apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Good Question: Casual Dinner Party for Twenty?

2007_12_20-HowToDinnerParty.jpgDear Kitchn,
I am having a casual get together on Friday. Just me, my family, and some other friends who are staying in town for the holidays.... and I ambitiously offered to cook dinner for everyone!

Our friends will bring cookies and dessert, but I need an easy dinner main dish for 15-20, including a few children. This isn't a big holiday party, so I'm not looking for something too fancy. We all will be coming from work so it needs to be low-maintenance, but still tasty, of course! I don't cook for this many very often so any ideas would be much appreciated!

Thank you...
- Anne

Anne, when it comes to cooking for a crowd we have a few staples. Here are the best dinners for a crowd that we know. We are always looking for more, though, since we do have dinner parties frequently. Hopefully our readers will come up with more!

• Pasta and meat sauce. The old reliable standby. Try our Lamb Ragu. You can also make a quick sauce of broccoli and zucchini with garlic for the vegetarians.

• Crockpot roast. Sear a big pork or beef roast on all sides and pop it in the slow cooker with some garlic, wine, herbs and broth. Heck - if you're short on time you don't even have to sear it. Cook on low for 10-12 hours then pull it apart. See another recipe here: Slow-Cooked Pork Roast, Two Ways.

• Curry and rice. If your guest list is made up of people who prefer spicy food, try a slow-cooked curry. You can also leave this in the slow cooker all day. Then just serve with rice for a hearty dinner. Try our Malaysian Beef Curry and Green Coconut and Pork Curry.

Now we'll throw this one open to the readers. What's your go-to dish when you have to serve a crowd?

(Image credit: History Cooperative)

Comments (19)

There is a pennette recipe with meat sauce on the Food and Wine website that looks delicious, and supposed to be good for a crowd. Their macaroni and cheese with buttery bread crumbs is also a big hit with kids and adults alike.

posted by Jordanna on 2007-12-20 12:35:49
view Jordanna's profile

I make a roast and spaghetti squash.

I get a top rump roast (or two) with generally half as many pounds as people so 20 people = 10 pounds. (there's usually some left over but that's what roast beef sandwiches are for.

Then, for cooking it:
-put the pan in the oven while preheating, and five minutes before you put in the roast, pour a small amount (couple tbsp) of olive oil in the pan.
-cut an onion in half, cut a tomato in half, cut a few cloves of garlic in half.
-Put it all in the pan with the roast(fat side up, so it self-bastes)
-cook at: 425 deg F for 15 minutes, then 350 for 15 min/lb (10 pounds=150min=2hrs 30min)

I usually serve the roasted veggies on the side because the onion gets amazingly sweet. You can use the jus and a bit of red wine to make a light gravy on the stove.

Now for the spaghetti squash:
1. poke it all over with a knife (I have broken too many forks that I simply use a knife).
2. put it in a microwavable dish
3. microwave on high for 15 minutes
4. cut in half and scoop out seeds: dispose of them.
5. use a fork to scrape out the "spaghetti", top with salt, pepper and butter

1 squash feeds about 5-7 people

Voila, simple, yet yummy meal in just a couple of hours.

posted by nadnuk on 2007-12-20 12:56:13
view nadnuk's profile

I must add that I got the roast recipe from Nigella Lawson's How to Eat, and this is what I have memorized now.

And the spaghetti squash is from The Joy of Cooking

posted by nadnuk on 2007-12-20 12:57:20
view nadnuk's profile

If it's really relaxed and you are ok with a non- roast type meal - I say spaghetti all the way. One big bowl of pasta, a wonderful salad and a glass of wine (or juice for the kids) and you are done.

I have done this several times for the holiday's for a large relaxed family get together.

No fuss, one pot and lots of time fun fun and talking with loved ones and making memories.

posted by annaland on 2007-12-20 13:00:56
view annaland's profile

What about a big pot of soup stew with lots of crusty bread? Something with white beans, kale and sausage? Sounds good to me!

posted by pierrot on 2007-12-20 13:05:54
view pierrot's profile

pierrot,

you are making me very hungry.

Great idea too because it can be made well in advance and just reheated.

One problem I could see though, is that many people don't have that many big soup bowls?

I don't want to sound too simplistic but...you could roast a ham or a beef roast and set up a buffet with various rolls and bread, a salad or two and a veggie (like the roasted squash above).

That way, it would be pretty casual. People may be late due to traffic, flights, work, etc. and there's no worries. People can slice the meat for sandwiches with some mustard or horseradish (kids mostly) and the others can prepare a nice plate.

And if you serve the sausage, kale and bean soup can you email me a bowl please?

posted by art on 2007-12-20 13:20:36
view art's profile

When cooking for a crowd, I go for casserole dishes that I can pre-make the night before and pop into the oven when I get home from work. I've done lasagna, enchiladas, mac and cheese, and spanokopita. Add a salad and maybe an extra side dish and you're good to go!

posted by Lorena in SD on 2007-12-20 13:24:21
view Lorena in SD's profile

Chili. Pre-made, the night before and heated up. Guests can top their own with a variety of toppings (cheese, sour cream, fresh herbs, etc.). Serve with crusty bread or corn bread.

posted by J-fer Rose on 2007-12-20 13:28:18
view J-fer Rose's profile

Chili is great for big groups... You can even have several types going in different crock pots. We usually have crackers, cheese, sour cream, noodles and such going for toppings.

We've also done the pasta route, with the sauces in crock pots. One was just a marinara, one with meatballs in the sauce, and one a meat sauce. Just remember to toss the noodles in either butter or oil to keep them from sticking to one another since guests are adding the sauce later. Don't forget Parmesan cheese, and lots of crusty bread.

