apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Survey: Sponge or Dishcloth?

2007_05_25-Sponge.jpg

Now for the big Cleaning Month question: Sponge or dishcloth?

Some people think sponges are gross; others think dishcloths are useless. How do you do your dishes, and why? How did your family wash dishes, and have you kept to it? Which camp do you fall in - or do you use something completely different? Enlighten us!

 
 

Tags

Cleaning, Surveys

Related Links

Share

Comments (30)

We always used a sponge as I was growing up, so that's what I use now but I've been thinking about switching to something else because the sponges get so icky. I really don't mind doing dishes to be honest, so I can't wait to see what other methods people say they use so I can get some ideas!

posted by bluestar on May 25th 2007 at 5:45am
view bluestar's profile

My mother always used a Dobie pad--a sponge inside a plastic mesh. The sponge holds the water and the soap, and the plastic mesh scrubs without scratching. They last a few months before they get too gross or torn. My local grocery store has stopped carrying them recently, though, so I tried a few other unsatisfactory things (including one that's a sponge with plastic mesh on only one side). Now I see they're introducing their own brand of the Dobie pad. I just bought one last night, so I'll see how it goes. I may have to stock up on the real thing when I go to other stores.

posted by Joan A. on May 25th 2007 at 5:57am
view Joan A.'s profile

I prefer the sponge mostly because sterilizing is quicker: 1 min in the microwave for the sponge, vs. a wash-and-dry cycle for the dishcloth. There's also the satisfaction of actually picking up all the spilled liquid with a sponge, instead of feeling like I'm just spreading it around with a dishcloth.

posted by nadarine on May 25th 2007 at 6:04am
view nadarine's profile

I do dishes with sponges, but I use dishclothes all the time-- to dry clean things (my hands, dishes, just-washed fruits) and to wipe up spills mostly.

posted by vera in dc on May 25th 2007 at 6:12am
view vera in dc's profile

i use a sponge - but would rather have a dishwasher! (ha! wouldn't everyone!!) but seriously, i don't like the sponge because it seems to get gross very often and once the green stuff on it is gone, you have to throw it away. i've used the thing that joan was talking about at another person's house and liked it, but it really just all seems wasteful because we have to throw them away. i just can't seem to get past that. i try my hardest to make a sponge last a month, but the bf is one of those skinny 6'4 145lb (yeah ways the same as i do!!!!!) garbage disposal so i spend at least an hour washing dishes everyday. oy.

posted by elizabeth in AL on May 25th 2007 at 6:14am
view elizabeth in AL's profile

I use a sponge to do dishes. At the end of the process I just make sure that they are completely rinsed and let them dry. There is no mess. I change them quite often thou, if it gets cut or starts to look ugly - out it goes. The counters I clean with solution and paper towels, although I feel it is a waste. I don't know why, but NEVER grew fond of dishcloths.

posted by Anusha73 on May 25th 2007 at 6:17am
view Anusha73's profile

I'm a sponge gal all the way. I like the sponges with a scrubby side for getting tough food off my pots and pans. I always make sure it's rinsed and allowed to dry, and is replaced every month.

posted by Cindy on May 25th 2007 at 6:17am
view Cindy's profile

I use a sponge, but grew up using dishcloths. I like the scrubby side of the sponge better than using a separate green scrubby, like my mom did. I have become very picky about sponge choice, though--I like the ones with concave sides, not too large. They have fairly cute patterns (stripes, polka dots) on them, but I don't know the brand. They last a lot longer than the regular rectangular ones.

The "how I grew up doing dishes" thing for me is using a dishpan. My husband had never used soapy water to do dishes; his family put soap on the sponge and washed under running water. He was amazed by how much better the double-sink system works!

posted by katef on May 25th 2007 at 6:29am
view katef's profile

Apparently dishcloths should be washed every day, because of the bacteria that hides in them--who knew? I just don't pay enough attention to them for that. I did grow up using them for wiping down counters, but I know they weren't changed every day, though my mother was the cleanest person I knew. Now I, too, use paper towels and spray, even though it is a waste. I do use the really small paper towels.

posted by Joan A. on May 25th 2007 at 6:50am
view Joan A.'s profile

Also, about the Dobie pads and their knockoffs--there's a version that has a different kind of plastic mesh, kind of fuzzy or hairy looking, which comes in much better colors than the original kind, but I've found that food, etc. gets stuck in them very quickly, and doesn't rinse out. Quite disgusting.

posted by Joan A. on May 25th 2007 at 6:52am
view Joan A.'s profile

I use a sponge for washing dishes, but a dish towel for everything else. No paper towels/napkins in my kitchen.

posted by mollyjade on May 25th 2007 at 7:20am
view mollyjade's profile

I use sponges for all my handwash and then they go on the top shelf in the dishwasher when I'm done and get washed with the dishes. They don't get icky, I usually get rid of them when they start wearing out. I use scotch brite pad types, so the yellow and green are for non-kitchen use and the blue ones are for countertops, dishes, microwave cleaning type use.

posted by Zaya on May 25th 2007 at 7:47am
view Zaya's profile

I toss my sponges in the laundry a couple of times a week, to de-germify them. And replace them with new ones every couple of months, just like my toofbrush.

