apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Survey: How Do You Puree Soups?

2009_02_17-Puree.jpgMany of our favorite soups are pureed -- blended into smooth, silky creaminess with a blender or food processor. We have to admit that pureeing soups is one of our least favorite parts of soup-making, however, since it involves transferring hot soup to a blender and leaning hard on the lid, hoping hot soup doesn't explode over the kitchen. We are seriously thinking about an immersion blender, but first we wanted to see what you think. How do you like to puree soups and other things? Food processor, immersion blender, or stand blender?

 
 

Pictured above, left to right:

Food processor: This is the Cuisinart 3-Cup Food Processor. A food processor is a great multi-tasker; it can shred, chop, and blend as well as puree. But it's a pain to put hot soup in a plastic food processor.

Immersion (stick) blender: This kind of blender (shown: Cuisinart SmartStick) is very convenient, since you stick straight into a pot of soup or soft potatoes and puree away. But we wonder if it's a one-trick pony; would we really use it enough to justify a purchase?

Stand blender: (Shown: the pricey, all-powerful VitaMix) A blender is like a food processor: endless uses. But it's a real pain to transfer soup; we have to cover our blender lid with a towel to keep hot soup from leaking out.

What's the verdict? How do you get smooth soups and sauces?

Related: 'Tis the Season for a Food Processor

Tags

Appliances - small, soup, blender, puree

Share

Comments (42)

I logged in but I can't answer the survey (even after re-loading).

Anyway, I use a food mill.

posted by Charlotte on February 17th 2009 at 4:56pm
view Charlotte's profile

Does anyone have a good recommendation for an immersion blender?

posted by EasilyAmused on February 17th 2009 at 5:04pm
view EasilyAmused's profile

The Cuisinart immersion blender pictured is available for pretty cheap at Amazon and, really, it's worth it for soup alone. Not having to get burned making the before pot to blender to after pot transfer, not making a mess putting too much into the blender and having it erupt, not fouling counters, stovetops, and potholders... I gladly paid under $30 for such joys. And then I get to use for everything from gravies to hot cocoa and frosty drinks.

posted by aaedible on February 17th 2009 at 5:13pm
view aaedible's profile

I don't a recommendation for a specific immersion blender, but I can recommend that buy one like the cuisinart pictured that is metal down where the blade is. Mine is plastic and it melted in the soup. I don't know what possessed them to make that part plastic.

posted by erinn on February 17th 2009 at 5:17pm
view erinn's profile

I use a basic kitchenaid immersion blender and I wouldn't go with anything else. It's ridiculously easy to clean and since I got it, I hardly ever pull out the big blender. If I want to make one or two smoothies, I use a wide glass and I can put it right in and blend, then clean up in no time. If I want to do soup I don't have to wait for it to cool a bit, stick it in the blender, dump it back out, and then clean the jar, blade, etc. It's also great for doing cooked salsa. My cheap immersion blender gives a much better texture to the salsa than any sub-$100 blenders that my friends have.

I know I said it twice, but cleanup is so much better. Just stick it in a cup of soapy water, blend, and then rinse. Perfectly clean.

posted by louiedog on February 17th 2009 at 5:18pm
view louiedog's profile

I like things chunky, but I'm also kind of terrified of using a blender to puree soup. I've used the food processor with gazpacho, but I am the world's biggest klutz and seem to injure myself cooking a couple of times a week. So the idea of pouring hot soup into something which might not hold it seems like a very very bad idea.

The discount on that immersion blender is really, really tempting, though... I am fighting off the impulse buy.

posted by Tangledgray on February 17th 2009 at 5:19pm
view Tangledgray's profile

I care about my immersion blender so much, I finally registered (after reading AT for more than a year.) just so I could comment on it! I use mine all the time. I have a Kitchen Aid immersion blender and it makes soup making so much easier. No transferring of hot liquids. I use it all summer for smoothies, too. It's really easy to clean, does not take up a lot of space. . .what's not to love?

posted by albgal on February 17th 2009 at 5:19pm
view albgal's profile

I've never made my own pureed soup before, but I don't believe the immersion blender is a one-trick pony! While I was in university it was the only blending device I owned, and I used it for everything. Smoothies, dips (especially hummus!) breadcrumbs...I prefer it to my stand blender since its easier to clean and requires no transfer of whatever I am blending from the bowl it's already in.

posted by minji on February 17th 2009 at 5:19pm
view minji's profile

I thought the immersion blender was a waste of space until we had a baby. Genius. I was totally converted. It works for almost everything although for a perfectly smooth and fiber-free puree you need to go with a food mill.