If you do a big pot of stew, but don't have a lot of bowls, we've also served such items in coffee mugs, so we would have less waste when the whole thing was through.

posted by FrannyA on 2007-12-20 13:40:29
view FrannyA's profile

The Barefoot Contessa's Turkey Sausage & Goat Cheese Lasagna. You can even make it layered with plain tomato sauce, and serve the turkey sausage sauce on the side in case you have vegetarians.

posted by NyKittyNy on 2007-12-20 13:43:49
view NyKittyNy's profile

On Christmas eve, my family makes corned beef sandwiches. My grandmother used to actually make the corned beef from scratch, but she's gotten a bit too old for that sort of thing. Now we buy a bunch from the deli, a couple of loaves of bread and all the fixings, and everone makes their own sandwiches. It's very laid back, and everyone just spends the evening enjoying each others company instead of making food. It's definately doable for a large crowd, and no cooking for you!

I'm all for the stew or soup idea. That's easy in large quantities, and gets better if it's been in the fridge over night anyway. And if you buy the bread and make a large salad, you don't have to do much cooking beyond the soup. If there are any kids who are picky eaters, keep some of those individual bagel pizzas in the freezer. If they refuse the soup, they'll probably eat them and you won't have to cook them.

Also, Trader Joes is your friend.

posted by SassySally on 2007-12-20 14:14:08
view SassySally's profile

The trick to a large dinner party, I have discovered, is to have everyone bring a food item until you have everything on the menu covered...

heehee....

posted by KrapArtist on 2007-12-20 14:15:29
view KrapArtist's profile

Why don't you make a buffet of dishes that you can prepare in advance?
* a pasta salad with nuts, gruyere cheese cubes and diced roasted vegetables;
* skewers with herb frittata cubes, cherry tomatoes and basil leaves;
*spicy roasted chicken drumsticks
* a fennel gratin
*pots de creme for desert, and a chocolate cake as well...

just some ideas

posted by Sol on 2007-12-20 14:58:41
view Sol's profile

I second J-fer Rose's chili suggestion, with either a yummy homemade cheddar cornbread, or the ubiquitous No-Knead Bread. Mmmm.

posted by Heuristic Chick on 2007-12-20 16:04:14
view Heuristic Chick's profile

Well, you really can't go wrong with a spiral ham - you just heat that up. And maybe a roast beef or pork? If you got some great crusty rolls and good cheeses it could be a make your own delicious sandwich supper.

Coming from a big Italian family I guess I'm from the 'deli tray & antipasti platter makes any party good' school - oh and don't forget a couple of decks of playing cards.

posted by Oven Mitzie on 2007-12-20 23:08:29
view Oven Mitzie's profile

I always like those super long sandwiches! I usually make a southwester butternut squash stew with hominy from the Greens cookbook. It's really good, and seems very gourmet without having to fuss too much.

posted by SFGail on 2007-12-20 23:46:04
view SFGail's profile

How about chicken marbella? I made this for 9 people and had leftovers. And it's so delicious.
Serves 10-12. Easy to make.
4 chickens quartered (I use 2-1/2 and seems to be plenty)
1 head of garlic, peeled and minced
1/4 c. dried oregano
Salt and pepper
1/2 c. Red wine vinegar
1/2 c. olive oil
1 c. pitted prunes
1/2 c. pitted green spanish olives
1/2 c. capers with juice
6 bay leaves
1 c. brown sugar
1 c. white wine
1/4 c. chopped parsley

1. combine all but last three items. Marinate in fridge overnight. Try a
garbage bag if making a full recipe).
2. Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
3. Arrange chicken in shallow pan. Spoon marinade over it. Sprinkle
with
brown sugar and drizzle with wine.
4. Bake 60 minutes, basting occasionally.
5. Transfer to a platter with slotted spoon. Drizzle with a few
spoonfuls
of pan juices. Garnish with parsley. Pass remaining juice in a
sauceboat.

Enjoy!

posted by alexarc on 2007-12-21 15:28:28
view alexarc's profile

Two lasagnas...one vegetarian with white sauce, one with meat sauce, tossed salad, fruit salad, crusty garlic toast.

posted by polkadot on 2007-12-22 11:28:34
view polkadot's profile

Go for some Rick Bayless-inspired build-your-own tacos with a couple of different fillings. Good for groups with picky eaters...the meats can be prepared the night before and quickly reheated. Last-minute prep is limited to some chopping -- the guests do most of the assembly work themselves!

Make three kinds of fillings...I'd go with:
- shredded poached or roasted chicken simmered briefly with some mild tomatillo salsa right before serving (I make my own, but Arriba or another good brand is great)
- shredded slow-cooked spicy pork or beef (i.e., cochinita pibil or barbacoa)
- black beans and sauteed baby bella mushrooms/onions/garlic

Take care of vegetarians/vegans, meat eaters, and kids (they love the chicken) with your selections. Other possibilities are grilled or fried fish, fajita-style meats, and old-school Tex Mex ground beef. The ones above are the easiest for me, though.

Chop up tomatos, lettuce, raw onions, seeded jalapenos, maybe some avocado, and cilantro (required). Have sour cream, cheese (I'd go for a crumbly fresh mild skim cheese), and guacamole, plus maybe some salsas. Serve with small soft tortillas warmed up (people will want to try multiple fillings) -- consider both corn and flour.

The secret is ample variety, to suit all tastes. The tomatillo chicken is usually a huge hit in my house -- twenty people could easily take down two good-sized hens.

Zack from Texas

posted by wuzuwu on 2008-01-15 23:29:56
view wuzuwu's profile
Buy Text Ads