The Best Pie Bakeoff 2008 Roundup: All 29 Pies!

A huge thank you to everyone who rolled, baked, and shared their best flaky pie doughs and best yummy fillings. All of your pies were so inspiring and delicious - we are already looking forward to next year's Bakeoff! Here's a full roundup of all 29 pies, including our five winners. If you're still looking for a Thanksgiving pie recipe, check out one of our Bakeoff entries. Happy baking, and happy Thanksgiving!

Visit us over the holiday weekend to see the things we're most thankful for, and to talk about your turkey and your leftovers.

The Entries

  1. Caramel Apple Crumb Pie
  2. Cherry Berry Pie
  3. Martha's Apple Pie
  4. Pumpkin Pie Tarts with Dark Chocolate Frosting
  5. Bean Brulee Tart
  6. Classic Apple Pie with Pâte Brisée Crust
  7. Chocolate Pecan Mini Tarts
  8. Confetti Quiche with Curry Crust
  9. Pie of the Vine
  10. Low-tech Korean Bulgogi Mini Pie
  11. Sugar and Spice Pumpkin Pie
  12. Chocolate Bourbon Truffle-Turtle Tart
  13. Pumpkin Pie Cups
  14. Quiche Oignon & Cumin
  15. Almond Cream Pie
  16. Banana Cream Pie
  17. Apple Ginger Pie Bars
  18. Buckeye Pie
  19. Candy Apple Pie
  20. Chocolate Truffle Tart with Vanilla Crème Brulee
  21. Creamy Adsuki Bean Pie
  22. Pumpple Pie (Pumpkin & Apple!)
  23. Apple Cranberry Galette with Stonewall Kitchen Apple Caramel Butter
  24. Rustic Pear Custard Pie
  25. Jack-O-Lantern Tartlets
  26. Pear Gruyère Pie
  27. Edith's Sweet Potato Pie
  28. Pecan and Date Pie
  29. Pumpkin Pie

The Winners

Here are the pies that go home with a prize. We wish we could have given everyone a prize - all of your pies were wonderful!

Best Classic Pie
by reader vote
Sugar and Spice Pumpkin Pie

Best Original Pie
by reader vote
Pie of the Vine

Most Unusual Pie
editorial pick
Bean Brulee Tart

Best Story
editorial pick
Edith's Sweet Potato Pie

Best-Looking Pie
editorial pick
Candy Apple Pie

1 Comment