Need a new, easy way for staying cool in August (and staying in touch with your inner child)? Look to the end of the rainbow for this pot–of–gold recipe! These ice cream sandwiches will make you do the happy dance and perhaps give you leprechaun–spotting powers too.
As a kid, my brother and I referred to Lucky Charms as "Saturday morning cartoon cereal." For a couple of precious hours on our special weekend day, we would lay towels on the carpet, a foot from the tube and watch our friends the Ninja Turtles, Captain Planet, Transformers and finally the Care Bears do their thing.
That sacred time was accompanied by a sweet cereal, and looking back this feels like quite a coup for us, considering the no sugar, no TV rules and regulations that governed the rest of our week. My older, far cooler brother (I mean he would be wearing his He-Man costume at breakfast; he looked rad!) would dive into his bowl of Lucky Charms with the gusto of a hound dog, reaching for his seconds before his bowl was even empty. The Ninja Turtles were powered by pizza, Nick (my bro) was determined to be rocket-fueled by this cereal.
I was slow and precise with my precious bowl of contraband cereal. More on the cloudy speed of Friendship Bear, I let my spoon frolic into the meal, prancing a few morsels into my delighted mouth every few minutes. It would take me the full two hours to finish my Lucky Charms (I only dream of such patience with food now!). Of course, I was careful to save as many of the marshmallows for the very end — my favorite part — where I'd slurp the powder pink, sugar-flavored milk, dotted with melted mallows in one final frenzy. Life was good!
Those days are long behind me (although I still sheepishly adore the Care Bears). And yet I find myself buying Lucky Charms maybe once a year. The box is still tantalizingly friendly and seductive to children and the marshmallow to cereal ratio seems to have stayed the same. They've added an extra marshmallow to the mix, similar to when M&M's added blue to their line-up. When a heat wave recently struck and a box of Charms was in my cupboard, along with marshmallows left over from camping, as well as a pint of vanilla ice cream, an idea was born.
These Lucky Charm ice cream sandwiches are outrageous. How could something that makes guests smile so much be so sinful? They are decadent, but absolutely worth the time, effort and calories. In fact, I think I've given up the bowl/milk Charm format I embraced for so many years and moved onto this new incarnation. Make extras, you'll need them.
(And by the way, if you love marshmallows as much as I do, check this out - did you know you can buy just the marshmallows?? In bulk?!)
3 tablespoons butter
1 package (10 ounces) mini marshmallows
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
1/2 teaspoon salt
4 cups Lucky Charms cereal
1 pint French vanilla ice cream
Heat butter, marshmallows, vanilla, and salt in a large pot set over medium heat. Cook down until melted, about 5 minutes, stirring continuously with a heat-proof spatula. Turn off the heat and pour in the Lucky Charms cereal, and stir with a spatula until evenly coated with marshmallow mixture. The consistency will be very thick and slightly difficult to stir. Scoop out the Lucky Charm/marshmallow mixture onto a lipped baking pan and press down into the pan, flattening as much as possible. Your hands will be very sticky, but keep pressing down hard to create an even plain of Lucky Charms.
Allow to set/rest for about 5 minutes then cut out circular shapes using a cookie cutter. You can store the "cookies" in a sealed container for a few days at this point.
To serve, smear about 1/4 to 1/3 cup ice cream between two Lucky Charm cookies, creating a sandwich.
(Best eaten while watching cartoons.)

Related: Playing Around: 5 Takes on Rice Krispie Treats
(Originally published August 11, 2011)
(Images: Leela Cyd Ross l styling: Kirsten Neiman)





Colorful Kitchen Bo...

