Here's a question from reader Amy, who lives in Manhattan. Any city-dwellers able to help her out with this good question about grilling?
My boyfriend and I have just bought a brand new propane grill from Home Depot with dreams of cooking out all summer long. But it seems propane tanks are illegal in Manhattan. Do you know what the rules/loopholes are surrounding this? Surely we can't be the only people who have a propane grill? Also, if it is illegal why would they sell them at the Manhattan Home Depot!? Please help us else our dreams of tasty grilled meats will be shattered!
And here's an update from Amy:
We were so eager to start grilling we found a delivery company that brought us a propane tank at 7am Saturday morning, it cost $87 and once it runs out we can call back and they'll bring us another full one for a cheaper price. The company is called Manhattan Propane, it seems a little weird since it is officially "illegal." But we're happy to have a functioning grill! And I can just put in my experience in the comments or you can put it as an update or something.
Amy, we don't have any direct experience with this, so we're throwing it open to the readers. What have your experiences been with propane tanks and grilling in Manhattan?
Related: Outside Cooking: Build Your Own Grill
(Image: Flickr member Unlisted Sightings licensed for use under Creative Commons)
Don't tell my landlord, but we've been grilling for about 2 years now (including 3 times in the past week). We have a small table top propane grill which we bring inside whenever we're finished grilling. I remember last summer seeing tons of people grilling, though I haven't noticed anybody yet this year. My advice, just be careful about it. If you're in a larger building, it'll probably be pretty hard for them to catch you.
view dev1ils's profile
Having a propane tank is not illegal in Manhattan. However, using them (or getting caught using them) on a terrace, balcony, or roof is illegal. You are welcome to use a propane-fueled grill in your home as long as you have no more than two, and you are on the grounds (garden or yard) of your one or two-family home. Hence -- Manhattan grilling is difficult, unless you want to use charcoal.
The other thing to remember, is that getting caught with a propane tank in any of the tunnels going in and out of Manhattan is VERY unpleasant, and can result in HUGE fines. So -- if you're carting them around, take the bridges.
view LeeHouck's profile
It is illegal but a law widely broken according to the view from our roof deck, where we can see several gas grills in action as we wait for our charcoal to heat up every night.
view VillageOven's profile
who would use a grill indoors? wouldn't that set off the smoke detector, piss of the neighbors and draw the fire dept. at the same time?
there was once an episode of "felicity" in which the RA caught a guy lighting up a grill in his (manhattan) dorm room. as a former RA, i could not believe that scene. to encounter such a stunt in real life would lift the dome off my skull.
view Lady J's profile
Heh. As a former dorm resident, I can totally believe that someone, some where, has tried it.
view tariqata's profile
Here's the FDNY's site on grilling:
http://www.nyc.gov/html/fdny/html/safety/barbeque.shtml
I will say that I have known some people to grill on their fire escape with a table top grill...
view Mota Rose's profile
Maybe use the small, Coleman camping propane canisters? Obviously not a lot of propane, but they'll be easy to hide when you're done!
view emmaduck's profile
I should have said earlier- I use the small coleman camping canisters. Works fine for the two of us
view dev1ils's profile
so you may not use them "in" your home, but in your yard or whatever you call the external part of the property around a non-apartment structure... that makes sense.
view Lady J's profile
I just use charcoal. I think it has better flavor, and it's certainly cheaper than propane in Manhattan. If you are above 145th st., you can use your charcoal grill in the parks up there for picnics and such.
view ScienceandtheCity's profile
Here is a good NYTIMES article, you can't even have a propane tank if it is more than 1 pound.
http://www.nytimes.com/1999/07/04/nyregion/outlaws-in-greasy-aprons-flouting-propane-code-new-yorkers-grill-outdoors.html?pagewanted=2
view liz100's profile
$87 for a tank of propane???? Are you kidding me??!!
view Kathryn's profile
"$87 for a tank of propane???? Are you kidding me??!!"
I think that's deposit for the canister and delivery, she did say the next tank would be cheaper.
view funstraw's profile
Using a grill (of any kind) on a balcony or rooftop is illegal in most cities. But I think most people do it anyway...
view boldcitygirl's profile
I have friends who burned down their beautiful house in Boston after grilling on their (wooden) porch. Please be careful!
view LizO's profile
We have been using a company called Tony's LPG
718 626-8111. They are very knowledgeable about the laws concerning propane. Their service is great and they work around our schedule. I have recommended them to many friends and they are all very satisfied with their service.
view josephsorce's profile