posted by holland on May 25th 2007 at 7:52am
view holland's profile

I grew up using and still use a dish brush. I just can't stand the smell the sponge leaves on everything, including my hands.

posted by jubgulia on May 25th 2007 at 8:10am
view jubgulia's profile

I use dish cloths and change them at least once a day, but usually more often. They go in the wash with everything else and it is no trouble. I grew up using sponges, but they seem repellent to me now; they always smell and even after a tour through the dishwasher or microwave they are bacterial sinks.

posted by dot on May 25th 2007 at 8:35am
view dot's profile

I also use sponges for dishes now, but grew up using a dishcloth. We always filled up the sink with hot soapy water to do dishes and then hung the wet dishrag over the faucet to dry when we were done.
Don't really know when or why I started buying sponges, but maybe because I feel that the dishrags are too big and slop water all over when washing...

posted by kkf on May 25th 2007 at 9:02am
view kkf's profile

Microfiber dishcloth- we bought a big pack at Cost-co, so they're changes out 1x day. The microfiber is also very absorbent for spills.

posted by Tacoma on May 25th 2007 at 9:39am
view Tacoma's profile

Can't you also microwave sponges to sterilize them?

posted by laura in la on May 25th 2007 at 7:07pm
view laura in la's profile

Dishcloths. Love them. I like that I can take out a new one every time I do the dishes, so it always seems much cleaner than using a much-used sponge.

And having a big supply of clean dishcloths around is extremely useful...they come in handy for a variety of different jobs.

posted by moema on May 26th 2007 at 4:46am
view moema's profile

Eew and eew-er. Dish brushes all the way.

posted by Kristen (gezellig-girl.com) on May 26th 2007 at 10:31am
view Kristen (gezellig-girl.com)'s profile

Wow! I can't believe the number of sponge users. Most of my friends and family use dishcloths. In my family, we used washable cloth everything. Cloth diapers, cloth napkins etc. My mom was pretty frugal, she figured it was cheaper to buy something once and wash it than to buy something over and over.
My favorite dishcloths are made from 100% wood fibers. They don't smell, and wash up so soft. They are sold under a variety of name brands, I buy mine at the dollar store.

posted by K8 in Maine on May 26th 2007 at 12:42pm
view K8 in Maine's profile

Dish brush, and hot, soapy water for dishes. Hot enough that it isn't comfortable to stick your hands in without gloves.

A dish cloth for counters and tables, wrung out periodically in hot soapy water. We have a lot of dish cloths, I've never had to do laundry because we're out of dish cloths.

Unless something dramatic has changed about microwaves in the last ten years while I wasn't looking, you can't sterilize anything in them. I'd love to know differently, though.

posted by amanda bee on May 27th 2007 at 7:36am
view amanda bee's profile

i use a scrubbie thing (bristles, rubber grip, soap reservoir) that a bleach/replace regularly. i used to use washcloths, but they gross me out.

posted by josué on May 27th 2007 at 1:36pm
view josué's profile

My major discovery in the past year or so is that sponges start smelling ick much more quickly when I used cheap store-brand dishwashing soap. Nicer stuff (e.g., Trader Joe's brand) keeps the sponge from getting so gross so quickly.

posted by Katie in Berkeley on May 27th 2007 at 2:03pm
view Katie in Berkeley's profile

Dishes get the sponge and countertops and spills get the washable dishcloth. Just vigilant about rinsing and letting the sponge dry in its holder after use. One scrubbie brush is just for the dog's dish.

posted by kdb on May 28th 2007 at 10:45am
view kdb's profile

Scrub sponge on a stick is how I roll.

posted by PriscillaAmber on May 29th 2007 at 12:54pm
view PriscillaAmber's profile

anyone try chef towels? great for the absorbtion and reuse.use on countertops and appliances...love the OXO Soap filled dish brush for dishes.

http://www.utilitieshome.com/store.php?crn=99&rn=627&action=show_detail

posted by den on May 30th 2007 at 5:52pm
view den's profile

Currently I use sponges, although my preference is for dishcloths. Not having a washing machine at home, I have a hard time letting the dishcloths sit in a pile for a week or two before getting to the laundromat. When I have a washing machine again it is dishcloths all the way. I will also be able to stop using paper towels for cleaning when I have a washing machine again for the same reasons! I have lots of rags, they work really well, but hate letting them sit around till I get to the laundromat.

posted by Hannah Ruth on June 19th 2008 at 6:04pm
view Hannah Ruth's profile

I use a dish brush that can be easily disinfected. Sponges and cloths are too germy- especially sponges!

posted by baltimoregal on September 4th 2008 at 8:51am
view baltimoregal's profile

Thanks for your useful info, I think it’s a good topic. So would you like the info about the Air jordan shoes
Tiffany Jewelry
ugg Gypsy
wholesale electronics
Cardy ugg boots
Michael jordan shoes
Classic tall ugg boots
UGG Slippers
Classic short ugg boots

posted by xinxi on May 31st 2009 at 1:12am
view xinxi's profile