Comments (31)
These are wrong -- and I would never make or eat them -- but they are really cute, and they do make me laugh.
I'd opt for any cereal other than nasty lucky charms. Maybe cocoa crispies.
If these are wrong, I don't want to be right.
Ice cream covered in marshmallows covered in marshmallows?
I like me some sweets, but this is enough to make me even gag a bit! Plus the cereal is bigger and wouldn't form as stable a rice krispie treat type thing. One bite and it would go everywhere.
the mere fact that creating these treats connected you to such a fond childhood memory is reason enough to make these. i shared similar mornings with my brother watching sat. morning cartoons - thanks for bringing that back for me. the ice cream sandwich idea might also be good with the cake batter rice krispie treat which i'm dying to make with my nephew :) thx again for sharing.
Some of you are crazy, this recipe was so fantastic I registered today just to say so. Also because the rest of this site is pretty awesome too.
I've been passing this recipe along to a lot of my friends and they love it too. I'm even going to make some today, thanks for the idea!
Oh my gosh! This is all about sweet childhood memories! Wonderful story - wish all the above understood this! Beautiful pictures too!
Why be a hater? Don't like the preservatives or the processed sugar? Don't make it! Leela shared a cute story and a cute recipe. Not interested, then move on! Don't be so negative!
Yay! Lucky Charms was my favorite childhood cereal that I almost never got to eat. These look awesome :)
these comments are hilarious! not into processed sugar, and want it all natural, just sub in the natural version of lucky charms, because seriously, i once doubted the glory that is this desert, and upon my first bite i was transformed into a drooling ball of happy. GREAT PHOTOS TOO! love it!
i want this so bad, and i want to force feed it to all the nay-sayers until they submit to its awesomeness.
Alpha bits! Do they still make Alpha Bits? I'll be sad if they don't.
My inner child is drooling. Heck, my adult self is, too! These are THE AWESOME!!!!
YUM! Lucky Charms was my favorite as a kid too. (ok...they still are) I'm pretty sure I would love this even without the ice cream. :)
to all the lucky charm haters: were you never children? i mean honestly: who talks smack about sugar cereal that involves horseshoes and clovers? who doesn't love a pot of gold at the end of a rainbow or a fat little leprechaun? maybe you should all eat one of these ice-cream-charm sandos. they might just change you from haters to lovers. leela you rock.
NicodemusBC, I once made this sort of cookie with Cocoa Crispies, and the only reason I've never done it again is that washing the marshmallow pan annoys me. As cheerful junk food, the chocolate cereal WORKS. One can also throw in a few chocolate chips and nuts for texture. (Can you tell I'm thinking of doing this again?)
You know what would make this even more amazing? Making the sandwiches with Christina Tosi's Cereal Milk Ice Cream from Momofuku Milk Bar.
I need to make these this weekend with Cocoa Crispies or I. WILL. DIE.
I'm usually a natural, health food advocate too, but I saw this recipe and thought "I HAVE to make these". It brought up the childhood memories for me too. Thanks for sharing! Everything in moderation, right?
I can't wait to make these. Excellent recipe, thanks or sharing!!
And for all you anti-sugar and preservative types, GET OVER IT!
It just goes to show that we "enlightened" parents were raised on some pretty and awful stuff--and loved it! Ah sweet memories!
The other day I topped an ice cream cone with the $1.99 version of Lucky Charms- known as Marshmallow Mateys (which is nautical/pirate themed AARGH)- in lieu of sprinkles, and it was great. I actually think the cheap-o version might be tastier than the big brand.
If I may suggest something: maybe one could line the cups in a muffin pan with greased wax paper and press a layer of cereal-marshmallow mixture into it to form the circular shape.
Wow! I can't believe the vitriol. This is a playful sweet treat that should make anyone smile and I've just spent the last five minutes dreaming up riffs on this recipe - captain crunch, sugar smacks, reese's puffs, cinnamon toast crunch, cheerios (frosted, honey nut, regular); OMG the list goes on and on. You could even crush the cereal up a bit to make it easier to bit into or use it to coat the edge of the ice cream. Thank you, thank you, thank you!
I love this colorful take on both cereal-based cookie treats & ice cream sandwiches. A definite smile inducer.
I just don't get Lucky Charms...they taste gross to me, always have. Substitute Trix, though, and I'm there! I think it is the extra artificial color that makes them so good.
STONER'S DELIGHT.
also, wax paper or a good coat of cooking spray (inside the pot, on the spatula and baking sheet) will make clean-up easy.
OMG, best idea ever. I have been meaning to make treats w/ my chocolate Cheerios forever, but this is the answer to my childrens' dreams. I have only ever allowed Lucky Charms and its ilk as "dessert," and we call all it "yucky cereal" with a fond smile, but such sin has to be part of childhood!!! thanks for the recipe.
I made these with my daughter because we both love Lucky Charms, and I also used the store brand and it was delicious! Next time, I'd try to make the lucky charms layers thinner because I could barely get my mouth around the sandwich, but other than that, it was great!
Also, as someone else said, what's with all the haters? Does nobody subscribe to the "everything in moderation" theory?
And, I know I'm getting picky and borderline mean here, but michelejm, if you're going to insult the staff at the Kitchn, you could at least spell their name right!
I know this recipe was posted a while ago, but I just had to comment and say that these photos are gorrrgeous.
Also, @ditherthither - I, too, LOVE Marshmallow Mateys. It almost seems like sacrilege, because I loved Lucky Charms as a kid - but I think Marshmallow Mateys are better. The texture of the cereal bits is superior.
Leela, I'm making these to take to a clothing swap tomorrow. Can't wait to try them!
Wonderful post!!