Plus easy to clean.

posted by JudiAU on February 17th 2009 at 5:24pm
view JudiAU's profile

I hope to buy an immersion blender soon, because just last week I burned myself trying to blend the tomato soup slink'd here on TheKitchn. The lid popped off spraying me and my kitchen. My "stand" blender died, but my Bullet blender did the trick, once the soup cooled.

posted by srivanis on February 17th 2009 at 5:26pm
view srivanis's profile

I never used my immersion blender until this winter when I really started to make soups from scratch. Love it -- SO easy to use. I have the Cuisinart one.

It's such a hassle to pour the soup into another receptacle and then pour back -- especially if you have to do it in batches.

posted by stlellen on February 17th 2009 at 5:31pm
view stlellen's profile

I have an ancient Braun immersion blender. I'm not even sure how old it is - my dad gave it to me when I first had an apartment during college (1997), but it wasn't new then. He didn't use it much, though (which is why he gave it to me).

Anyway, it came with a little "mini-processor" bowl, and between that and the blender itself, it's WAY more than a one-trick pony. Breadcrumbs, finely chopped onions/carrots/celery, chopped nuts - all are much easier in the "mini-processor". And (before I had a mixer), I even used the immersion blender for making banana bread dough.

Plus, I use it for everything that should mix, but doesn't want to (gravy, hot cocoa, puddings). It's really a lifesaver!

posted by marisab on February 17th 2009 at 5:38pm
view marisab's profile

Another vote for the Braun immersion blender. Mine 's a >10 year old model, bought gently used for $5! Sweet.

posted by mikeinkansascity on February 17th 2009 at 6:04pm
view mikeinkansascity's profile

I've tested out both the immersion blender and my stand blender for a soup exchange. I was much happier with the results of the stand blender surprisingly. I was making an asparagus leek soup and I felt that the stand blender did a better job of really liquefying the leeks. I'll be sticking with my Breville stand mixer in the future.

posted by Brooklynne on February 17th 2009 at 6:08pm
view Brooklynne's profile

I have a Braun immersion blender, which I use if I'm feeling lazy, but it doesn't make the soup as silky-smooth as the stand blender. I just do my soup in small batches (blender a little under half-full) and I don't have blender-exploding-mishaps (but I had to learn the hard way :).

If you do get the immersion blender, it's useful to get the mini-food processor and whipping top attachments, so that you can use it for more things.

posted by angorian on February 17th 2009 at 6:09pm
view angorian's profile

Thanks, everyone! I think I'll probably go with the KitchenAid. I just hope I don't end up scratching my Le Creuset. Perish the thought!

posted by EasilyAmused on February 17th 2009 at 6:12pm
view EasilyAmused's profile

I use Magic Bullet to puree anything but NOT SOUP, I like my soups "chunky" (well, my soups are mostly chicken noodle or bortsch)

posted by Nudik on February 17th 2009 at 6:19pm
view Nudik's profile

I've seen quite a few accidents with hot liquids in blenders in the restaurant kitchen where I used to work, so I'd go for an immersion blender on that alone! I have the KitchenAid immersion blender, and I love it. My favorite things about it are the variable speed control, and I can remove the blending shaft from the motor for easy cleaning (you can even toss it in the dishwasher - although a quick rinse at the sink usually does the trick).

I haven't used it for soups, but I have used it on several occasions for making fresh fruit sauces right on the stove top, drinks or smoothies, and I plan to use it to make baby food.

posted by Lucky Bug on February 17th 2009 at 6:25pm
view Lucky Bug's profile

Immersion blender all the way.

