apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Skeptical Shopper: Born Free Hard Boiled Peeled Eggs

2008_04_11-BornFree.jpgOur first reaction to seeing this bag of ready-to-eat, hard-boiled eggs in the grocery store was along the lines of, "That's ridiculous." In fact, that's exactly what our husband said when we put them in our basket.

Why did we buy them when we are perfectly capable of hard-boiling our own? Because to give you a full report, we needed to slice and taste a few. Could this new convenience product have a place in our kitchen?

 
 

The short answer is no.

Their merit lies in the fact that they are uniform size and have relatively well-centered yolks. If you are making a bunch of deviled eggs and don't want to run the risk of having lopsided yolks that are hard to scoop out — or ragged whites from a difficult-to-peel shell — these eggs solve that problem while saving you time.

2008_04_11-BornFree2.jpgAnd while we only saw the cage free eggs in our store, Born Free sells organic ones, too. We've also seen bags of organic, ready-to-eat eggs from a brand called Egg Innovations.

The cons: They tasted stale, the whites were rubbery, and the yolks were pretty hard. Our bag contained 11 eggs and cost $4.59, which isn't a premium we're willing to pay.

Are you? Would you buy these bagged, hard-boiled eggs?

A better option:

(All images: Elizabeth Passarella)

Tags

Dairy Products, eggs, hard-boiled, Born Free, Egg Innovations, deviled

Related Links

Share

Comments (40)

This is beyond ridiculous.

posted by Eve in Hochelaga on April 11th 2008 at 4:52am
view Eve in Hochelaga's profile

Ick.

posted by Joan A. on April 11th 2008 at 5:08am
view Joan A.'s profile

icky, too. doesn't seem safe or appetizing.

posted by kdkaboom on April 11th 2008 at 5:09am
view kdkaboom's profile

I literally thought this was a late April Fool's joke.

posted by Squirrely on April 11th 2008 at 5:09am
view Squirrely's profile

Absolutely not. Under no circumstances. Not even as a joke. Not even as a PRANK. Elizabeth, you took a bullet for us all by testing this product.

posted by Nora Rocket on April 11th 2008 at 5:20am
view Nora Rocket's profile

Did anyone else think it was odd that the bag says: "Contains 9-10 eggs?" It's not that these are difficult to count (like, say, crackers)...very weird overall. Ick is right!

posted by Aaron on April 11th 2008 at 5:22am
view Aaron's profile

I think the idea of this is gross..let alone how I imagine they would taste

posted by designerny on April 11th 2008 at 5:36am
view designerny's profile

Hell no. If my food needs processing I will do it myself, thank you. Eggs already have their own biodegradable packaging, why replace it with plastic?

I wish I could use stronger words to describe how back-ass-wards I find this product.

posted by samaritan on April 11th 2008 at 5:41am
view samaritan's profile

The other day I was boiling eggs and I thought to myself "this is so hard, I wish someone could simplify the process".

The only thing that would make these better is hearing they are shelf stable.

posted by SleepyDweller on April 11th 2008 at 5:45am
view SleepyDweller's profile

I got a stomach ache as soon as I saw the picture of bagged hard boiled eggs. This is essentially a horrible food poisening family picnic incident waiting to happen. Just say no.

posted by Likey on April 11th 2008 at 5:59am
view Likey's profile

Bleck

posted by viola on April 11th 2008 at 6:31am
view viola's profile

here in Switzerland they sell hard boiled eggs (in their shells) in the egg aisle -- which isn't refrigerated by the way. At first, I thought like you -- how ridiculous-I can boil my own! But then I became a convert...

First off, the eggs are PERFECTLY boiled, with that orangey slightly soft centre -- not overboiled. I find it hard to get eggs that perfect: there are so many variables, such as the size, temperature and age of the egg...

And it is pretty convenient to have them in the fridge -- just throw a couple in a salad, or make sandwiches with them. And since they are coloured like Easter eggs here, my 4 year old likes to eat them as snacks.

posted by mschatelaine on April 11th 2008 at 6:33am
view mschatelaine's profile

forgot to mention that the eggs here are super, super fresh, definitely no rubbery whites!

posted by mschatelaine on April 11th 2008 at 6:34am
view mschatelaine's profile

Talk about "off gassing".

I'll bet that bag lets off a stench when it's opened.

posted by art on April 11th 2008 at 6:42am
view art's profile

What hurts the most, is the packaging. At least with raw eggs I can put the paper carton into the recycling.

posted by scaram0uche on April 11th 2008 at 7:06am
view scaram0uche's profile

In China, you can find individually-packaged hard-boiled eggs sold at convenience stores as quick snacks. And duck feet too, but that's another matter completely.....

posted by Michelle of Montreal on April 11th 2008 at 7:15am
view Michelle of Montreal's profile

That's moronic. Besides, paper egg cartons are recyleable and can be used in arts and crafts!

posted by Melissa A. on April 11th 2008 at 7:15am
view Melissa A.'s profile

I get these all the time.. and I love them - they taste awesome and there isn't anything wrong with them.

Why I like them:
They are easy and instant..
No messy cleanup because you dont need to shell anything
My small apt doesnt smell like eggs for a week because I dont have to boil them
Did I mention they come in a re-sealable bag?

-These are great for someone that needs to whip up a dish for a meetup on the quick or for someone in a small apt like me. I want hard boiled eggs.. not a rank egg smelling apt

posted by ire on April 11th 2008 at 7:42am
view ire's profile

Ew. No no no no no.

posted by Kathryn Hill on April 11th 2008 at 7:49am
view Kathryn Hill's profile

I cringed when I saw boiled eggs prepackaged at my Harris Teeter. There is something repulsive about it.

posted by Kate (NC) on April 11th 2008 at 8:51am
view Kate (NC)'s profile

Elizabeth, this is such a funny coincidence! A couple of days ago my husband accompanied me to the grocery store for the first time in maybe a year. He spotted these eggs in the dairy case & was immediately repulsed by the idea. Understand that I am not a fan of eggs - the flavor just doesn't appeal to me - but my husband loves them. I was surprised that he reacted so strongly. I thought it might be a nice shortcut & thought about buying some to make scotch eggs as a surprise for him. But now I guess not!

