The Real Deal: What Makes a Recipe Authentic?

Ask a room of people how to make chicken noodle soup, and you'll open a Pandora's box. Each person will have their own version, their own exact method, and their own claim to authenticity. So, we ask you: when we talk about an authentic recipe, what does that mean to you? What makes it not authentic? When is it ok to improvise?We think about this a lot as cooks and people who love food. We love the quest for the perfect dish - the perfect risotto, the ultimate noodle pho, the quintessential lamb curry. That moment when you finally find the ingredient you were looking for or master the technique? We live for that moment.

But improvisation is also a part of cooking. Maybe we couldn't find saffron for our paella - does that make it no longer paella? Maybe we never really liked our grandmother's meatballs and start making them differently - have we broken with tradition?

Afterall, every recipe evolved from improvisation at some point. As people moved around and environments changed, cooks all over the world had to make do with the ingredients they could find. They made little tweaks over the years until now we have a dishes like gumbo and falafel and Yorkshire pudding.

And this is all without counting the improvisation that comes when a cook is alone in the kitchen, tasting and seasoning as they go! A dish is very rarely exactly the same twice in a row.

Authenticity...what does that really mean?

Related: What Foods Do You Bring Back from Home?

(Image: Flickr member Mr.nomind licensed under Creative Commons)

14 Comments