We're big fizzy water drinkers in our house and we've been thinking about investing in a soda siphon for quite some time.They seem fairly straightforward to use and maintain: You fill the container with fresh cold water, screw on the cap, screw in the CO2 cartridge to release the gas, and PRESTO! Fizzy water!
We really like the idea of cutting down on the number of bottles getting tossed in the recycling bin. And as intrepid home cooks, the possibility of customized flavorings has our imagination in high gear!
Does anyone have experience or opinions on devices like this?
With the older glass soda siphons, there was a risk of explosion if too much pressure built up inside the container. This doesn't appear to be as much of a safety concern with the newer models. Their design has been updated quite a bit and the CO2 cartridges are customized for the specific container to only release as much gas as the container can handle.
The manufacturers don't recommend putting any other liquid except for water in the container, but making a flavored fizzy water (a.k.a. Italian soda) is easily done by mixing a few tablespoons of fruit juice concentrate into a glass of fizzy water.
Of course, you can replace the fruit juice with simple syrup, wine, or any other liquid of your choosing. We like the idea of infusing the simple syrup with herbs, spices, and other aromatics!
We've heard a lot of good reviews about the Isi soda siphon, but there are several other brands out on the market in a range of prices. Here are a few we came across:
Isi Soda Siphon SSL, $59.99 at Isi Store
Liss Quart Soda Siphon, $59.99 at Target
Soda Club Home Soda Maker, $79.99 (for a basic package) at Soda Club.
Mr. Fizz Seltzer Bottle, $39.95 via Prairie Moon.
Easy Whip Soda Siphon, $44.95 via Easy Whip
Williams-Sonoma Soda Siphon, $74.95 via William-Sonoma
Check out our article "Make Soda Water at Home" for some other options for DIY sodas!
What do you think: is this a worthwhile investment for seltzer-lovers or another gadget to clutter our shelves?
(Image via Williams Sonoma)
My friend has one and she loves it.
view J's profile
We use and love Soda Club. It is very cheap to operate, allows you to control the carbonation level, and doesn't have a large counter footprint. The bottles are made out of (safe) PES plastic. It works best with cold water we store them in the fridge. When we want cold sparkling water we have it about ten seconds.
We used to go through two cases of imported sparkling water a month. No more air miles! No more wasted glass bottles!
We had a soda siphon but it degraded pretty quickly and frankly, one bottle doesn't get you very far.
view JudiAU's profile
test
view Maxwell's profile
We also use and love the soda club. We were buying so much bottled sparkling water that 2 summers ago we went ahead and bought the soda club "penguin" and haven't purchased another bottle of water since.
view rosebud's profile
My boyfriend has 2 antique leaded crystal soda siphons. They're so sturdy and beautiful. Unfortunately they're not safe due to all the lead.
They make a nice addition to our bar collection though!
view revolution9's profile
We have the isi soda siphon and have been quite happy with it. It makes 1 liter of soda water which is about as much as we drink with dinner anyway. We thought about the Soda Club but didn't want plastic bottles and could not afford the Penguin (the one that uses glass bottles.) This has worked out pretty well for us so far. We live near a beer brewing supplier, so buying new cartridges is only a short bike ride away.
view laura c's profile
My grandpa has one of these and has had it for at least 20 years. One of my earliest childhood memories is going to his house and watching him change the CO2 cartridge and drinking homemade bubble water. I remember it being much bubblier than store bought bubble water. I loved it.
view SarahBrin's profile
Over the winter, I followed the instructions at this site http://foo.net/~jmgray/carbonation/ and built a seltzer maker on my own. Since it uses a CO2 tank you don't have to worry about buying replacement cartridges and you get that feeling of accomplishment from making something yourself! (Plus it looks cool and works great)
view sarahaha's profile
we've recently gotten addicted to pellegrino sparkling mineral water. i'd love to make my own, but how do i make mineral water? my husband really prefers the taste of mineral water to regular tap water. we try not to buy it too much due to how far it travels (all the way from italy, ugh)
any suggestions?
http://threadtrace.wordpress.com
view cassiopia's profile
I have the Isi cream whipper which uses N02 chargers instead of CO2. Does anyone know if the CO2 chargers are interchangeable on the cream whipper???
view kathrine's profile
I bought the soda club middle-range model after the profile and give-away done on here a few months ago. It's great, takes up about as much space as a two liter bottle on my counter top. One of the things I've heard that many people prefer about it is that you can choose the amount of fizz you add, where as that's difficult to do with the siphons, or so i've heard.
view sunnyteigh's profile
Kathrine - isi sells separate cream and soda chargers; they are not interchangeable.
Still worth it though, yes?
view peelmeagrape's profile
I'd love to go using a siphon to cut down on plastic/bottles, food miles and cost but does anyone know if its possible to recycle the co2 cartridges? From googling, I haven't found anywhere to do so in Chicago yet.
view scarab1's profile
I own the pictured isi soda siphon. I really enjoy it. We make mixes of juice and soda or add it to cocktails.
view mandarinmarie's profile
My friends have soda club and they love it. Their parents got it for them and insist on pronouncing it "kloob" because that's how they say it in spain. It drives my friends crazy.
view brittanykate's profile
Scarab1 -- The cartridges I use are steel, which is recyclable where I live.
view ottan's profile
So, which is going to be less harmful for the environment: accumulating plastic bottles , or soda cartridges?
view Kit's profile
How much do the replacement cartridges cost?
I saw a soda siphon on clearance @ William Sonoma but passed b/c I thought the cost of the cartridges would be too much..
view crasht1224's profile
Is it possible to use the old blue siphons one sees at flea markets? Their colors are so much more beautiful than any of the above....
view Cassis's profile
I have a like soda club, but I wish I had bought one of these old fashioned looking ones so I could reuse glass bottles, and just because they look a lot more stylish.
By the way, I learned this week that it takes over 200 liters of water to make one liter of sugar soda (like Pepsi or coke) when you include the sugar and making the plastic bottle and shipping. More reason to make your own!
view fancyd's profile
health effects of coke, pepsi--very bad. diet soda--extremely bad.
this water carbonation thing looks promising--maybe this sort of discussion can drive down the cost/landfill/transport impact. have to admit, i love fizzy water.
cassiopia, that wedding cake at on your threadtrace site--adorable, incredible.
view avianmission's profile