This is the time of year when nearly every food writer and editor scratches their head, looking for something new to say about Thanksgiving. Can we spice up the turkey? Put a glaze on the pumpkin pie? Can we buff up the old standards, add a bit of shine? But all of this is largely a quixotic endeavor as you, like us, prefer to stick with the old favorites. And rightly so: the charm of Thanksgiving is its familiarity. So, to that end, here is our own rundown of Thanksgiving essentials — everything you need to start from scratch and put that masterpiece of classic cooking on the table.
There is a ritual in returning to the turkey, the mashed potatoes, and the pumpkin pie, one that centers and humbles us as cooks. Thanksgiving is not about culinary pyrotechnics; it's the struggle to cook a bird as tender as Dad's, or a pie that will never be quite as good as Grandma's. The important thing is to put the favorites on the table, and to turn them out with pleasure and not too much stress.
These are the tools and guides to help you roast your first turkey, and bake a delicious pan of stuffing. We show you how to make gravy and whip up fluffy mashed potatoes. Just the basics for a classic, traditional Thanksgiving dinner. And then, of course, because we are what we are, we couldn't resist throwing in a handful of fresh favorites, too.
THE CLASSIC ESSENTIALS
• 1 How to Cook a Turkey: The Simplest, Easiest Method
• 2 How to Make a Quick Turkey Gravy - (Bonus: How To Make Gravy Ahead)
• 3 How to Make Easy Thanksgiving Stuffing
• 4 How To Make the Best Mashed Potatoes - (Bonus: How To Make Mashed Potatoes for Just Two People)
• 5 Spiced Cranberry Sauce
• 6 Sweet Potato Soufflé
• 7 Green Bean Casserole with Mushroom Bechamel & Crispy Onions
• 8 Easy Potato Dough Rolls
THE SWEET ESSENTIALS
• 9 Ginger Pumpkin Pie with Graham Cracker Crust
• 10 Old-Fashioned Pecan Pie
A FEW FRESH FAVORITES
• 11 Thai-Style Brussels Sprouts
• 12 No-Knead Sweet Potato Dinner Rolls
• 13 Butternut Squash Tian with Herbed Bread Crumbs
• 14 Sweet Potato Gratin with Smoky Breadcrumbs
• 15 Cranberry Curd Bars with Walnut Shortbread Crust
How does this list of guides and recipes compare to your own menu? Does it look more or less the same? Or will you have a different tradition? What does Thanksgiving look like on your table?
(Images: See linked recipes for full image credits)
















Red-and-Pink-Stripe...

Thanksgiving is all about family and sharing with others, family traditions run deep. I also, like those old favorite, handed down recipes that mean comfort food.
If you don't have traditional recipes, why not start some this season? It's never to late.
A turkey, cooked a day early.
Cranberry sauce and/or relish, homemade only.
My Great Grandmother's dressing; stuffing cooking in a pan instead of the bird. Her daughter wrote the recipe down one year as it was made so we'd have her recipe.
Butternut squash casserole (a recipe my grandmother found and tried on assorted potlucks and then Thanksgiving.) She laughed through the whole meal because my Grandfather did not eat "squash" except in pies, he had three helpings and only then learned it was not sweet potatoes like he thought.
The other veggie side changes. green bean casserole or roasted veggies
Sister Schubert rolls. favorite and easy- homemade squash rolls if we were 2 only.
Pies and sometimes a birthday cake.
Pies this year are pumpkin and an adapted Apple Cider Cream
Definitely, play with your non-traditional dishes, you might find a new traditional dish. I'm attracted to all the seasonal fruits and vegetables now.
I just ran across the recipe for cranberry bread, in my grandmother's handwriting. It totally made me smile to remember the story of the bread, seeing her writing, seeing the paper it was written on & how we always have that bread on the table for Thanksgiving.
I pulled out the recipe to make for our celebration this year, the 1st one we'll have in our home.
"This is the time of year when nearly every food writer and editor scratches their head, looking for something new to say about Thanksgiving."
I always chuckle when reading these articles each year as I wonder how many hours (blood sweat & tears) were invested in them. Our Thanksgiving & Christmas menus (and even Easter, for that matter) are written in stone and God help the one who tries to change it up.
Having said that, I enjoy perusing new ideas & have adopted/adapted quite a few for *other* times of the year. That to say, I do appreciate the sweat equity involved. Not sure the stress is worth it for the writers/editors but I guess some work better under pressure & I for one would hate to miss out on all the creativity such pressure inspires.
@discerning: "...written in stone and God help the one who tries to change it up."
My sentiments exactly! Lazy weekends, summer vacation, finding a new veggie at the farmer's markets...these are occasions for experiments, crazy concoctions and adventures. Thanksgiving? Give me a turkey, some mashed potatoes and a pecan pie and I'm one happy gal.
We are big on the sides: great salads, roasted squash or sweet potatoes and Brussels sprouts, mashed potatoes, cranberry sauce, and pies. But most of my family is vegetarian, so the turkey thing, not so much. Some years there's a turkey breast (or leg) if someone is coming who will miss it. Some years we've had a salmon as a centerpiece; other years, I cringe to admit, a Tofurkey. Mostly now, we just go straight vegetarian. If you’re looking for vegetarian Thanksgiving menu ideas, some of my favorites are here!
My Thanksgiving day menu has been set in stone for years.
Kahlua Turkey, and Kahlua yams. Salad, homemade cranberry relish, stuffing.
I do vary my desserts, some form of pumpkin pie, and something chocolate. (There's usually only 3 of us, so it's a small gathering)
@Laura "Barbara" Bennett,
Please stop plugging your apron on every thanksgiving post.
Thank you.