apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Help! Did I Ruin My Copper Pots?
Good Questions

2009_10_22-CopperPot.jpgQ: I decided to take my copper pots once used for decor and take off the laqueur so i can cook with them. Now they have horrible black stains and a terrible copper finish and I am so sorry I ruined these shiny beautful things. I have used a Twinkle copper cleaner — a waste of time and money.

But now what can I do to get back at least some sheen and get rid of the black oxidization?

Sent by Natalie

 
 

Editor: Natalie, we're so sorry to hear that! We don't have a lot of direct experience with copper pots, so we'll throw this out to the readers. Readers, what advice would you give Natalie? Have you had similar experience with copper pans or pots?

Related: Good Question: Is My Vintage Copper Kettle Safe to Use?

(Image: Mauviel Copper 1.8-Quart Zabaglione Pan at Amazon)

Comments (18)

I'd probably start with vinegar and salt, or Bon Ami. Use a sponge or very fine steel wool (#0000).

posted by melkozek on October 22nd 2009 at 10:11am
view melkozek's profile

My mom had copper bottomed pots, and one year for christmas I scrubbed them all til they shined.

Within a week they were all black again, copper is only pretty if you don't cook with it imho.

posted by ktoth04 on October 22nd 2009 at 10:13am
view ktoth04's profile

The pots aren't ruined. They are still useful, but they won't look like the one in the photo anymore.

posted by slobound on October 22nd 2009 at 10:18am
view slobound's profile

Are copper pots usually used for decor? Is that why they are lacquered? I'm so confused.
My mom had copper bottom pots that she scrubbed with copper cleaner every time she used them. I think they are very high maintenance.

posted by Nikita on October 22nd 2009 at 10:21am
view Nikita's profile

They aren't at all ruined, they are just hard to take care of, and they can look just like they used to.

I've used copper for cooking exclusively for many years. Here is what I do to keep my pans looking good.

It's a two-step process...

a) Use Bar Keeper's Friend. It will get you 90% there quickly. You can find it online or in most cooking/grocery stores.

b) When you want the original shine back, follow up step a) with a polishing with Wenol. You can find Wenol at cooking shops or online.

Essentially you are cleaning and removing oxidation with a) and b) is just polishing. I have about a dozen copper pots and I do about one every week (that's a lot of labor, but I really love them) and they stay nice for a month or so.

Make sure you keep them clean and dry and the finish will last longer.

My copper is 10 years old and looks as good as new when I follow these steps.

posted by meekmeek on October 22nd 2009 at 10:56am
view meekmeek's profile

I'm also confused about remove the lacquer... were these pots not meant to be cooked with?

posted by lsk on October 22nd 2009 at 10:59am
view lsk's profile

Copperbrill was made to clean Mauviel copper pots, and works wonders. It's pretty easy to use, and since it's designed specifically to take the tarnish off copper, it doesn't require too much elbow grease.

I work somewhere where the copper pans (about 30 of them) have to be polished every two weeks. Takes less than 5 mintues a pot usually. I only use Bon Ami when there is a small stain I want off.

Hope that helps!

posted by Amanda0730 on October 22nd 2009 at 11:02am
view Amanda0730's profile

If they were the shiny lacquered kind that you can get at Hobby Lobby or Michaels (or similar store) then they werent' meant for cooking. They're probably not even solid copper, just a thin layer of copper on top of God-knows-what.

Otherwise, I've also had great success cleaning copper with Bar Keeper's Friend. Excellent stuff, that.

posted by m_dow on October 22nd 2009 at 11:12am
view m_dow's profile

FYI: Copper pots have a lacquer that is to be removed before you cook with them. Even the ones that ARE meant to be cooked with. There are instructions on the pot on how to remove the lacquer (baking soda and boiling water). Mine is from Sur la Table, for example. According to the tag it says:

no metal tools for stirring, normal for color to change with heat, original color is easily restored by washing with hot soapy water rising and polishing the OUTSIDE ONLY with copper polish, never use steel wool, abrasive powders/liquids or anything that will scratch or damage the surface.

Hope that helps!

posted by MissMatlock on October 22nd 2009 at 11:20am
view MissMatlock's profile

sorry that should be "rinsing" not "rising"

posted by MissMatlock on October 22nd 2009 at 11:21am
view MissMatlock's profile

Hi guys that was my question posted:

yes they are true copper and I did have to remove the laqueur and did so according to company instructions even tho I truly did not know why I had to remove the outside laqueur..

I did the vinegar and salt and it worked temporarily...u would not believe but I ordered Bar Keepers friend via internet (very hard to find in Canada) and the post office lost the package and the store had no more Copper Glo...so I am still looking for that product....

However, I am glad to know that they probably look the way they are supposed to look (a far cry from their previous life) and will definitely cook with them....if I had known how much work it would be to take care of them; I probably would have hung 'em up again...so thankyou all.

posted by blondee47 on October 22nd 2009 at 12:44pm
view blondee47's profile

blondee, if you have any Cucina Moderna's near you, they carry Barkeepers Friend. That's where I got mine.

posted by little_melly on October 22nd 2009 at 3:28pm
view little_melly's profile

we've always used ketchup to clean our copper pots, seems to work at least as good as copper cleaner

posted by mf1192 on October 22nd 2009 at 5:28pm
view mf1192's profile

I've never had copper cookware, but I know that you can clean pennies with a soda like Coke. So perhaps that would also work to soak your cookware clean....

posted by jesstastic on October 22nd 2009 at 5:49pm
view jesstastic's profile

Any place that sells copper or stainless steel pots should sell the cleaners. Also, Bed Bath and beyond has it. I think even Home Depot sells it.

posted by Nudik on October 22nd 2009 at 8:59pm
view Nudik's profile

I appreciate all the readers' advice, and I can understand the writer of this column has minimal experience with this issue. However, I wish there was some kind of effort put into trying to answer the question. It's easy to blog Martha Stewart, or Real Simple, or some cleaning sites.

I appreciate this site being available to answer these questions, but lately, everyone on AT has just been "sending this out to the readers." Come on, guys. I used to love these blog. Please put some effort into giving us useful information. That's why we ask you.

Sorry about the rant. I actually really love the kitchen blog. It's one of my favourites.

posted by janeymac on October 22nd 2009 at 10:17pm
view janeymac's profile

Try checking your local WalMart. That's where I buy Barkeeper's friend. I use it on everything!

posted by MiSchelle on October 25th 2009 at 5:49pm
view MiSchelle's profile

Cleaning with a little vinegar and coarse salt will make the pots "coppery" again, use Bon Ami or Bar keepers Friend abrasive only on stubborn spots on outside, and very, very carefully on inside. They will never be shiny, though. And they don't have to be clean to love them and use them. I let mine "go" so that I don't avoid using them and messing them up!

QUESTION for those who are looking at this - where can I get mine re-tinned. Most pre-date the stainless steel lining manufacture. So I need to send them somewhere, as the place I used to use in Denver has gone out of business.

Hope for help with this!

posted by EllieA on November 17th 2009 at 12:30pm
view EllieA's profile