say that these bake perfect wedge-shaped servings every time; they're each 5” wedges with a 2/3 cup capacity. Dishwasher-safe too.

On the other hand, we could do almost exactly the same thing in one of the ramekins we have on hand; we must have two dozen knocking about our cupboards! What do you think?

Individual Pie Slice Pans - Set of 2, $10.95 at King Arthur Flour

Related: Meyer Lemon Shaker Pie

(Images: King Arthur Flour)

Tags

Baking Supplies, Surveys, baking, pie, Hot or Not, pie pan

Related Links

Share

Comments (15)

you can't get a smaller/bigger slice this way...

posted by Lady J on 2008-07-22 11:52:56
view Lady J's profile

Awww, come on. The best part of eating pie is holding the knife over the pie, pivoting from the center, and repeating "here? here? here?"!
Then, of course, when your guest decides on the size, creating a diversion while you cut the slice just a little bit bigger.
I was pretty sure the world would explode if this sacred ritual were tampered with...

posted by bangbangpow on 2008-07-22 11:56:16
view bangbangpow's profile

I don't need more complexity in cooking. There's little time enough. Also, how do you eat it? I think it would be harder to either a) eat out of these than eating pie off a plate or b) harder to get this out of the pan to eat on the plate. I won't even comment on the dishwashing aspect.

I'm sure there's some benefit, but I'm not seeing it.

posted by Pixie on 2008-07-22 12:03:53
view Pixie's profile

I feel this is one of these things that look adorable but it is not practical. It seems that we must eat inside the pan because it must be hard to remove it without breaking the hot potpie. Then, I will be afraid to burn myself. Extra steps are required to eat a warmed fruit pie with ice cream.

One suitable usage can be for singles or couples for which a regular pie is simply too large. You can prep several pieces, freeze them and cook them on a need basis.

posted by At Home with kim vallee on 2008-07-22 12:20:51
view At Home with kim vallee's profile

I can see it being used for other stuff but not pie! It's annoying enough to get the dough into a big round plate, can you imagine the time it would take to get it just right... ack.

posted by mgn on 2008-07-22 12:25:07
view mgn's profile

Big no no.

Imagine washing the things.... yeah, they are dishwasher safe, but I don t care what the advertisement says, you need elbow grease to get those things clean

If I got those as a gift, I would use them - but not for pizza and pies. To serve olives, crackers, peanuts, on cocktail parties :-)

posted by SallyBR on 2008-07-22 12:28:32
view SallyBR's profile

The clean-up aslect alone makes me shudder.

posted by Squirrely on 2008-07-22 12:33:06
view Squirrely's profile

I can kind of see the appeal of these -- for things other than pie, though. Wouldn't an array of snacks look cute with six different dishes of them set up in a circle?

Personally, I like making pies just to share with as many people as possible...and if I wanted to make a mini pie for one I would break out my oven-proof ramekins/pudding cups instead of having to buy a special dish.

posted by SexyAnteater on 2008-07-22 13:14:57
view SexyAnteater's profile

Attack of the unitaskers! Not to mention too much work. I can't imagine filling those tight corners with pie crust. At least ramekins have a wide variety of uses.

posted by crazy_betty on 2008-07-22 13:35:37
view crazy_betty's profile

Ridiculous! More work for the pie maker. I do love King Arthur flours, but their catalog is full of one-use gadgets. Sure, they look pretty on the page, but they're the sorts of things that will just clog up the cupboards.

And darn it, now I want pie.

posted by CleanSimple on 2008-07-22 13:44:21
view CleanSimple's profile

^bangbangpow---too funny!

I agree these look very cute, but are very impractical.

posted by bobcatsteph3 on 2008-07-22 14:13:42
view bobcatsteph3's profile

But it wouldn't be pie in a ramekin. Apple pie is my arch nemesis due to wetness. The last one I made turned out fine by my standards but my dad insisted that the crust was not done enough. Next time I will give him his own mini slice to bake to whatever level of dryness he wants. Hopefully you can buy just one for the backseat cook in the family.

posted by sally599 on 2008-07-22 16:18:09
view sally599's profile

Besides the filling and crust, the real joy of pie is "straightening out the edges"--that is, ensuring that my world is safe from the threat of uneven edges of pie. On that point alone, I must say NOT when queried about the individual pie slice pan's level of hotness.

posted by krister on 2008-07-22 23:35:50
view krister's profile

I would never use these to bake, but I would love something like this for storage/transit. I swear I once saw pie-slice-shaped tupperware or the like, thought it useless, and have since changed my mind and can't find it. Anybody have/seen something like that?

posted by cmcinnyc on 2008-07-23 13:58:39
view cmcinnyc's profile

My mom had one of those pie slice savers from Tupperware, but I think she gave it away last summer when we remodeled her kitchen.

posted by kaanswfm on 2008-07-24 21:45:17
view kaanswfm's profile