"Contains Sulfites." These are words you see on almost every bottle of wine. Just two little words — yet so frequently misunderstood!
What are sulfites? Are they really bad? Do they cause wine headaches or other related ills?
The Facts About Sulfites in Wine
First off — let's talk about what sulfites are, and what they aren't.
What Are Sulfites?
The term ‘sulfites’ is an inclusive term for sulfur dioxide (SO2). SO2 is a preservative and widely used in winemaking (and most food industries), because of its antioxidant and antibacterial properties. SO2 plays a very important role in preventing oxidization and maintaining a wine’s freshness.
Are Sulfites Harmful?
Consumption of sulfites is generally harmless, unless you suffer from severe asthma or do not have the particular enzymes necessary to break down sulfites in your body. There are people who have a genuine allergy to sulfites, and these allergies are often linked with asthma. The FDA estimates that less than 1% of the U.S. population is sulfite-sensitive, so it is relatively rare.
If you do have a sulfite allergy (which can develop over the course of your life) it is more likely to reveal itself through a food other than wine, given that many foods have higher levels of sulfites than wine.
How Much Sulfites Are in Wine?
The amount of sulfites that a wine can contain is highly regulated around the world. Any wine containing more than 10 parts per million (ppm) of sulfur dioxide must affix to the label ‘contains sulfites’.
4 Myths About Sulfites in Wine
Here are four myths that I have found are commonly believed about sulfites and wine.
Myth #1: Sulfites in wine cause headaches.
Medical research is not definitive on the relationship between sulfites and headaches. There are many other compounds in wine such as histamines and tannins that are more likely connected to the headache effect (not to mention alcohol!).
Myth #2: Red wine has extra sulfites, thus causes headaches.
In the EU the maximum levels of sulfur dioxide that a wine can contain are 210 ppm for white wine, 400 ppm for sweet wines — and 160 ppm for red wine.
The fact that red wines typically contain less sulfites may seem surprising to people who blame sulfites for their red wine headaches! Quite similar levels apply in the U.S., Australia and around the world.
Why do red wines have less sulfites? They contain tannin, which is a stabilizing agent, and also almost all red wines go through malolactic fermentation. Therefore, less sulfur dioxide is needed to protect the wine during winemaking and maturation.
Myth #3: Wine should be avoided because it contains sulfites.
Another surprising fact is that wine contains about ten times less sulfites than most dried fruits, which can have levels up to 1000 ppm. So if you regularly eat dried fruit and do not have any adverse reaction you are probably not allergic to sulfites.
While the figures I have stated are maximum SO2 levels, discussions with many winemakers over the years would lead me to believe that in practice, sulfite levels are generally well below the maximum permitted limits.
Myth #4: Sulfites are inherently unnatural.
Apart from the potential allergic reaction, many people are against sulfites, because they feel they are an unnatural addition when making wine. While that view is valid, it is important to remember that sulfites are also a natural by-product of the yeast metabolism during fermentation. So even if you do not add any additional SO2, your wine will still contain sulfites.
A better understanding of how sulfur dioxide breaks down and binds during winemaking, better winery hygiene, and more careful viticultural practices to ensure healthy grapes (i.e no rot) have all greatly helped to reduce the need for SO2 additions during winemaking. Today, there are many winemakers who refrain from adding any SO2 until after the fermentation is complete.
Why Sulfites Are Often Necessary in Wine
There are really very few wines that are made without some use of SO2. This is because wine is perishable, prone to oxidation and the development of aldehyde off-odors. SO2, particularly for white wines, is important for freshness. Wines without any SO2 generally have a shorter shelf life – about six months, and need to be kept in perfect storage conditions. Given that a winemaker has very little control over the wine’s storage conditions from the time the wine leaves the winery until it is consumed, it is little wonder that SO2 is so widely used to help guarantee that the bottle of wine you open will be fresh and clean, and taste as the winemaker intended.
Additionally, one of the reasons that you see more wines labeled ‘made from organically grown grapes’ than labeled ‘organic wine’ is because in the US organic wine must not have any added SO2.
Avoiding Sulfites? Some Thoughts on Sulfur-Free Wines
All that said, we are beginning to see a number of "natural" wines on the market, where little or no SO2 is added. This is a great development for the small part of the population that has an allergy to sulfites, and the biodynamic wine movement is also fascinating and positive for reasons that go far beyond the exclusion of sulfites.
As indicated earlier, leaving out sulfites is easier with red wines, because the tannin acts as a as a natural antioxidant. It also helps if natural wines are sold locally and not shipped. This local aspect of "natural" wines is part of what makes them so interesting; they're often best discovered close to their place of origin.
Sulfur-Free Wines to Try
Some sulfur-free wines to look for include:
- Catherine & Pierre Breton from the Loire. They make one wine without any SO2 addition during winemaking. 2006 Catherine & Pierre Breton Bourgueil Nuits d'Ivresse ( $26), is 100% Cabernet Franc. It is made from organically grown grapes, unsulfured and unfiltered. The label clearly states that the wine "doit être stocké en dessous de 14ºC", - a warning that the wine should be stored at below 14 degrees C (57 degrees F). Note: There is a tiny amount added before the bottling to keep the wine stable in shipping, but it is so minimal as to be undetectable in testing.
- Pierre Frick from Alsace makes a range of wines ‘sans souffre’. The 2007 Riesling and Pinot Noir wines ‘sans souffre’, are available at Chambers Street Wines in NYC (at about $22 to $24).
- Frey Vineyards, Mendocino – One of the first organic and biodynamic wineries in California. Their range include wines made without the addition of any sulfur dioxide. Organic Natural Red, NV from Mendocino is a blend of Carignan, Zinfandel and Syrah and costs only $8. Their unsulfured white Organic Natural White also, $8, is a blend of Chenin Blanc and Chardonnay.
- Domaine des Deux Ânes, in the Languedoc, is another organic wine producer using very little sulfites. I mentioned one of their wines in last week's post on the wines from the Languedoc Roussillon. Great value, delicious wines and widely available.
So Why Do I Get a Headache When I Drink Red Wine?
All of these scientific facts, however, do nothing more than say that sulfites are probably not the culprit for the well-known phenomenon of red wine headaches. Other possible reasons include, as I mentioned above, histamines, and the alcohol content itself. Here is a collection of some quotes and resources that are quite interesting on the topic:
→ Red Wine Makes Me Mean at Cup of Jo
What is your view on sulfites in wine? Do you get the dreaded red wine headaches?