apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Good Question: What Should We Cook for St. Patrick's?

2009_03_11-Patricks.jpgNJS is doing a St. Patrick's Day meal, but wants some fun yet elegant ideas for starters and desserts. Can you help?

St. Patrick's day is coming up and I wondering if you had any ideas for a St. Patrick's day dinner for a group? St. Patrick's day seems to get wilder and more absurd in the U.S. each year and has basically just turned into one big drinking game. We were really hoping to have a nice dinner party (i.e. no green beer) and many sites seem to go from Valentine's Day meals right into Easter or they just have hokey St. Patrick's day ideas.

We plan on doing corned beef, cabbage, potatoes and carrots. Any ideas for starters or desserts? Ways to liven up the bland traditional meal?

 
 

NJS, here are a few ideas for St. Patrick's Day starters, desserts, and sides (and no green beer - I promise).

Starters
Beef Hand Pies - At Martha Stewart. (Pictured above) We love the look of these little hand pies, which can be adapted to vegetarians too (stuff with cheese and cabbage instead of beef). Make them ultra-mini and they would be awesome little appetizers.
Irish Appetizers - Some of these are a little meh, but the Wild Rice & Barley Stuffed Mushrooms look promising, as do the Cheese Bites with Chutney. These both can be good for vegetarian guests, too.
• If the whole dinner is a sit-down affair, try a soup to start. What's more Irish than potatoes and leeks? Try Dana's super-easy potato leek soup. Or try this very green Kale and Apple Soup. These could be served in little cups as soup shots too.

Side Dishes
• You may be going the traditional route and boiling the potatoes, cabbage, and meat all together. But if you want to split them up, this cabbage recipe is deeply delicious; it's a recipe to convert cabbage-haters: Wine-Braised Cabbage. Also see this Roasted Baby Cabbage.
• Or you could leave the cabbage crunchy for a more interesting salad, like this one: Fresh Fennel and Lemon Slaw, and serve the potatoes cold in a spring potato salad: Mixed New Potato Salad with Sweet Basil and Shallots.
• Also try our Fried Cabbage and Potato Cakes.
• A side dish of applesauce is always good with all the salty vegetables and meat.

Dessert
• Dessert is easy! How about a Stout Float or our own Guinness Milkshake?
• You can put Guinness in ice cream too: David Lebovitz's Guinness-Milk Chocolate Ice Cream.
• Or just go for a dark, rich cake: Chocolate Guinness Cake.
• And of course there's always Irish Coffee to end, or perhaps a nip of Irish whiskey.

Related: Dinner Tonight: Last Minute St. Patrick's Day Ideas

(Images: Martha Stewart; Mikkel Vang for Gourmet)

Tags

Good Questions, Entertaining, Holidays - St. Patrick's Day, menu planning

Related Links

Share

Comments (13)

Smitten Kitchen's "Car Bomb" cupcakes. Guiness chocolate cake cupcakes with Bailey's cream frosting. Need I say more?

http://smittenkitchen.com/2009/01/car-bomb-cupcakes/

posted by jess pith on March 11th 2009 at 1:33pm
view jess pith's profile

I'd go with Tamasin Day Lewis' Bittersweet Chocolate Irish Whisky Cake:

http://www.epicurious.com/recipes/food/photo/Bittersweet-Chocolate-Irish-Whiskey-Cake-238254

For starters, since you are going with a very heavy main course, I'd make warmed oysters with chive sauce:

http://britishfood.about.com/od/starter1/r/oysters.htm

Or Mussels in Garlic and Guiness:

http://www.irishcultureandcustoms.com/2Kitch/Starters.html

posted by mschatelaine on March 11th 2009 at 1:51pm
view mschatelaine's profile

When I was a kid, mom would always make us Broonie for breakfast on St. Patrick's Day. It's a light gingerbread with oatmeal. Here's a similar recipe:
http://www.recipezaar.com/Orkney-Broonie-122068

Substitute molasses for treacle.

posted by inkstainedwriter on March 11th 2009 at 2:48pm
view inkstainedwriter's profile

Irish coffee, definitely! We make it with strong coffee, irish whiskey and lightly sweetened whipped cream. (I don't actually drink it because I dislike coffee, but it's my dad's specialty after-dinner drink)

Maybe serve some fancy mustards with your corned beef and cabbage? I know it's the only way I eat mustard a lot of the time.

