As a holiday gift this past year, we received a few pounds of pre-shaped and frozen hamburgers ordered from an online company. We've been enjoying them a lot and now that we're down to our last few, we're contemplating whether to order more. Have you ever ordered meat online?
There are a few issues that we've been considering - primarily cost, environmental issues, and convenience.
The cost is probably the biggest factor. We've been looking into ordering from Omaha Steak Company, and it seems like you can get a good bargain if you hit on one of their sales or if you can buy in large bulk. Otherwise, we calculate that we'd end up paying twice or more what we'd pay for the same meat in the grocery store.
Environmentally, there are two issues to consider - both common riffs from the local and organic food movements. One is the environmental and economic cost it takes to transport this meat over long distances (in this case, from Nebraska to Massachusetts), and the second is our desire to buy meat from farms that follow ethical practices in raising their livestock.
We might be willing to buy local even if it's not organic or buy organic even if it has to be shipped. But if it's neither, that becomes a big deterrent for us.
And finally, we come to the convenience factor. Oh, wonderful convenience! It's so nice to pull a burger out of the freezer in the morning and know that dinner will be as easy as frying it up with some cheese.
But really, we have to admit to ourselves that we're being a bit easy. It's not that hard to buy ground beef to make a few patties at home, wrap them in wax paper, and keep them in the freezer for those lazy days. If we make them ourselves, we also have greater control over the kind of beef we're using, the other ingredients going into the burger, and the size of the burgers.
Buying meat online might make more sense for specialty cuts that aren't easy to find in the store or if you're throwing a large party and want to buy in bulk. Otherwise...it seems like we've just talked ourselves out of buying meat online!
What's your perspective?
Related: Food Safety: Is it Safe to Order Hamburgers Rare?
(Image: Emma Christensen for the Kitchn)
my mother-in-law sends my husband a box of steaks and burgers from omaha steaks every year for his birthday. they are convenient, but it seems like we always have a box of burgers taking up room in the freezer. we're not big burgers cooked on the stove top people, so we have at least two years worth of burgers in the freezer. we have moved and will finally get to bbq this summer! i'm sure those burgers will come in handy then.
all of that being said, i don't think we will ever order from them. if i'm going to be filling my freezer with meat, i'd rather it be local and/or organic meat. i live in portland, or which is nowhere near omaha...
http://threadtrace.wordpress.com
view cassiopia's profile
I was surprised to find that Bill Kurtis' beef from his Montana ranch, Prairie Grass Farms, is available through Peapod.
Prairie Grass is a free-range, grass-fed cattle ranch.
view art's profile
Regardless of whether the meat is conventionally raised or grass-fed, free-range, etc., I think of meat as being somethign I'd rather inspect myself and not buy online or via mail order.
view rosebud's profile
I'm lucky enough to live in Seattle, so I get meat/fish from Amazon Fresh (amazon.com/fresh) ALL the time, and the quality is great! I like the salmon from Amazon FAR better than whats at the deli counter at Safeway.
view mcb23's profile
I order fresh oysters online. I found a supplier that sells them at a great price packs them beautifully and couriers for only $5NZ (about $3US). I'd only order meat online if it were a good price.
view buda's profile
What about using a local company like The Meat House? http://www.themeathouse.com/default.aspx
They have a base in Mass, so it wouldn't be shipped far. I've gotten their meats before, and they were super good quality.
view Muffinator's profile
Also on the environmental side, that looks like a whole lot of packaging, and I'm sure there was a lot more with the box and packing filler, etc.
