The Kitchn's Guide to Essential Baking Pans

Setting Up a Kitchen

What are the essential tools every cook needs in the kitchen? Both new and experienced cooks can benefit from going back to the basics. The last few weeks we at The Kitchn have been compiling a list of kitchen essentials, from prep tools and utensils to cookware. Up today: our essential guide to baking pans.

As in all of our guides, we've offered a few product recommendations in each category based on personal preferences, experience, and editor and reader reviews. Most of these tools can be bought on Amazon, but a terrific and cost-effective resource for basic kitchen tools is a restaurant supply store. Just buy the best quality you can afford!

We're not done with baking just yet! Look for guides to essential small electrics and essential gadgets in the future, many of which pertain to baking.

Must Read: Metal, Glass, Ceramic, or Silicone Pans: When To Use Each - this post is a great supplementary read when understanding what pan material is suitable for your cooking and baking needs!

1. A 9" x 13" Glass, Ceramic, or Metal Baking Pan: the standard pan size, this versatile pan typically holds about 3 quarts of volume. You can also convert almost any basic cake or cupcake recipe into a 9x13 size with no major adjustments. Glass is more presentable, particularly for things like casseroles and sheet cakes, but metal is more versatile. We recommend buying this pan with a lid. It'll make it so much easier for storage and/or to transport your dish across town.

Pyrex Bakeware 9" x 13" Rectangular Baking Dish with Lid, $40 from Amazon
Nordic Ware 9" x 13" Cake Pan with Storage Lid, $16.99 from Amazon
Emile Henry Artisan Rectangular Baker, $80 from Williams-Sonoma

Related Reading: Halving Casseroles: Tips for Reducing the Size of a Recipe

2. An 8" x 8" or 9" x 9" Square Baking Pan: An 8" x 8" pan is just slightly bigger than a halved 9" x 13" pan. Great for brownies and bars.

Pyrex Grip-Rite 8-Inch Square Baking Dish, $8.12 from Amazon
Le Creuset Stoneware Square Dish, $40 from Le Creuset
Nordic Ware Square Pan with Lid, $15.99 from Amazon

3. Two Commercial-Quality Half Sheet Pans: We recommend commercial quality half sheet pans. They're more expensive, but worth it. Baking sheets are not a place to cut corners: look for heavy pans, and avoid nonstick and dark coated pans. (Why? Nonstick isn't that helpful and darker pans brown baked goods too fast.)

Nordic Ware Bakers Half Sheet, 13" x 18" x 1", $12.51 on Amazon. Read our review here.
Norpro Professional 9" x 12" Heavy Gauge Cookie Sheet, $10.94 at Amazon

4. A 9" or 10" Round Cake Pan This is a standard size for traditional layer cakes, but it's helpful for other dishes, too, like biscuits, sweet rolls, even meatballs.

Chicago Metallic Professional Nonstick 9" Round Cake Pan, $16.99 from Amazon
Pro Line Nonstick Round Cake Pan, $14.95 from Crate and Barrel
Chicago Metallic 9" x 2" Commercial II Round Cake Pan, $13.00 from Sur La Table

5. A Muffin Pan OR Paper Souffle Cups: If you like baking muffins and cupcakes often, then a muffin pan is essential. If it's an occasional treat for you, then you can probably get away with paper soufflé cups. Cheap and recyclable, just fill them with batter, line them up on a regular cookie sheet, and bake!

NordicWare Muffin Pan, $15.19 from Amazon
Souffle / Portion Cups, $3.69 for a box of 250 at Webstaurant Store

6. A 9" or 10" Pie Pan: A basic pie pan isn't just for pies: it's great for roasting a chicken or making a quiche, too! Look for extra deep pie dishes to accommodate lots of filling. Glass or ceramic is best here.

Emile Henry Pie Dish, $45 from Emily Henry
Pyrex Pie Plate Portable, $10.47 from Amazon
Nordic Ware 10" Naturals Hi-Dome Pie Pan with Lid, $13.95 from Amazon

Related Reading: Baker's Tip: Choosing the Right Pie Dish

7. A 9" x 5" Loaf Pan: You can cook everything from pound cakes t banana bread, meatloaf, and yeast breads in a standard loaf pan. Heavy and plain is best.

Farberware Bakeware 9-by-5-Inch Loaf Pan, $11.05 from Amazon
Platinum Professional Pullman Loaf Pan, $29.95 from Sur La Table

Readers, do you have anything to add?

Supplementary Essential Tools Up for Discussion
Cooling racks
An electronic scale
A French rolling pin
A pastry scraper

The Kitchn's Other 'Essentials' Guides:
The Kitchn's Guide to Essential Prep Tools & Utensils
The Kitchn's Guide to Essential Cooking Tools & Utensils
The Kitchn's Guide to Essential Cookware

12 Comments