Monika, are the eggs sold in Switzerland boiled at a facility like these seem to be or do you think they're boiled at the store where they're sold? That could make a big difference.

posted by Nougat on April 11th 2008 at 8:59am
view Nougat's profile

They're awful. My S/O bought them for me as a surprise, because I love boiled eggs ... but as Elizabeth noted, they tasted rubbery, smelled awful ... and all that useless packaging.

posted by madampince on April 11th 2008 at 9:00am
view madampince's profile

next they're going to sell ready made poo that you just have to throw in the toilet.

posted by Sol on April 11th 2008 at 10:33am
view Sol's profile

Nougat -- they're definitely not boiled on-site -- most grocery stores here (except for the HUGE grocery stores that sell EVERYTHING including furniture, bedding, shoes, clothes, etc., called hyper-marchés or, in France, grand-surfaces) are TINY. Everything is incredibly fresh, and goes off very, very, fast. People shop here every day or two for the most part. So even though the eggs are not cooked in the store, they are probably cooked fairly quickly after being taken from the hen, and shipped immediately.

Food in Europe is for the most part, of a much higher quality than what we are used to in North America. They take it very, very seriously (especially in France, where we buy most of our groceries) and have much more extensive regulations than we do. For example, battery hens are almost a thing of the past here -- eggs here seem to be either free range or organic free-range. And not being refrigerated, eggs are VERY fresh. Some grocery stores, you can buy quail eggs or in Holland, eggs from specific chickens -- Aracuana or Black Cochin, and others whose name I forget.

Really folks, the Swiss version of this is pretty amazing, and as Martha would say, they are a Good Thing. (they are packaged in just regular egg cartons -- the only difference is that they are coloured).

posted by mschatelaine on April 11th 2008 at 11:04am
view mschatelaine's profile

I think I would find these less disgusting if in fact they were in their shell as the found in Switzerland (from the post above). Peeled and put in a plastic bag is just foul. In fact, having to use plastic at all makes this a thumbs down product.

posted by designerny on April 11th 2008 at 11:15am
view designerny's profile

I'm with designery.

posted by Barbara S on April 11th 2008 at 11:48am
view Barbara S's profile

These have been in use in restaurants for at least a decade - pretty much any place that serves salads with eggs uses them (incl. egg salad) - and they come in a HUGE five gallon bucket.

They float. :)

posted by anaximander on April 11th 2008 at 12:11pm
view anaximander's profile

I find some of these comments strange. I don't find making hard boiled eggs time consuming, messy, or smelly. It's funny how people view these experiences differently I guess.

posted by Melissa A. on April 11th 2008 at 1:29pm
view Melissa A.'s profile

yuk yuk yuk. That's all I have to say.

posted by umeboshi on April 11th 2008 at 6:59pm
view umeboshi's profile

I LOVE hard-boiled eggs and I have to say that I buy them BY THE BAG at Trader Joe's. They're fresh and delicious. And yes, it did catch me off guard when I first saw this in the store. But I tried them and now they're in my fridge.

posted by millzee on April 11th 2008 at 7:27pm
view millzee's profile

I understand that AT is a "we" but this post says "our husband" which confuses me even more than those peeled eggs.

Sorry to correct your grammar here, but it significantly changes the meaning of your thought!

posted by raven on April 12th 2008 at 6:21am
view raven's profile

sorry to correct yoy raven, but Elizabeth married a polygamist. She goes to the grocery store with the other 15 wives. Her grammar is impeccable.

posted by Sol on April 12th 2008 at 7:13am
view Sol's profile

ah ha! I thought so.

posted by raven on April 12th 2008 at 8:46am
view raven's profile

I might try it once because i sometimes just want one egg and i refuse to boil less then a dozen at a time to save time later. But i love a deviled egg but hubby hates hard boiled eggs unless very hot super fresh.


http://organicandnaturalmom.blogspot.com/

posted by luv2cook on April 12th 2008 at 3:18pm
view luv2cook's profile

"They tried to make me eat some prefab, but I said no, no, no...."!

posted by KarenH on April 12th 2008 at 8:40pm
view KarenH's profile

Ah, now I see when I brought these as a house warming gift why I wasn't invited back.

posted by peacelily on April 13th 2008 at 9:08am
view peacelily's profile

I am not as disgusted by this as others, but would never buy it. I like my hard boiled eggs fresh and still hot from boiling. Am not a fan of deviled eggs at all -- probably the only egg preparation I don't love -- but I can see this would make that process easier.

posted by Susmita on April 14th 2008 at 7:26am
view Susmita's profile

Someone already beat me to the punch on the "our husband" bit, I see. It's one of those times when writing in the first person plural backfires... badly!

posted by alicia on April 14th 2008 at 4:43pm
view alicia's profile

Why should you buy something like this ? It takes only 5 minutes to prepare your own. And I can't believe that are good after staying on the grocery some days.

________
az spas

posted by EddieSmith on October 29th 2008 at 3:12am
view EddieSmith's profile

Being a foodie, the thought of it totally grosses me out BUT -

I have a friend who is an athlete - with a physical disability. Since it is challanging for him to prepare his own food, these eggs, as well as precut fruits and veggies are a part of his regular diet.

posted by VeryDelishVeg on January 1st 2009 at 3:46pm
view VeryDelishVeg's profile