I sometimes buy premade burgers from the grocery store, and they generally just come in a cardboard box or one plastic bag, sometimes with wax paper between the patties.
view Jennybeen's profile
I'm a huge fan of the NYC-based www.dicksonsfarmstand.com. They even have cute little photos on the site to help you identify the cuts of meat! Also, you know that your meat is coming from a farm within 200 miles of where you are - you even know what farm it comes from and they give details on how the animals are raised.
view rjb2003's profile
We both give and receive. We send people in our family bbq from Jack Stack in KC. They love it. We receive andouille and other Louisiana specialties from one SIL and Omaha steaks from another. I think its great when you are getting something you couldn't have otherwise. But, if it is more basic, I would get it local.
view twosavoie's profile
www.eightoclockranch.com/ is in upstate New York, has great prices, humane treatment, amazingly delicious meat. They even have a CSA program. I've been using them for a little over a year now.
view sunnyteigh's profile
I ordered a roast of wild boar once from a ranch selling through Amazon.com. I served it at a christmas party I was throwing, and it was a big hit. :)
view tomahto's profile
We buy meat online for specific reasons, primarily ethical and environmental. But it helps that tastes good. I want meat from animals that are raised humanely (not in a CAFO), on a natural diet (not stinking up the planet because of corn), and slaughtered with dignity.
Meat like this is expensive when purchased piece by piece, assuming you can find it. You can help yourself and the farmer by buying in quality. We have good luck with Eight O'Clock Ranch (already mentioned) as well as splitting an animal with friends from a local farmer. I also appreciate working my through the various cuts available. It makes for interesting cooking and I think it shows respect to eat from nose to tail, even if you don't quite make it to the tail.
view JudiAU's profile
If you are in NYC, one way to compromise is to purchase the meat on-line and pick it up at the greenmarket. Bobolink Dairy does this...
http://www.cowsoutside.com/
view izzy's mama's profile
I can't imagine buying meat online. Here in Minnesota we have some of the best meat in the country. I can get local, organic, fresh meat any day of the week. Why would I buy it online? And it is much cheaper than online.
view Kassie's profile
I try to always buy my meat at the local farmer's market. But after doing a taste test of artisan raised beef, I'm suddenly considering purchasing mail order beef.
Thanks to a thorough taste test with Oliver Ranch, I learned how they carefully select beef that's been raised responsibly, ethically, and with the utmost care for the animal and consumer in mind. They're teaching people to ask questions about the beef they're buying in order to find out what kind of meat they're eating (breed), how the cow was fed and raised, what sort of land the cows grew up on, and how the beef was processed. Though I still wonder if shipping beef via FedX is the best for the environment, I'm definitely interested in education Oliver Ranch's Artisan Beef Institute offers.
view foodwoolf's profile
I'm not against ordering meat online - it makes a nice gift for elderly family members or friends who do not get out much, or do get special products that are unique, but it is much nicer and productive to see your meat in person and to freeze it in the way you want.
view jgphotomom's profile
Tallgrass Beef is outstanding. It's served at Harry Carey's in Chicago.
http://www.tallgrassbeef.com/
And who doesn't love Bill Kurtis??
view ohjodi's profile
I don't know where you are but many localities now have meat CSAs which allow farmers to continue to raise meat in a sustainable small way. I live in the Boston area and once a month a Vermont meat farmer brings deliveries down of organically raised beef and pork. He is able to keep his family farm, I'm not buying "Big Meat" and it's delicious! On average it's slightly more expensive than the grocery store, but quality is so superior it is worth it.
view Charlotte's profile
http://www.eatwild.org
You can find local meat/poultry farmers here and eliminate the transport/shipping costs!
view chow.baby's profile
Oops!
http://www.eatwild.com
(not .org)
view chow.baby's profile
We grew up getting Omaha Steaks for Christmas every year from my uncle. Now I always give my brother Omaha steaks for his birthday (around Memorial Day). They earn high praise from his organic food obsessed wife and friends, probably due to his expert grilling skills. I myself am going home tonight to grill an Omaha steak given to me by my other steak loving brother. I'm sure there are trendier more politically correct meats out there, but I'm happy with the price/quality of what I know and don't care so much about how happy the animal was while dying.
view sfgirl's profile