apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Survey: Do You Sift Your Flour?

2008_01_16-Sifter.jpg

How many times have you seen these instructions in a recipe: Sift the flour, baking soda, and salt... Quite a lot, right? How many times do you follow it? We're curious about how often you sift your flour and dry ingredients - are you a rule-follower when it comes to baking?

Take our survey then click through for our own answer, some more information on sifting, and tips like how to sift flour without a sifter.

 
 

We admit that we chose "Sometimes..." Commercial flour is far better sifted than its early predecessors, which needed to be sifted free of lumps, chaff, and even bugs. We sift our dry ingredients when we want to be really, really sure that they are all combined, like when we are making a very finely textured cake. But usually our modern high-powered mixers will do their work so well that this isn't much of a concern.

• If you are being very particular about sifting you may wonder if you sift the flour before or after measuring. The key is in how the recipe is written. If the recipe tells you the quantity first, then says to sift it (ie 3 cups flour, sifted) then measure it first then sift, along with the other dry ingredients. If the recipe says "3 cups of sifted flour" then you should sift a quantity of flour and take your three cups out of it.

• How to sift flour without a sifter: Simply press the flour down through a large sieve, which is a more common tool in a kitchen than a sifter.

The sifter picture above is from Crate & Barrel and retails for $14.95.

Tags

Surveys, Tips & Techniques, Gadgets, Ingredients - Pantry, baking, flour

Related Links

Share

Comments (11)

I'm not sure what you mean by "press" the flour through the sieve? I usually lay out a piece of wax paper or flexible cutting board and shake the dry ingredients over it through the sieve... it's about a million times faster then an actual flour sifter. You can sometime get away with whisking everything in a bowl if you're not really worried about lumps, just intermingling the baking soda, salt and flour or whatever.

posted by mgn on 2008-01-16 15:58:37
view mgn's profile

I ALWAYS sift!!! (some may say it's a sin not too!) However, I do not use the 'hand crank' sifter. I use a regular spoon like sifter. I used to use the hand crank sifter but the risk vs reward just wasn't there. I never could get it quite clean after using it.

~TableBread
http://tablebread.blogspot.com

posted by TableBread on 2008-01-16 16:08:04
view TableBread's profile

I always sift if the recipe calls for it (I do use the hand-crank sifter), and I assume it has nothing to do with lumps. It's either to mix the dry ingredients really well (sifting them all together) or to measure the flour correctly (sifting before measuring).

posted by Joan A. on 2008-01-16 16:25:27
view Joan A.'s profile

A tip I picked up from watching Martha (and always use now) is to "lazy-sift" by whisking together the dry ingrediets in a bowl. It mixes the dry ingredients together while breaking up lumps and works as well as traditional sifting, in my experience anyway.

posted by Jenny Ryan on 2008-01-16 16:49:44
view Jenny Ryan's profile

By the way, the measuring cups in the picture look exactly like mine (also from C&B), and I got them because they were the only metal ones I could find where the handles were of a piece with the cups, and so most likely won't break off.

posted by Joan A. on 2008-01-16 16:52:12
view Joan A.'s profile

I do own a sifter, but it sits in the bin of used-once-a-year kitchen tools at the very back of a cupboard. I just use a fork to mix all the dry stuff togeather and get out lumps. I only use the proper sifter if a recipe calls for the sifting before the measuring, and I do that to get the measurements right, but that is really rare...

posted by Rosie on 2008-01-16 18:04:39
view Rosie's profile

I always sift when it's called for, but I usually use a fine mesh sieve rather than a traditional sifter. I own a sifter, but the sieve is more readily accessible and so it gets used.

One of the things I enjoy about baking is that I can usually expect decent results if I follow the directions closely. It's a nice combination of science and art.

I never knew that the measurements for the amount of flour were different depending on the wording. I think I need write that down somewhere so I don't forget!

Another tip I learned from Martha is that you should always measure your flour into the measuring cup by spoonful rather than dipping the cup into the container you keep your flour in. I was surprised to see how different the two amounts were when demonstrated!

posted by hwtm on 2008-01-16 19:25:51
view hwtm's profile

Sometimes? No..no...Always. Baking isn't like cooking, it's a precise science. But, if you are not going to follow exact directions, (which I might add...I've been know to do here and there), you must know this- If a recipe calls for 3 cups sifted flour as opposed to 3 cups flour, sifted; there is a great difference in the amount of flour you will end up with. I have weighed it to check. Sifted flour is fluffier than non- sifted so a cup of sifted is much less than a cup of non-sifted. I hope that made sense. The point is never skip the step when the recipe calls for sifted flour, your cakes will end up much denser than they should as a result because of the extra flour.

posted by Katia on 2008-01-16 21:23:10
view Katia's profile

I can never get the flour to go through the mesh of my seive. And then afterwards I can never wash all the flour out of it. I almost always end up breaking up any clumps with a fork.

posted by mollyjade on 2008-01-17 09:19:12
view mollyjade's profile

Julia Child, in her show about Queen of Sheba cake, puts a measuring cup on a sheet of waxed paper, then sifts the flour right into the cup, and then levels it off. That's one of the French cakes that uses only egg whites for leavening, so I imagine that it's really important not to use too much flour in it.

posted by Joan A. on 2008-01-17 09:47:47
view Joan A.'s profile

I don't sift unless it specifically says to. What i do do, though is measure all my ingredients. A cup of sifted flour is way different than a cup of unsifted flour. That's why I chose sometimes. But if I'm measuring the correct weight of flour, should I sift that?

posted by chusmabilly on 2008-01-18 15:40:32
view chusmabilly's profile