The footprint is so small (we keep ours in a corner of a cupboard right by the door), and it's tons safer than transferring hot (chunky) liquids to a foodpro or blender.

We just replaced our plastic Krups with a nice, metal Kitchenaid and have been very pleased.

They also work well for emulsifying salad dressings and making (the obvious) smoothie.

And, as a bonus, you can make David Lebovitz's easiest chocolate ice cream (wow, amazing).

posted by Trey Jackson on February 17th 2009 at 6:25pm
view Trey Jackson's profile

I use a food mill. It's a bit fussy, but certainly much safer and easier than a blender or food processor. That said, the comments make a persuasive case for an immersion blender.

posted by Pamela G on February 17th 2009 at 6:34pm
view Pamela G's profile

Glad you came out of the shadows, albgal! Welcome :)

posted by melanie on February 17th 2009 at 6:36pm
view melanie's profile

I also highly recommend the immersion blender; that thing purees soup in a snap! Didn't think to use it for hot cocoa; will have to try it!

posted by madichan on February 17th 2009 at 6:53pm
view madichan's profile

I use a Bamix hand blender and it's one of the best kitchen investments I've made. It's commercial-quality (I think) - seems more so than the Cuisinart. The thing does a LOT. Crushes ice for drinks and smoothies, whips cream - everything the blender did and then some. The only thing I'd need a blender for is large batches of crushed ice. Oh, and the immersion blender is MUCH easier to clean - just "blend" a cup of hot soapy water and you're done.

posted by Tracey at The Thoughtful Table on February 17th 2009 at 8:23pm
view Tracey at The Thoughtful Table's profile

I'm in the market for a new stick blender - I haven't had one in a while and have been putting hot soup in the blender regularly lately. Kitchenaid people, which of these:
http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=nb_ss_gw_0_25?url=search-alias%3Daps&field-keywords=immersion blender kitchenaid&x=0&y=0&sprefix=immersion blender kitchen

posted by Pixie on February 17th 2009 at 8:28pm
view Pixie's profile

Whoops, use this link instead:
http://tinyurl.com/adzzmr

posted by Pixie on February 17th 2009 at 8:31pm
view Pixie's profile

Love my immersion blender, a plugin Kitchen Aid that has been wonderful. I can justify it because I puree soup at least once a week, but as many others have said, it is also perfect for smoothies, gravy, and cleanup couldn't be faster. I've saved myself so many burns and so many kitchen splatters.....

posted by lotusmoss on February 17th 2009 at 9:27pm
view lotusmoss's profile

as of now, I use my knife skills to finely chop everything and a spoon/spatula to mash it once it's cooked... but I've been lusting after a good food mill. no electricity needed!

posted by foodefafa on February 17th 2009 at 9:44pm
view foodefafa's profile

I have one of those ancient Brauns, and like any ancient appliance it takes 20-30 seconds to "rev-up" as the bearings re-lube.

I am lusting after the kitchen aid KHB300 with attachments. As for electricity vs. sweat, I will take electricity. Yes, I am not pure, but compared to all the other appliances, this will be used less than a blow dryer, and hopefully save on 2nd degree burns. 65% of my electrons come from lower-guilt hydropower in my city.

posted by JD523 on February 17th 2009 at 10:12pm
view JD523's profile

And yet another for the Braun immersion blender, especially if you don't need to make a lot of food at once. It has a small bowl food processor included which allows you to do double-duty with it. You can also get a blender and ice crusher attachment. It takes the place of a lot of infrequently used appliances.

posted by Orchid64 on February 17th 2009 at 10:57pm
view Orchid64's profile

I've had my trusty Braun for 13 years now but have been checking out the Bamix as a future purchase if the Braun ever dies on me.

posted by catlike on February 17th 2009 at 11:17pm
view catlike's profile

BTW, my food processor (Kitchen Aid) has a low freeboard on the main bowl (under the blade, like about a 1.25-inch of submersion.) Sure, it will work, but a blender or immersion blender will do better, unless you like cleaning the top, cup insert, blade, the bottom, and maybe the motor unit if you over-fill it.