I hear guiness floats are quite good, too.

posted by Tiamat_the_Red on March 11th 2009 at 2:50pm
view Tiamat_the_Red's profile

Difficult to think of typically Irish appies, and I'm speaking as an Irish person! Traditional Irish fare rarely includes starters, as it tends to be rustic "peasant" type food. Corned beef not usually eaten in Ireland, it's usually ham or bacon. The cabbage is cooked with the bacon, added towards the end of the cooking time, but I've only seen the potatoes boiled separately.
Popular starters in Ireland, from my experience, are not very "traditional", and not particularly "Irish" eg steamed mussels, root veg soups, melon, deep fried brie with fruit coulis.
For dessert, how about brown bread ice cream? Bread and butter pudding? Stewed apple or rhubarb with custard? Even if there is no dessert, every dinner finishes with a cup of tea and a biscuit/ cookie.

posted by kitchennightmare on March 11th 2009 at 3:07pm
view kitchennightmare's profile

and after ( or while ) you eat these delicious things, I recommend watching "Darby O' Gill and the Little People"

posted by Kate (NC) on March 11th 2009 at 3:54pm
view Kate (NC)'s profile

I tried the Beef Hand Pies from Everyday Food last week. If you make them, consider adding sauteed onion and much more in the way of seasonings. They were pretty and flaky, but bland.

posted by truckstoptunes on March 11th 2009 at 4:18pm
view truckstoptunes's profile

I apologize in advance for what may sound like snark; I've just had a couple too many "what's up with the green beer anyway" conversations with Irish friends.

One way to "liven up" the "bland traditional meal" is...go with something a bit more authentic. Corned beef isn't actually all that authentically Irish. It's Irish-American, definitely -- it was based on a bacon-and-cabbage dish popular as a celebratory meal among the Irish peasants who came over during the days of the Famine.

These days, though, the cuisine in Ireland proper has improved somewhat -- and you can have something a little more authentic, but tastier. Salmon in any way, shape, or form is one choice -- there's an ancient Irish legend about the hero Finn McCool eating a magic salmon that gave him wisdom, so there's a tie-in there. Spiced roast beef is more of a Christmas thing, but would also do.

Then there's some of the homier casseroles and "pub grub" kind of things that could even be side-dishes for if you want to stick with the corned beef. Colcannon -- a sort of casserole of mashed potatoes, cabbage, onion, and cheese -- is very traditional. Something I love is Dublin Coddle -- a stew of bacon, sausage, sliced potato, sliced onion, and sliced carrot.

As for a nice simple green side dish, I found a simple recipe in an Irish cookbook that just combined green peas, green beans, lima beans, and butter beans; they were all just simply cooked and mixed together in a very simple sauce of just a bit of melted butter, a dash of parsley, and a couple strips of bacon crumbled on top. I brought that to a pot luck and it was devoured by everyone who had been getting sick of all the baked ziti and such.

There are some very traditional fruit desserts -- fruit crumbles or fruit crisps are always good, and then there's the "fool" or the "flummery." Both the fool and the flummery are very simple, mousse or pudding-type things -- for the fool, you stew fruit, puree it with a bit of sugar, and then fold it into whipped cream and chill until firm. Flummery is similar, but a bit thicker -- one recipe I have involves whipping together cream cheese and heavy cream, lacing it with some whiskey and toasted oatmeal, and then layering that in a parfait glass with raspberries.

posted by empresscallipygos on March 11th 2009 at 6:21pm
view empresscallipygos's profile

I second Deb's (smittenkitchen.com) Car Bomb cupcakes.. made the cupcake version.. then did a cake version which is easier and equally delicious (both in the last 6 wks)

I just did 2 9 inch rounds, poured ganache in the middle and on the sides and frosted w/the bailey's buttercream.

I plan on making another cake for the coworkers next week.

posted by crasht1224 on March 11th 2009 at 7:42pm
view crasht1224's profile

I love corned beef, but I love corned beef followed by an Irish coffee or a stout float more!! I am so excited for my own green-beer-less St. Patrick's Day party.

posted by mandarinmarie on March 11th 2009 at 8:01pm
view mandarinmarie's profile

OMG ... I was totally planning to do the Guinness chocolate cake for my friend's b-day this weekend after I saw it at RecipeGirl - http://www.recipegirl.com/2008/08/11/chocolate-guinness-stout-cake/.

But carbomb is totally taking it up another notch. Awesomeness!

posted by rebelle on March 11th 2009 at 8:55pm
view rebelle's profile

Make some brown bread and try to find some Kerrygold butter!

posted by bos_ted on March 12th 2009 at 7:51am
view bos_ted's profile

Irish soda-bread with potato soup?

If you're not above a little bit of st-patricks-day cheesiness, you might do a salad starter displayed in the shape of a clover leaf.

posted by angorian on March 12th 2009 at 9:48am
view angorian's profile