Another two cents.

posted by JD523 on February 18th 2009 at 12:12am
view JD523's profile

Funny this post came up today. Just last night I was making potato leek soup, and thought hey, lets puree it in batches in the magic bullet (I'm cooking for one). Intelligently, I forgot that steam expands, and proceeded to ladle hot soup into said bullet. KABOOM! Scalded forearms and potatoey walls ensued. Not smart.
I reckon its time for an immersion blender...

posted by thehalfie on February 18th 2009 at 12:17am
view thehalfie's profile

Between making soups and smoothies, I use my cheap little Braun immersion blender almost every day. After the stove and espresso maker, it's probably my most-used appliance. I can't even fathom how I'd go about pureeing a huge pot of soup in a blender. If I owned a blender, that is.

posted by TammyE on February 18th 2009 at 2:36am
view TammyE's profile

I have a braun immersion blender, with the whip attachment and the mini chopper - I got it for $25 but now the only way to get one with the attachments is to buy the $100 one. It's the only gadget I use consistently.

posted by NYKate on February 18th 2009 at 8:58am
view NYKate's profile

I had an immersion blender but it broke, and it just didn't do as good of a job as the stand one. I open the pour lid every few seconds to let out steam so I don't have to worry about exploding soup.

posted by kitchengraffiti on February 18th 2009 at 9:58am
view kitchengraffiti's profile

I actually have two immersion blenders. One is a cheapy toastmaster one that has been going strong for 5 years (don't think I spent more than 10 bucks on it). I recently got a cuisinart one with the whisk and chopper attachments. I love them both and they get a lot of use.

posted by jkpenny on February 18th 2009 at 11:09am
view jkpenny's profile

Get a good stainless steel immersion blender that comes apart so you can clean it. I use mine constantly. No need to haul out the big heavy food processor or the blender that can't usually hold all the soup--just more things to wash. Plus, the soup stays hot in its own pot so you don't have to warm it back up.

posted by Rivercat0338 on February 18th 2009 at 1:00pm
view Rivercat0338's profile

If you use a food processor it will all leak out when you try and take it off the stand. ick! I like my trusty little hand blender.

posted by jennywenny on February 18th 2009 at 2:57pm
view jennywenny's profile

I have a braun immersion blender that I think my parents got so I could make smoothies for myself after school in junior high-- I'm in college now and I still use it at least once a week. If I had the counter space I might consider a regular blender, but my stick blender is just so easy to clean and store. I remember it came with a special wide cup to blend in, but that's been missing for a long time and I just use my five cup french press beaker instead for smoothies and blended drinks. Otherwise the blender goes straight into hot soup pots, skillets of tomato sauce, and mixing bowls. My favorite thing- crumble some feta cheese into a bowl, add a jar of roasted red peppers and some oregano and go at it with the stick blender. It's good as a dip, on sandwiches or even tossed with hot pasta.

posted by shlowzi on February 18th 2009 at 3:36pm
view shlowzi's profile

Another vote for an immersion blender (mine is also a Braun with the nifty attachments).

posted by als1 on February 18th 2009 at 3:58pm
view als1's profile

I borrowed an immersion blender once when I was doing a soup swap and had a large quantity to blend. I was pretty unhappy with the job it did and ended up doing batches in my stand blender anyway. It just didn't incorporate everything into a nice smooth, thick soup the way I wanted. Maybe it was the quantity? Although it's a hassle, I begrudgingly vote for the stand mixer.

posted by mizrobot on February 18th 2009 at 8:24pm
view mizrobot's profile

One episode of cream of asparagus soup all over my kitchen walls led me to our immersion blender - it's an old tan Braun with no attachments (except a bowl which I don't use) and a wall holder (storage problem solved) which I've now had for 25 years - same as my marriage! I have talked strangers into buying them at garage sales, I think they're so great. I use mine for soup, primarily, but also for refried beans - it makes a great consistency. I never thought about some of these other uses - great ideas. Ice, really?

posted by KnittingGene on February 19th 2009 at 12:19am
view KnittingGene's profile